Five of the AP Top 7 went down on the same Saturday, and the poll was blown wide open. The result was a brand-new No. 1, a reshuffled top tier, and a few heavyweight programs left to pick up the pieces after one of the wildest weekends the sport has seen in a while.
Miami came through the chaos untouched. It took double overtime and one highly controversial last play, but the Hurricanes did what so many others couldn’t: they survived Florida State. Even without facing a ranked opponent yet this season at the time of play, Miami’s spotless record and the carnage around it pushed the pollsters to give the Hurricanes 40 first-place votes and the No. 1 spot for the first time since 2002.
Right behind them, BYU delivered one of the statement wins of the year. Bear Bachmeier put together a complete night, throwing for a touchdown, running for two more, and even catching a score in No.
8 BYU’s stunning upset of No. 2 Notre Dame.
The Cougars jumped to No. 2 for the first time since the school’s 1984 national championship season, and they also gave the Big 12 a major boost. The league now has a real path to getting two teams into the College Football Playoff, with Texas Tech looking like the other candidate after a confident dismantling of Arizona State.
That sets up a very real possibility of a Big 12 title game between Texas Tech and BYU, with playoff spots more or less in hand.
In the Big Ten’s marquee matchup, Ohio State stopped Indiana’s 22-game winning streak with a 19-15 grind. The Buckeyes entered the day with one loss and badly needed to avoid another in Bloomington, and they managed that.
But the win came with a major concern: quarterback Julian Sayin left with a throwing-shoulder injury, and the timing could hardly be worse with USC and Nebraska on the road and Oregon and Michigan coming to Columbus. Jeremiah Smith can do just about everything a receiver can do, but even he needs a quarterback capable of getting him the ball.
That remains an open question now.
Tennessee also made a loud case to be taken seriously. The Vols leaned on defense, running the ball, and takeaways in a 24-point showing against Alabama that felt like a turning point.
DeSean Bishop ran for 159 yards and two touchdowns, Tennessee forced four turnovers, and the defense held Alabama to just 10 points and 2 yards per carry. The reward was a jump to No. 11, while Alabama fell seven spots to No. 13 after back-to-back losses.
With more production from the quarterback spot, Tennessee suddenly looks capable of making noise in both the SEC and the playoff race.
Florida had a completely different kind of breakthrough. Backup quarterback Tramell Jones Jr., in his first career start, threw two touchdown passes as the Gators erased a 14-point deficit and beat No.
7 Texas 27-24 in Austin. Florida’s defense was just as important.
It sacked Arch Manning five times, forced a late fumble that sealed the win, and held Texas to 173 passing yards in what was a striking turnaround for a secondary that had been the SEC’s worst coming in. The Gators snapped a two-game skid, picked up their first road win over a top-10 opponent since 2012, and returned to the AP poll at No.
- Texas slid 12 spots to No.
Then came the biggest jolt of all: Auburn took down No. 1 Georgia.
Unranked and trailing by two touchdowns early, the Tigers scored 24 straight points and finished the upset with Alex McPherson’s 34-yard field goal as time expired. Byrum Brown rushed for 115 yards and a touchdown, while Georgia coughed it up three times, including a costly late fumble by Gunner Stockton.
The win snapped Georgia’s streaks against Auburn and unranked teams and gave new coach Alex Golesh a major lift. Georgia, which had just climbed to No. 1 after an emotional win at Alabama, looked worn down.
Kirby Smart had admitted the Bulldogs might have been spent, and the performance matched that concern. Favored by more than three touchdowns at home, Georgia tied the game with under three minutes left, then fumbled near midfield and watched Auburn set up the winning kick.
The Bulldogs dropped to No. 5 after one week at the top.
And then there was Texas. The loss to Florida brought the criticism of Arch Manning right back to the surface, the same questions that followed him since he was a high school recruit and people wondered whether his ranking had more to do with the name on the back of the jersey.
Steve Sarkisian made it clear changes could be coming. “Everything is going to be evaluated,” he said.
“Everything means everything.” At this point, Manning has been evaluated.
He looks like a very average quarterback.
In Other News...
Miami Is 6-0 But One Midseason Concern Won't Go Away
Miami has kept rolling to a 6-0 start and stays firmly in the national conversation, but the unbeaten record has not erased every concern around this team. Even with quarterback Darian Mensah and receiver Malachi Toney delivering standout play, the Hurricanes have had to navigate injuries and uneven stretches that have kept the week-to-week picture from feeling entirely settled.
The biggest issue continues to hover around the offensive front and the running back group, both of which have been affected by injuries and in turn put more pressure on the rest of the offense. On defense, Miami has been sturdy against the run, but the challenge has been clear against mobile quarterbacks and in pass protection, which leaves a real midseason question for a team with bigger goals than just staying undefeated. [Read more 🡒]
Miamis Florida State Win Exposed Who Carried The Canes
Miamis win over Florida State offered a pretty clear snapshot of which Hurricanes players drove the result and which ones left some questions behind. The breakdown leaned on both eye test and Pro Football Focus grades, giving a fuller view of who stacked up in the matchup and who struggled to match the moment in a game that had plenty of physical play and a few injury concerns along the way.
The comparison also surfaced some interesting gaps between what stood out live and what showed up in the grading. A handful of players landed near the top of both lists, while others were viewed much less favorably once the film and the numbers were lined up, leaving a useful if imperfect picture of how Miami got through one of its biggest games and which performances helped carry the Canes. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Can End Notre Dame's Playoff Dream With One More Loss
Miamis rise to No. 1 in the latest AP Top 25 poll has only sharpened the spotlight on what comes next, and Notre Dame is walking into that matchup with plenty on the line. The Irish were already dealing with the sting of a close loss to BYU, a game that ended amid controversy and prompted the Atlantic Coast Conference to announce a review of the officiating at the finish.
Now the schedule has put Notre Dame in a spot where another loss could make its College Football Playoff path far more complicated, even with the expanded 12-team field. For Miami, it is another chance to reinforce its place at the top. For Notre Dame, it is the kind of game that can either steady a season or push the margin for error almost to nothing. [Read more 🡒]