Kirk Herbstreit is not backing away from his preseason national title pick on Notre Dame just yet, but after five weeks, he’s clearly widening the lens.
On his Nonstop podcast with former Ohio State receiver Joey Galloway, the ESPN analyst said the Fighting Irish still deserve scrutiny, then pointed to Miami, Georgia and Alabama as the programs he’d place in the same conversation for the sport’s top team.
“Because for me, it feels like the two best teams right now, I would put Miami in that discussion. I would put Georgia in that discussion.
I would put Alabama in that discussion. They're actually playing each other this weekend,” Herbstreit said.
He then pushed Galloway on whether Notre Dame and Texas still belonged near the top. “Would you put Notre Dame right now in that discussion, even though they haven't been tested? Would you put Texas in that discussion, even though they're the number one team in the country?”
Galloway, who also had Notre Dame winning it all before the season, didn’t jump off the bandwagon. “I don't feel as good about Notre Dame as I did when we began the season.
That doesn't mean I feel bad about them. That means I don't feel as good,” he said.
The Irish are 5-0 and ranked No. 3 in the AP poll, but the skepticism comes from the schedule. Notre Dame has handled Wisconsin, Rice, Michigan State and Purdue by a combined 169-33, then survived its closest test with a 37-26 win at North Carolina. CJ Carr has been sharp through the first month, completing 88 of 124 passes for 1,197 yards with 13 touchdowns and one interception.
The numbers beneath the surface still paint Notre Dame in a strong light. The Irish sit first nationally in net expected points added per play, a measure adjusted for opponent, home field and garbage time, and sixth in adjusted defense. Texas is third in adjusted defense, but only 49th on offense.
Notre Dame gets Stanford at home Saturday before heading to No. 8 BYU on Oct. 17.
Herbstreit’s latest comments came after Miami’s 41-13 rout at Clemson on Oct. 3, a result that left the No. 4 Hurricanes alone atop the ACC at 5-0 overall and 3-0 in league play. Darian Mensah passed for 227 yards and a touchdown, added a 34-yard scoring run, and Mark Fletcher Jr. rushed for 77 yards and two touchdowns as Miami piled up a 192-55 edge on the ground.
The Hurricanes are sixth nationally in adjusted offensive efficiency, and they’ll also get Notre Dame later this season. Miami visits South Bend on Nov. 7, one year after beating the Irish 27-24 in the 2025 opener and claiming the final at-large playoff spot over them.
Georgia has built its own case with points, plenty of them. The No.
2 Bulldogs are 5-0 and 3-0 in the SEC, and their 257 points through five games are just one shy of the 1910 team’s program record for that span. They knocked off Oklahoma 41-13 and Vanderbilt 38-14, with Gunner Stockton throwing for 295 yards and three touchdowns against the Commodores.
Even so, the underlying metrics are less flattering. Georgia’s net efficiency rank sits at 31st nationally, and its adjusted defense is 67th, the weakest profile of the four teams Herbstreit mentioned. Two weeks into the season, Herbstreit was blunt about the Bulldogs: “We don't know anything about Georgia.”
Alabama has also surged into the mix. The No.
6 Crimson Tide are 5-0 and 3-0 in the SEC, and they’ve scored at least 49 points in each of their last three games. That stretch ended with a 56-23 win at No.
16 Mississippi State, where Keelon Russell threw three touchdown passes and ran for another. After that performance, Paul Finebaum called Alabama college football’s most complete team.
The Crimson Tide’s profile backs up the buzz. They rank second nationally in net efficiency and ninth in adjusted defense.
Now the spotlight turns to Saturday night’s showdown in Tuscaloosa. Georgia visits Alabama at 7:30 p.m.
ET on ABC from Bryant-Denny Stadium. The teams split two meetings last season, with Alabama winning 24-21 in Athens and Georgia taking the SEC Championship Game 28-7.
In Other News...
Malachi Toneys Viral Clemson Moment Has Miami Fans Debating The Coverage
After Miamis win over Clemson, wide receiver Malachi Toney found himself at the center of a moment that had little to do with the scoreboard and plenty to do with how it was framed afterward. Toneys postgame hug with Dabo Swinney stood out as a simple show of sportsmanship, and the clip quickly spread well beyond the usual reach of a victory recap.
What followed was a different kind of conversation, with Miami fans focusing on the sideline reporters comments as much as the exchange itself. The reaction also pulled old memories back into the picture, including previous criticism of ESPN reporter Holly Rowe during college football coverage, turning one brief postgame scene into a wider debate about how these moments get covered. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Has An Early Edge In A Recruitment Fans Will Watch Closely
Brysen Wrights upcoming trip to Coral Gables is another reminder that Miami has already done a lot of the early work in one of the most closely watched recruiting races in the country. The No. 1 prospect in the 2028 class is set to be on campus Oct. 17 for the Florida State game, giving the Hurricanes another chance to impress a recruit who has already been around the program multiple times more than any other school.
Miamis position has drawn notice beyond the usual recruiting chatter, including praise from Wrights father, but the competition is far from settled. Florida, Texas and Ohio State are still in the mix, which is why this visit matters so much for Miami as it tries to turn an early edge into something sturdier as the process continues. [Read more 🡒]
Malachi Toney Is Still Producing But Miami Has A Real Concern
Malachi Toney kept working against Clemson even as the Tigers made him earn everything, with cornerback Ashton Hampton helping keep the Miami receiver in check. He still finished with five catches for 40 yards, a line that fit the kind of day it was for the Hurricanes' passing game, but it also underscored how central Toney has become to Miamis offense even while hes clearly not at full strength.
Miami heads into the bye week with a few key players banged up, and Toney is one of the names worth watching most closely. He has continued to put up strong numbers on the season, but the reduced speed he showed against Clemson adds another layer to the Hurricanes' injury picture, especially with the stretch run approaching and the offense needing him to keep drawing attention every week. [Read more 🡒]