Sean Payton apparently took Miami’s 70-20 beatdown of the Broncos personally.
That game, which the Dolphins won on September 24th, 2023, is still a fresh memory for Miami fans. For Denver, it was the kind of night that can linger. Since then, the two franchises have moved in very different directions - Denver was an ankle injury to quarterback Bo Nix away from making last year’s Super Bowl, while Miami has started another rebuild attempt this offseason.
According to an ESPN report by Seth Wickersham on Tuesday morning, Payton’s response to that humiliation may have been even more dramatic than the scoreline. The Broncos head coach allegedly mulled a plan to step aside at the start of the 2024 season so Denver could hire Bill Belichick, then recently separated from New England, and chase down Don Shula’s NFL wins record in the process.
Shula still sits atop the league’s all-time coaching wins list with 347 victories. Belichick is second with 333, 14 shy of the mark.
Wickersham wrote that Payton considered pitching Broncos owner Greg Penner on a setup in which Belichick would coach Denver until he reached 15 more wins, enough to pass Shula’s total. Payton would have temporarily shifted into the assistant head coach role and handled the offense before returning to the top job once the record fell.
“When Belichick and the Patriots divorced in 2024, Payton considered presenting Broncos owner Greg Penner a proposal for the ages: Hire Belichick as head coach until he reached 15 wins, enough to break Don Shula’s career record of 347. Payton would temporarily step down to assistant head coach and run the offense, then move back after Belichick became the all-time leader. In the end, it was too complicated - and maybe too fanciful.”
The whole thing never got off the ground. Belichick didn’t land another NFL head coaching job and instead took over at the University of North Carolina ahead of the 2025 college season. He went 4-8 in his first year with the Tar Heels.
So the revenge plot stayed just that - a plot. Shula remains the winningest coach in NFL history, Belichick is entering his second season at North Carolina, and Payton is still trying to steer Denver toward a Super Bowl before the Broncos hand out a big-money extension to Nix.
In Other News...
Former Dolphins Draft Bust Found An Unexpected Second Act In Football
Michael Egnews NFL run with Miami never came close to matching the expectations that came with a third-round pick in 2012. The former tight end managed only seven catches over two seasons before his time with the Dolphins ended, a quick and disappointing chapter that could have been the whole story.
Instead, Egnew found a second act in coaching, and it has taken root in Columbia, Missouri, where he has helped build Father Tolton High School into a far more competitive program. Since taking over in 2019, the team has climbed from a 1-9 season in 2020 to an 11-1 finish in 2023, capped by a conference championship, with Egnew stressing hard work and a winning standard along the way. [Read more 🡒]
Former Steelers Tight End Suddenly Draws New AFC Buzz
Jonnu Smiths name is back in the AFC conversation after a strong run with Miami reminded teams what he can still bring to an offense. The former Dolphins Pro Bowler was one of the more productive tight ends in the league during his 2024 season in South Florida, a sharp contrast to the quieter year he had the season before, when his role and production dipped after leaving Miami.
For the Dolphins, Smiths market matters because it reinforces how valuable that Miami stretch was in reshaping his reputation around the league. A recent CBS Sports link to Denver reflects the kind of attention he can still draw when teams are looking for help at tight end, and it also says plenty about how his name now sits in the AFC mix as clubs search for a reliable answer at a position that has not produced enough. [Read more 🡒]