Florida State left Hard Rock Stadium with the same record it arrived with, but not the same conversation.
The Seminoles’ double-overtime loss to No. 3 Miami hardly changed the standings, yet it may have changed the temperature around Mike Norvell. After a week in which his future looked as shaky as it has all season, FSU played with enough fight on Saturday night to make a coaching change feel less urgent, at least for the moment.
That matters because the noise around Norvell had gotten loud after last week’s loss to Louisville. With Florida State mired in another disappointing season, some were already treating his exit like a formality, even with a buyout that remains a major obstacle.
But against Miami, the Seminoles didn’t look like a team checked out on its coach. They looked invested, energized and stubborn.
They also came heartbreakingly close to flipping the whole story.
Florida State went toe-to-toe with one of the nation’s best teams and pushed the rivalry game into double overtime before falling 43-35. For a program searching for signs of life, that was enough to keep the season from feeling completely flatlined. It may not have saved the year, but it gave Norvell something he badly needed: evidence that his team is still willing to run through a wall for him.
That has been a recurring theme during his tenure. When the pressure builds, his teams have often responded with their best effort, and Saturday fit that pattern.
Few outside the locker room expected FSU to hang with a top-three opponent, much less push it to the wire. Instead, the Seminoles gave themselves a real shot at a season-defining upset.
Still, the criticism isn’t going anywhere.
The biggest frustration remains the same one that surfaced after the Louisville loss: Florida State left points on the field. Twice inside the Miami 5-yard line, the Seminoles came away empty on failed fourth-down tries. The decisions reflected Norvell’s aggressive style and his belief in his play-calling, but they also fed a familiar complaint.
At some point, taking the points matters.
In a game that needed two overtime periods, those six points became impossible to ignore. That’s why the postgame what-ifs kept piling up.
What if Florida State kicked the field goals? What if it forced Miami to chase?
What if one call had changed everything and delivered the biggest win of the Norvell era?
None of those answers exist. What does exist is a 3-4 team heading back to Tallahassee with an ugly road losing streak still in place. But the next stretch does offer a path forward.
FSU has a bye week before Clemson comes to town on Halloween. Then comes a run of games against Pitt, Boston College, NC State and Florida. The Seminoles still have a real shot to climb back toward .500 and keep bowl hopes alive, and Saturday’s showing against Miami suggests they can at least walk into the Clemson game believing they belong on the field.
That’s why a move now would feel premature.
This isn’t a case for giving Norvell a free pass. The results still have to change, and Florida State will be judged by wins and losses just like everyone else. But after watching the Seminoles fight Miami for four quarters and two overtimes, there’s enough reason to let the season keep unfolding before making a final call.
Norvell is still under pressure. One fierce effort doesn’t wash away months of frustration.
But it did show something important: Florida State is still playing for him. Whether that turns into wins over the final stretch is another question entirely.
For now, though, the performance in Miami likely bought him what he needed most - time.
In Other News...
Dolphins Kicking Decision Just Got More Complicated Than Fans Expected
The Dolphins spent time sorting through the kicking market this summer, and the picture has only gotten murkier. Justin Tucker was reinstated to the NFL in late July after serving a 10-game suspension for violating the leagues personal conduct policy, then went through workouts with the Jets, Saints, Colts and Dolphins as teams weighed whether to bring him in.
Miamis path at the position appears to be moving in a different direction, with Zane Gonzalez now part of the conversation after a career that has included several signings and releases. He most recently landed a one-year deal with the Dolphins for the 2026 season, a move that gives the team another layer to its kicking plans as the Tucker situation continues to linger in the background. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins Fans Should Watch This Jaguars Trade Rumor Closely
Brian Thomas Jr. has become a name worth tracking far beyond Jacksonville, especially for a Dolphins team that has been searching for more help at wide receiver. The Jaguars young pass catcher has seen his role and production dip under the current coaching staff, and that downturn has only added fuel to the trade speculation around him. Miami, with its need for more talent at the position and a roster-building history that has leaned toward similar types of players, keeps coming up as a possible fit.
Jacksonvilles general manager has tried to tamp down the rumor mill, insisting the chatter is not driving the teams decisions. Still, Thomas reduced target share and the fact that his contract situation is getting closer to a pressure point make this the kind of situation that can linger, even when the public stance says otherwise. For Dolphins fans, the appeal is obvious, and so is the uncertainty, because a player like Thomas is exactly the sort of target that can move from speculation to something more serious quickly. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins Kicker Decision Just Added To Miamis Growing Questions
The Dolphins are adding another layer to an already uneasy early-season picture by bringing in Zane Gonzalez after a workout that also included Justin Tucker, pending a physical. For a team trying to steady itself after an 0-5 start, even the kicker decision has become part of the larger conversation around where Miami goes next and how it can start correcting course.
Jeff Hafley said the team is self-evaluating and considering adjustments, a comment that fits the mood around the building as the losses pile up. Tuckers presence in the workout drew attention because of his experience, but the broader takeaway is that Miami is still sorting through options at a position that can swing close games while the rest of the roster searches for answers. [Read more 🡒]