Florida State is heading into the kind of stretch that can reshape the conversation around Mike Norvell in a hurry.
At 2-2, the Seminoles have only beaten FCS Central Arkansas - the head coach’s alma mater - and New Mexico State in a shaky Week 0 showing. The Labor Day loss to SMU, with the power outage layered on top of the result, did little for Norvell’s national standing. The Alabama game, though, at least hinted that the offense is moving in the right direction, even if only a little.
Now the schedule tightens fast. Virginia comes to Tallahassee this week, and Florida State is a 2.5-point home underdog.
The Cavs already showed they can be a problem, beating Florida State in double overtime at home on a Friday night on their way to becoming one of college football’s biggest surprises in 2025. After that, it’s Louisville, then rival Miami, and then a bye.
A decision on Norvell may not arrive by month’s end, but the pressure and the storylines are building right now. And at this point, it is not a foregone conclusion that Norvell will be fired.
All of this is happening while Florida State’s athletic department is in the middle of a wider shakeup. After the firing of athletic director Michael Alford, the school is doing more than just hiring a replacement. It is rethinking what the department should look like in a college sports landscape that keeps changing under everyone’s feet.
Board of trustees chairman Peter Collins has taken on a bigger role in athletics, and he and school president Rick McCullough announced Alford’s firing. They were also the ones who last year kept Norvell in place to avoid paying a buyout that is now listed at $46.7 million.
That kind of trustee involvement says plenty about where the sport is headed, and it can also make things messy. North Carolina’s search that led to Bill Belichick is one example, with sources indicating there were essentially two searches running at once and the one that landed the eight-time Super Bowl champion ultimately won out.
Florida State has also been positioning itself for the next wave in college sports. Many in the industry believe the end of the decade could bring another major realignment moment, and the Seminoles have spent the last couple of years leaning into private capital and private equity conversations.
The school is also trying to reshape what an athletic director actually does. That role used to center on building facilities, raising money the old-fashioned way and working the room.
The next version may look far more like a Fortune 500 CEO.
That vision ties into the bigger questions around Florida State’s place in the sport. In a 2023 board of trustees meeting, former Seminoles quarterback and then-trustee Drew Weatherford said, "It's not a matter of if we leave [the ACC], but how and when we leave."
Another trustee pushed for that exit to happen within a year. Weatherford is now the founding partner of a private capital firm.
As Florida State continues to think about life beyond the ACC, it is also chasing membership in the Association of American Universities and pumping nearly $500 million into research efforts to improve its standing, especially with an eye toward the Big Ten if that ever becomes a real possibility.
Florida State is not alone in trying to modernize. Clemson, Kentucky, Michigan State, Texas Tech and West Virginia have all been moving to commercialize their athletic departments in different ways. At the simplest level, that means bundling the revenue-generating pieces of the department into one structure and separating them from the older-school side of athletic administration.
Behind the scenes, another name keeps surfacing if Norvell’s tenure ends: Jimbo Fisher. Sources told CBS Sports that former players with real influence are lobbying FSU officials on Fisher’s behalf, and the push from Fisher’s side is described as very real.
His appeal is obvious from a financial standpoint. He would likely come cheaper than other candidates, which matters for an athletic department still sorting itself out.
A coach with his experience and track record would normally command at least $10 million, and that is considered a low-end estimate. The thinking is straightforward: if Fisher takes less, the school could put more money into his assistants or roster.
Whether that idea has any traction with school leadership is another matter. Right now, it is described as a far-fetched possibility.
There is precedent for bringing back a former coach, though. West Virginia, UCF and Rutgers have all done it in recent years.
Norvell, meanwhile, has been trying to win in a financial setup that does not exactly match the competition around him. Sources say Florida State is working with roster spending somewhere between $23 million and $30 million this season, while Miami is operating in the upper $40 million range. The Seminoles are being asked to keep pace with Miami’s kind of budget while working with something closer to NC State’s.
A lot of that gap traces back to administrative disorder and a structure that has not kept up in a revenue-driven sport. Florida State also appears to have misread how the first revenue-sharing cap would play out, initially believing other schools would stay within the $20.5 million limit and that enforcement from the college sports commission would be strict. That view was not unique in the sport, but it has left the Seminoles behind on the field.
Industry sources told CBS Sports there is still a path for Norvell to keep his job. But wins matter, and that is why the next few weeks carry so much weight.
In Other News...
Dolphins Defense Is Getting Healthier As One Return Could Matter Most
The Dolphins are starting to get a little healthier on defense, and the timing matters as the season starts to settle in. Cornerback Storm Duck is back at practice as he works his way off the Reserve/Physically Unable to Perform list, while rookie defensive lineman Trey Moore remains on injured reserve with an ankle injury but is still expected back at some point this season.
Perhaps the most encouraging update comes with Kenneth Grant, who has been out since training camp with a foot and ankle injury. The defensive lineman is progressing well and could be close to a return to practice as early as Week 5, a development that could give Miami a needed boost up front if his recovery continues on schedule. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins May Finally Be Seeing Hope From Two Young Linemen
After another loss to Kansas City dropped Miami to 0-3, the spotlight again landed on an offensive line that has spent much of the early season trying to settle itself. There were still mixed grades to sort through, but rookie left guard Kadyn Proctor and second-year right guard Jonah Savaiinaea gave the Dolphins something they have not had enough of lately: a couple of young linemen trending in the right direction.
Proctor, in particular, showed cleaner work in pass protection and even turned in a key block on a touchdown run, the kind of detail that tends to matter more as the games pile up. Miamis line also kept the Chiefs from recording a sack, which does not erase the bigger issues, but it does at least offer a small sign that the unit may be finding a foothold with two of its youngest pieces. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins May Have A Tough Zach Sieler Decision Coming
The Dolphins have a decision looming with Zach Sieler, and it is the kind that can say a lot about where a team believes it stands. Sieler has been a steady part of Miamis defensive front in recent seasons, even if he has not gotten to the quarterback for a sack this year, and that track record is part of why he is drawing attention as the trade market begins to take shape.
Chicago is one team reportedly eyeing help on the defensive line as it tries to bolster its playoff push, which puts Miami in an awkward spot. Moving Sieler would mean giving up a dependable veteran and hoping the return in draft assets justifies it, while keeping him would signal the Dolphins still value depth and experience on a unit that could use both. The kind of offer that lands in the middle may end up being the real test. [Read more 🡒]