The Dolphins have a kicker decision staring them in the face, and after Zane Gonzalez’s latest miss, the answer feels pretty straightforward.
One day after Gonzalez missed a second field goal in as many weeks, Miami head coach Jeff Hafley said he and GM Jon-Eric Sullivan still hadn’t settled on a direction at the position. But Gonzalez has already used up his three practice squad elevations with Miami, which means he can’t kick for the team again in 2026 unless the Dolphins sign him to the active roster.
That makes this less of a debate and more of a choice the Dolphins need to make now.
Gonzalez’s two misses came at moments that mattered. One came in the fourth quarter against the New England Patriots in Week 8, when the miss kept Miami two scores back. The other came on the final play of the first half, denying the Dolphins a chance to go into halftime tied 6-6.
After the game and again Monday, Hafley made the point plainly: the Dolphins have to make those kicks.
Sure, both makes might still have left Miami short in the final result. But this team doesn’t have much room to waste chances, especially against quality opponents when the game is still hanging around.
The bigger argument for moving on is simpler than that. Miami should treat the kicking spot the same way it’s treating the rest of the roster: as a place to keep looking, keep testing, and keep trying to get better. This season has been about auditions for veteran additions and development for draft picks, so why stop there?
Gonzalez has had a solid NFL career, but the Dolphins should be aiming higher for 2027 and getting a look at someone with more upside now.
They’ve already worked out other kickers this season, and one name stands out: Lucas Havrisik. Hafley and Sullivan know him, and he’s shown enough to be interesting.
In three games with the Green Bay Packers in 2025, he went 4-for-4 on field goals, including a long of 61 yards. Before that, he played nine games for the Rams in 2023 and made 15 of 20 tries.
Another option is Tanner Brown, who has never kicked in the NFL but went 25-for-28 for Louisville of the UFL this year and hit from 60 yards. Brown was also among the kickers who tried out for Miami this season.
Why not take a swing on one of the younger, unproven options?
The current setup hasn’t exactly been rock solid.
And the same kind of question hangs over punter Bradley Pinion, whose 25-yard shank helped set up a Detroit field goal in the second quarter. Miami has already brought in punters for tryouts too, so that spot could be in play as well.
Still, the Pinion situation is a tougher one because he’s already on the 53-man roster. With Gonzalez, the decision is cleaner: either replace him or clear a spot on the 53 to keep him around.
In Other News...
Chop Robinson Is Giving Dolphins Fans A Very Intriguing Problem
Chop Robinson has already turned a limited sample into one of the more interesting development stories on Miamis defense. The Dolphins edge rusher has been productive when he gets after the quarterback, piling up 30 total pressures on 166 pass rushes and showing the kind of burst that can change a game even without a huge workload.
The wrinkle for Miami is simple: there have not been many chances to unleash him. Because opponents have thrown so little against the Dolphins this season, Robinsons opportunities have been capped, but the production is loud enough to make you wonder what it could look like if his role grows. For a defense always looking for more disruption off the edge, that is the kind of problem worth having. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins Put A Frustrating Problem At The Center Of Their Lions Loss
Penalties ended up sitting at the center of Miamis loss to the Lions, and head coach Jeff Hafley made it clear afterward that the Dolphins made life harder on themselves than Detroit did. The flags repeatedly put the offense behind the chains and chipped away at any chance to settle into a rhythm, turning a competitive game into one where Miami kept having to dig out of avoidable mistakes.
Hafleys frustration was rooted in how familiar the problem felt, because the Dolphins have seen this kind of self-inflicted damage before and know it can wreck a game plan fast. With the margin in the AFC so thin, the message coming out of the loss was less about one bad night and more about a habit Miami cannot afford to let linger if it wants to stay on track. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins Should Be Careful Judging Malik Willis Right Now
Malik Willis remains the Dolphins starting quarterback for the 2023 season, even as some fans have pushed for a change. The bigger picture around his first year in Miami is less about a quick verdict and more about the circumstances he has been asked to navigate, from a weak supporting cast to the general uncertainty that comes with a team still trying to sort out its long-term direction.
Miamis front office is clearly treating Willis as a possible answer beyond this season, but that does not mean the evaluation is finished or simple. With injuries and roster questions hanging over the offense, the Dolphins are left weighing what they have seen against what they still need to see, all while knowing the next turn could come through the draft, free agency, or a different answer altogether. [Read more 🡒]