The Miami Dolphins are staring at a draft position nobody in South Florida wanted to imagine this early, and the bigger surprise might be the name most mock drafts keep tying to that pick.
Ten weeks into the season, Miami sits in a tie with the Tennessee Titans and Los Angeles Chargers for the NFL’s worst record at 1-8. The New York Jets are close behind at 2-8, and they’ve already lost to the Dolphins once this year. The two teams meet again Nov. 29 in South Florida, while Miami and Los Angeles are set to square off in Week 16 in a game with major draft implications.
For now, the draft conversation starts with Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith, the consensus top player in April’s class. If Miami ends up at No. 1 overall, Smith would make plenty of sense, especially after the Dolphins gave quarterback Malik Willis a three-year deal worth $67.5 million this offseason. Pairing Willis with a Heisman front-runner at receiver would be the cleanest path on paper.
But there’s another layer here. With the top quarterback prospects in play, it’s hard to imagine general manager Jon-Eric Sullivan passing on a passer if Miami gets the chance.
And even that may be too neat a scenario, because the Dolphins are not currently slotted for No. 1.
After Week 10, they’re projected for the No. 3 pick because tiebreakers and their league-worst strength of schedule have pushed them there.
That leaves the Dolphins in the middle of a draft board that could still swing plenty before January. So what are the experts saying? A lot of them are pointing Miami toward a quarterback.
Josh Edwards of CBS Sports has the Dolphins taking Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker at No. 3, calling him the most stable option in the class. Curt Popejoy of DraftWire is on the same track, saying the Willis signing isn’t working and that Miami has too much young talent to stay put at the position.
Justin Melo of SI.com also sees Mestemaker as the move, especially with a division rival lurking right behind Miami in the order. Cody Williams of FanSided likes the upside too, praising Mestemaker’s arm strength, his growth as a thrower and his ability to create with his legs.
There’s another route in the mock-draft world, though. Jordan Reid of ESPN has the Jets trading up for Mestemaker, which sends Miami to the defensive side for Texas edge rusher Colin Simmons.
Reid described Simmons as a possible star and one of the best pressure creators in the FBS. That would give the Dolphins a much-needed difference-maker off the edge.
Chris Gregory of RotoBaller also has the Jets moving up for Mestemaker, but he keeps Miami on offense with Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr. Gregory framed Carr as the more polished option, a passer with a safer floor who could give the Dolphins a steadier answer at the game’s most important spot.
And then there’s the offensive line path. Cameron Sheath of Pro Football Network said Miami should target an elite receiver, but with Jeremiah Smith likely gone first overall, he has the Dolphins addressing tackle with LSU’s Jordan Seaton.
Sheath wrote that the move would let 2026 first-rounder Kadyn Proctor stay inside, where he has done well in his rookie season, while also accounting for Austin Jackson’s expected departure in free agency. He also noted that Patrick Paul’s form has declined in his second season as the starting left tackle, with his rookie contract set to expire after next season.
The board can still move, and plenty will change before the draft order is finalized in January. But right now, the mock drafts are sending a clear message: if Miami stays near the top, the Dolphins are likely to be choosing between a quarterback, a pass rusher, or a major piece for the offensive line.
In Other News...
Dolphins Are Taking Another Kicker Gamble Fans Have Seen Before
The Dolphins are back in familiar territory at kicker, moving on from Zane Gonzalez after a run of missed field goals and bringing in veteran Daniel Carlson on the practice squad as a possible fix. Miami has seen this movie before, and the latest reset comes with the usual urgency that follows when a team starts treating special teams like an active roster problem instead of a background detail.
Carlson now enters a three-week tryout window, with the Dolphins able to elevate him up to three times before deciding whether he merits a permanent spot on the 53-man roster. He arrives with a track record that includes a stint with the New Orleans Saints, where he was released after missing several long field goals, leaving Miami with another familiar question to answer as it tries to stabilize the position. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins Defense Is Already Top 10 And Might Be Far Scarier
The Dolphins have already climbed into the top 10 in total defense, and the part that makes it stand out is how young this group still is. Miami is leaning on the leagues youngest defensive unit, with three rookie starters, yet the results have come quickly enough to suggest this side of the ball is ahead of schedule.
Jeff Hafley has not even opened up the full playbook yet, choosing instead to tailor the defense to the experience level of his players. Add in the injuries that have kept some key pieces from reaching their full impact, plus a schedule that still features several strong offenses, and there is a real sense that Miamis defense may only be scratching the surface of what it can become. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins Roster Move Hints At A Bigger Bills Game Concern
The Dolphins made another round of roster shuffling this week, and the most notable move was promoting rookie edge defender Max Llewellyn from the practice squad to the active roster ahead of the upcoming game against the Buffalo Bills. Miami also added punter Jack Browning to the practice squad while continuing to adjust the bottom of the roster, a reminder of how quickly depth can become a concern this time of year.
The bigger picture is the defensive line, where the Dolphins placed Zeek Biggers and Jordan Phillips on injured reserve as part of a broader set of moves. With multiple players cycling on and off the roster and Llewellyn now eligible to suit up, Miami is clearly bracing for a matchup that could test its front in a way the current depth chart had not fully anticipated. [Read more 🡒]
