The Dolphins may be staring at an 0-5 start, but the rookie class is giving Miami something real to hang onto during the bye week.
For all the issues swirling around the team - from questions about Malik Willis at quarterback to a special teams unit that has been called atrocious - the first five games have made one thing pretty clear: Jon-Eric Sullivan’s 2026 draft class is producing. Miami used 13 picks in that draft, and the early returns suggest the front office may have hit on far more than just one or two names.
I wasn’t sold on the class at first either, and that’s putting it mildly. Kadyn Proctor going at the top of Round 1 felt steep with Rueben Bain Jr. and Caleb Downs still on the board, and Caleb Douglas in the third round looked like a reach.
I also didn’t love the decision to move Proctor inside to left guard after he spent his entire Alabama career at tackle. But five games in, the results have started to rewrite that initial reaction.
Proctor has been outstanding through the opening stretch. No matter who’s lined up across from him - including All-Pro defensive tackle Chris Jones - he’s generally handled business. Miami may eventually kick him back outside to right tackle, especially with Austin Jackson’s time in Miami seemingly numbered, but the rookie already looks like the kind of player you build around.
The same can’t be said yet for Bain, who has struggled early in his NFL career. Even so, Sullivan stayed true to his board, and right now that first-round pick still looks like it could pay off down the line. At this point, the Dolphins’ general manager deserves a strong A grade for that opening selection alone.
Douglas has been harder to evaluate because of the ankle injury that has kept him out for the last few games, but the early signs were there before he went down. He turned heads in camp and quickly became Willis’ favorite target. Then he backed it up with a spectacular catch in Miami’s first preseason game against Washington and opened the regular season with five catches for 94 yards against the Raiders.
His injury in Week 2 has slowed his momentum, but Douglas already looks capable of being a solid starting receiver for Miami. And with him sidelined, Chris Bell - taken 19 picks later - has started to show why the Dolphins liked him so much.
Returning from an ACL injury he suffered in college, Bell still hasn’t fully flashed the burst he’s known for, but he’s already shown enough to suggest NFL playmaking ability. One out-of-bounds call that wiped out a long touchdown offered a reminder of the big-play juice he brings.
On defense, Miami’s top two picks have been even more impressive.
Chris Johnson keeps getting better, and that’s the kind of growth every team hopes for from a young corner. He’s already playing like a shutdown defender, and opposing quarterbacks are starting to treat him that way. Patrick Mahomes, for example, didn’t even test him in their Week 3 matchup.
Then there’s Jacob Rodriguez, who has been operating on another level. Five weeks into the season, the rookie led the NFL in total tackles and also picked off Mahomes for his first career interception. He’s making a serious push for Defensive Rookie of the Year, and it’s easy to understand why Miami wanted to move up to get him.
The Zach Thomas comparisons have already started because of the way Rodriguez plays, and because both players came out of Texas Tech. He’s not Zach Thomas - there’s only one of those - but the resemblance is easy to see. Rodriguez still has work to do in coverage, yet he’s already looking like Sullivan’s best pick in a class that has a strong case to be remembered for a long time.
The rest of the group has also done its part. Tight end Will Kacmarek has been exactly what the Dolphins hoped for as a blocker, and that matters because Miami wants to build a more physical run game. He may get more work in the passing game later, but right now his blocking is the headline.
Safety Michael Taaffe has also outperformed expectations. A Day 3 pick, he was thrown into a secondary that was expected to be rough from the jump, and instead he’s been around the ball and trending up as the defense improves week by week. He’ll need more help next season, but his instincts have already made him a useful piece.
Miami also picked up two rookies off waivers later in the year, and that gave Sullivan two more cheap swings. After roster cuts at the end of August, the Broncos surprisingly let go of fifth-round tight end Justin Joly.
Then, just before Week 5, the Commanders waived running back Kaytron Allen, and the Dolphins claimed him too. If nothing else, those were low-risk additions worth taking.
That’s where the larger picture lands right now: the record is ugly, but the rookie class is doing its job. For a rebuild, development matters more than the standings at this stage, and Miami’s young players are giving the organization plenty to like early on.
In Other News...
Tyreek Hill's Uncertain Future Keeps One Dolphins Storyline Alive
Tyreek Hills future has stayed one of the more intriguing loose ends around the Dolphins, even with the offseason moving along and plenty of other roster issues demanding attention. The unresolved contract situation has kept the conversation alive, and the latest tone from his camp suggests there is still no clean finish line in sight as teams weigh the fit and the timing.
Hills agent has described the process as fluid, with a deal still possible at any moment as everyone tries to land on the right medical and contractual terms. His knee health, the possibility of a suspension tied to the civil lawsuit, and his contract demands are all part of the holdup, which means Miami is still watching one of the leagues biggest names without real clarity on what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Malik Willis Is Forcing A Dolphins Question Nobody Wanted Answered
The Dolphins are still searching for their first win of the season, and the offense has been part of the reason the start has gone sideways. Malik Willis has been under the microscope from the opening weeks, trying to stabilize a unit that has too often looked stuck in neutral, and the numbers behind his performance have only made the conversation louder around Miami.
Through five games, Willis has completed 56.2% of his passes for 849 yards, with 2 touchdowns and 4 interceptions, leaving him with a 68.4 passer rating that sits at the bottom of the league among quarterbacks with at least four starts. The bigger concern is where this could be headed if nothing changes soon, because the pace he is on would put him in rare and uncomfortable company for a full-season starter. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins O-Line Progress Comes With A New Question Fans Didn't Expect
The Dolphins offensive line has been one of the few areas showing real progress through a rough start, and the rookie-year learning curve for left guard Kadyn Proctor has started to look less like a weekly emergency than a position the team can actually build around. Even in a 0-5 season after the loss to the Bengals, Miamis front has done enough to rank 12th in the NFL, which is a notable sign for a group that has spent recent seasons under constant scrutiny.
Jonah Savaiinaeas development is part of that picture too, which is why his exit against Cincinnati raised an immediate flag even if the expectation is that hell be back next week. The bigger question for Miami now is how the line holds up if the depth chart is tested again, especially after Jarrett Kingston stepped in and looked ready for more responsibility in Savaiinaeas absence. [Read more 🡒]