The Dolphins are getting hammered in preseason roster talk, and the latest national ranking is rough.
ESPN’s Mike Clay, Aaron Schatz and Seth Walder pegged Miami’s roster as the worst in the NFL heading into training-camp practices, adding another layer to a summer that has already been full of skepticism around the team. Back in March, unnamed NFL executives were said to have blasted first-year general manager Jon-Eric Sullivan and first-year head coach Jeff Hafley for handing quarterback and free-agency signing Malik Willis “no chance” to succeed after Sullivan put together a group that is “not a starting NFL offense.”
Clay pointed to the secondary as the clearest weak spot. “The Dolphins are in full rebuild mode and have several units that rank among the league's worst,” Clay said.
“That makes it hard to pick for this exercise, but we'll go secondary. On paper, this is a worse group than the one that allowed a 58.3 QBR last season (fifth worst).
First-round rookie Chris Johnson figures to immediately become an every-down starter, with Storm Duck, slot Jason Marshall Jr., Darrell Baker Jr., JuJu Brents and Alex Austin battling for substantial roles. With Minkah Fitzpatrick and Ashtyn Davis gone, 2025 fifth-rounder Dante Trader Jr. and journeyman Lonnie Johnson Jr. are strong candidates to start.”
Miami’s quarterback situation isn’t helping the mood. A June report said backup Quinn Ewers, a 2025 seventh-round pick, had “outperformed” Willis in at least some spring practices open to the media. That’s a problem for Willis, who remains very much unproven after making just six regular-season starts since arriving as a 2022 third-round pick.
The offseason departures only added fuel to the fire. The Dolphins moved on from former starting quarterback Tua Tagovailoa, pass-rusher Bradley Chubb, wide receiver Tyreek Hill and receiver Jaylen Waddle.
The betting market has noticed, too. As of early Monday afternoon, DraftKings Sportsbook listed Miami second among the favorites to finish with the fewest wins this season at +350. Only the Arizona Cardinals were higher at +250.
There is at least one bright spot on offense. Clay called De'Von Achane the centerpiece, saying, “The recently extended De'Von Achane is the star of Miami's offense, and it's not close,” Clay said about the Dolphins running back.
“The 2023 third-rounder has scored either 11 or 12 touchdowns in each of his three NFL seasons and gained a career-high 1,838 scrimmage yards in 2025. Achane's elite receiving production is nothing new (he has finished in the top five among backs in targets and receiving yards in each of the past two seasons), but he made another leap forward as a rusher in 2025, finishing fifth in rushing yards.
His 5.62 yards per carry is best among qualified backs since he entered the league.”
Even with Achane in place, the Dolphins still look like a team that could be forced to make hard decisions quickly. If he doesn’t stay healthy and keep producing at an Offensive Player of the Year level through October, Miami could be looking at a sell-off before the in-season trade deadline later this fall.
In Other News...
Dolphins Receiver Battle Suddenly Has One Surprise Name To Watch
The Dolphins receiver room is one of the more open competitions on the roster this spring, and Caleb Douglas has quickly become a name worth tracking. Miami used a third-round pick on the wideout, a move that caught some attention because many around the league expected him to be more of a day-three selection, but the team clearly saw enough to make him part of a class that included three drafted receivers.
Now the question is whether that investment translates into a real path to a starting job. With no clear answer yet on who will line up first at wide receiver, Douglas is in the mix, and the fact that coaches Jon-Eric Sullivan and Jeff Hafley have seen something in him only adds to the intrigue as Miami tries to sort out its passing game around a roster built to chase bigger goals. [Read more 🡒]
Tua Just Reached The Moment Dolphins Fans Knew Was Coming
Tua Tagovailoas next chapter has already become one of the more watched storylines of the offseason, and not just because of where its happening. After years of debate in Miami over whether he could stay healthy and sustain the level he flashed before the regression set in, he has landed in a setting where every throw is being weighed against the version of him Dolphins fans kept waiting to see again. The early buzz out of Atlanta has been encouraging, with Tagovailoa standing out in practices and forcing the conversation to shift from what went wrong in Miami to what might still be possible.
The bigger question now is whether this is the start of a real rebound or just another stop in a career that has already invited plenty of labels. Fans and analysts have been split on the outcome for months, with some expecting a short-term bridge role and others still holding out hope that he can get back to his earlier form. Atlantas quarterback situation gives him a path to prove it, but the pressure is obvious: if he keeps building on this start, he can change the narrative around his future, and if he doesnt, the league may decide it has seen enough. [Read more 🡒]
Mark Gronowski Could Force A Tough Dolphins Quarterback Decision
The Dolphins quarterback room for 2026 already looks very different, with Tua Tagovailoa now in Atlanta and Malik Willis projected to take over as the starter. Quinn Ewers is expected to settle in as the No. 2 option, which leaves the final spot in the room to a younger competition that could matter more than it first appears.
Mark Gronowski, an undrafted rookie with a dual-threat rsum and plenty of college success behind him, is pushing Cam Miller for that third quarterback job. Miami may not want to carry more than three passers, but if Gronowski doesnt make the active roster, the practice squad is the other obvious path, and even that comes with a risk if another team decides it likes his upside enough to make a move during the season. [Read more 🡒]