Stop if you’ve heard this one before: the Miami Dolphins are headed to Buffalo as big underdogs, and that setup has become almost routine.
This time, the numbers are brutal. Miami is 1-8, Buffalo is 8-1, and the Dolphins also haven’t won in Buffalo in 10 years. The last Miami victory there came on December 24, 2016, when the Dolphins pulled out a 34-31 overtime win and later that day got a little help from Denver to reach the playoffs.
Since then, it’s been 10 straight losses in Buffalo, including a playoff game in the 2022 season. But that run hasn’t been a string of total blowouts. Miami has had real chances in several of those games, with three losses by three points, one by eight, and two others that stayed live deep into the fourth quarter.
That matters because some of those near-misses came when the Dolphins were supposed to get steamrolled anyway. Sunday brings another one of those spots, even with Miami down three defensive linemen.
Here’s a look back at the Dolphins’ 10 straight losses in Buffalo, ranked by how close they came to flipping one of them.
The narrowest miss came with rookie seventh-round pick Skylar Thompson at quarterback, after Tua Tagovailoa was out with a concussion and Teddy Bridgewater was sidelined by a hand injury. Miami went in as 13.5-point underdogs, got big defensive plays and a long punt return from Cedrick Wilson Jr., and still had a chance to steal it on the final drive after going down three near midfield. The drive just never got over the line.
Another one that stung came on a late touchdown pass from Tagovailoa to Jaylen Waddle that tied the game 27-27. Jordan Poyer’s roughness penalty on a third-and-9 kept a potential winning drive alive, only for Tyler Bass to finish it with a 61-yard field goal.
On a snowy Saturday night after losses to the 49ers and Chargers, Miami had a real opening in a 29-29 game. The Dolphins had first-and-10 at the Buffalo 41, but the drive fizzled. Buffalo then escaped a second-and-18 hole and got into position for a chip-shot winning field goal after a DPI on Kader Kohou.
Another painful one came with the Dolphins listed as 12-point underdogs after an 0-2 start. The game was tied 21-21 in the fourth quarter when Zach Sieler was called for roughing the kicker, and that was one of two massive swings against Miami. The other came later when Tagovailoa threw an interception on first-and-10 from the Bills 21.
When Miami went to Buffalo at 0-5 against a 4-1 Bills team, it was a 17-point underdog but still led 14-9 heading into the fourth quarter. Then the game slipped away, helped along by a Preston Williams fumble inside the Miami 30. Buffalo sealed it when Micah Hyde returned the Dolphins’ onside kick attempt for a touchdown.
Not every loss in the streak was dramatic. One of them stood out mainly because Jay Cutler threw three interceptions.
Another came the week after Miami put up 70 points on the Denver Broncos to move to 3-0. The teams traded touchdowns on the first five possessions, but Buffalo scored 10 points in the final 3:12 of the first half and took a 31-14 lead.
There was also a rough offensive day that turned on a disastrous sequence near the end of the first half. Miami was trying to break a 3-3 tie, and on third-and-5 from the Buffalo 12 with 24 seconds left, a shotgun snap from center Austin Reiter hit Mike Gesicki while he was in motion. Buffalo recovered the fumble and killed the threat.
In another game, Miami actually entered as the favorite because Buffalo had already clinched the AFC East and was expected to rest starters. The Dolphins needed a win to clinch a playoff spot and led 3-0 after the first quarter, but Josh Allen threw three touchdown passes and Buffalo added a punt return score to make it 28-6 at halftime. Allen was done after that, and Miami’s playoff hopes were done too.
The streak also includes what became Adam Gase’s final game as Dolphins head coach. In that one, Josh Allen beat Miami for the first time by throwing three touchdown passes and running for two more as a 14-14 halftime game got away from the Dolphins.
In Other News...
Dolphins Suddenly Have A Special Teams Job Up For Grabs
The Dolphins special teams picture changed quickly this week when they released kicker Zane Gonzalez and brought in Daniel Carlson to take over the job. It is another reminder that this unit has been in flux, and it comes at a time when Miami is already dealing with a separate issue at punter, where Bradley Pinion is sidelined and unavailable for the upcoming game.
Jack Browning is set to handle punting duties in Pinions absence, giving Miami a closer look at a player with limited NFL experience. The Dolphins will use this stretch to judge whether Browning can do more than fill in for a week, because the performance he puts on now could factor into whether he stays in the conversation for a longer-term role. [Read more 🡒]
Bills Defensive Front Suddenly Looks A Lot Less Certain Vs Dolphins
Buffalos defensive front has picked up a new layer of uncertainty heading into its matchup with Miami, with defensive tackle Ed Oliver landing on the injury report because of an oblique issue. The Bills evaluated Oliver after he reported the injury, and while the team is still holding out hope he can suit up, his status adds another wrinkle to a unit already dealing with questions.
T.J. Sanders is among the other defensive players listed as questionable or ruled out, which leaves Buffalos front in a less stable spot than it expected to be at this point in the week. For the Dolphins, that is the kind of development worth watching closely, because any change up front can alter how the Bills try to handle Miamis offense on game day. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins Suddenly Face A Brutal Race They Never Wanted To Lead
The Dolphins have found themselves in an uncomfortable place this season, with ESPNs Football Power Index now projecting Miami and Tennessee as the leading candidates to land the No. 1 overall pick in the 2027 NFL Draft. It is a jarring turn for a team that entered the year with very different expectations, and the remaining schedule only adds to the intrigue, with games still ahead against other low-win opponents that could reshape where Miami ultimately lands.
Miamis projection sits at 40%, just ahead of the Titans at 38%, putting both clubs well in front of the rest of the struggling pack in the race for the top selection. For a team that would much rather be chasing wins than draft positioning, the next few weeks could end up mattering in a way nobody in South Florida wanted to think about this early. [Read more 🡒]
