Dolphins Defense Is Already Top 10 And Might Be Far Scarier

The Miami Dolphins' youthful defense is not only among the NFL's best but also thriving under challenging conditions and strategic restraint.

The Miami Dolphins have quietly built a defense that belongs in the top 10, and the part that should really catch your attention is how young it is.

After the Week 10 loss to the Colts, Miami sits 10th in total defense, according to the Miami Herald’s Barry Jackson. That ranking comes with three rookie starters and a group filled with players who have barely logged any NFL experience. Even with that kind of inexperience, the unit has held its ground.

There’s also more going on here than youth alone. Jeff Hafley reportedly hasn’t even put the full defense on the field yet.

During the bye week, he said he trimmed back parts of the system and held off on installing more as he adjusted to the experience level of his roster. It has worked so far, but it also leaves the sense that Miami is still only scratching the surface of what the scheme could become.

The defense has started to show a few more wrinkles since the bye, but not many. And that likely won’t change much the rest of the way, especially with Zach Sieler, Jordan Phillips, and Zeek Biggers all out for the season.

What makes the ranking even more impressive is the schedule. Miami hasn’t been padding these numbers against soft competition.

The Dolphins are working through the second-toughest schedule in the NFL, and the rest of the slate is no picnic either. They still have two games against the Bills, plus the Bears, Broncos, Packers, Patriots, Chargers, and Jets.

They’ve already seen plenty of quality offenses, too. The only real blowout came in Week 2 against the 49ers in San Francisco. They pushed the Chiefs deep into the fourth quarter and came close against the Vikings’ top defense and the Bengals’ high-powered attack.

If Hafley’s group keeps playing like this, it will only add to the surprise. But it also says plenty about the coach himself. This defense has been better than any Miami has had since Vic Fangio was in charge, and that unit was built around veterans.

For Dolphins fans, the takeaway is pretty clear: Hafley knows what he’s doing, and the defense should only improve as the roster gets healthier and more experienced. The growth may not always jump off the screen in real time, when fans are tracking big plays and third-down stops, but the numbers tell a different story.

The Lions game offered another reminder. Miami held the league’s top offense in check and made them look ordinary, something the Patriots couldn’t do in their Week 10 blowout loss to Detroit.

There is one possible catch: this may be as high as the Dolphins’ defense climbs. Even so, that might not be the worst outcome for a team with a clear path to the top pick in the upcoming NFL Draft.

In Other News...

Dolphins Are Taking Another Kicker Gamble Fans Have Seen Before

The Dolphins are back in familiar territory at kicker, moving on from Zane Gonzalez after a run of missed field goals and bringing in veteran Daniel Carlson on the practice squad as a possible fix. Miami has seen this movie before, and the latest reset comes with the usual urgency that follows when a team starts treating special teams like an active roster problem instead of a background detail.

Carlson now enters a three-week tryout window, with the Dolphins able to elevate him up to three times before deciding whether he merits a permanent spot on the 53-man roster. He arrives with a track record that includes a stint with the New Orleans Saints, where he was released after missing several long field goals, leaving Miami with another familiar question to answer as it tries to stabilize the position. [Read more 🡒]

Dolphins Suddenly Face A Franchise Defining Draft Debate

With one of the worst records in the league, Miami is already staring at a draft position that could reshape the franchise for years. The early buzz around the 2027 NFL Draft has centered on the Dolphins and the kind of choice that can define a front office, with some evaluators floating Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker among the possibilities while others point to top non-quarterback talents such as Jeremiah Smith and Colin Simmons.

For general manager Jon-Eric Sullivan, the real question is less about who might be available and more about what direction the organization believes it needs to take. Miami still has plenty of season left and the draft order is far from settled, but the conversation has already started to turn toward whether the Dolphins should use a premium pick on a quarterback or attack another area of need instead. [Read more 🡒]

Dolphins Roster Move Hints At A Bigger Bills Game Concern

The Dolphins made another round of roster shuffling this week, and the most notable move was promoting rookie edge defender Max Llewellyn from the practice squad to the active roster ahead of the upcoming game against the Buffalo Bills. Miami also added punter Jack Browning to the practice squad while continuing to adjust the bottom of the roster, a reminder of how quickly depth can become a concern this time of year.

The bigger picture is the defensive line, where the Dolphins placed Zeek Biggers and Jordan Phillips on injured reserve as part of a broader set of moves. With multiple players cycling on and off the roster and Llewellyn now eligible to suit up, Miami is clearly bracing for a matchup that could test its front in a way the current depth chart had not fully anticipated. [Read more 🡒]