Dolphins Are Taking Another Kicker Gamble Fans Have Seen Before

Can Daniel Carlson break the Miami Dolphins' kicker curse, or will his past haunt him again?

The Dolphins are back in the kicker market, and this time the name attached to the job is Daniel Carlson.

Miami moved on from Zane Gonzalez on Monday morning after a rough outing against the Colts, when he missed two field goals and an extra point. That came on the heels of another missed field goal in Week 9.

Gonzalez had only been in place after Riley Patterson was cut earlier in the season, following two missed field goals of his own. Now the Dolphins are trying again, and Carlson is the latest man handed the opportunity.

At least for now, though, this is not a full commitment. Carlson was signed to the practice squad, not the 53-man roster, which says plenty about where Miami stands.

The team keeps a roster spot open for another position and can elevate Carlson three times before needing to either release him or sign him to the active roster. In other words, this is a three-week audition.

That setup fits the reality of Carlson’s recent track record. He was with the Saints to open 2026, but they cut him after he missed four field goals.

Over seven weeks with New Orleans, he missed a kick in six games, including four field goals and two extra points. Every one of those misses came from beyond 50 yards.

The long-ball profile is part of the story here. Carlson has missed 18 kicks from outside 50 yards in his career, even though he has made 86% of his attempts overall and has a long of 60 yards.

If Miami gives him chances from deep, those attempts could turn into field-position trouble fast. That’s why his margin for error figures to be small.

Still, the Dolphins clearly weren’t swimming in options. They worked out several kickers over the last two weeks, and more before settling on Gonzalez.

With the season where it is, the goal is simply to get through the stretch run. Carlson may end up lasting longer because of that, but if the misses show up again, it’s hard to see Miami making him the permanent answer.

In Other News...

Dolphins Suddenly Face A Franchise Defining Draft Debate

With one of the worst records in the league, Miami is already staring at a draft position that could reshape the franchise for years. The early buzz around the 2027 NFL Draft has centered on the Dolphins and the kind of choice that can define a front office, with some evaluators floating Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker among the possibilities while others point to top non-quarterback talents such as Jeremiah Smith and Colin Simmons.

For general manager Jon-Eric Sullivan, the real question is less about who might be available and more about what direction the organization believes it needs to take. Miami still has plenty of season left and the draft order is far from settled, but the conversation has already started to turn toward whether the Dolphins should use a premium pick on a quarterback or attack another area of need instead. [Read more 🡒]

Dolphins Defense Is Already Top 10 And Might Be Far Scarier

The Dolphins have already climbed into the top 10 in total defense, and the part that makes it stand out is how young this group still is. Miami is leaning on the leagues youngest defensive unit, with three rookie starters, yet the results have come quickly enough to suggest this side of the ball is ahead of schedule.

Jeff Hafley has not even opened up the full playbook yet, choosing instead to tailor the defense to the experience level of his players. Add in the injuries that have kept some key pieces from reaching their full impact, plus a schedule that still features several strong offenses, and there is a real sense that Miamis defense may only be scratching the surface of what it can become. [Read more 🡒]

Dolphins Roster Move Hints At A Bigger Bills Game Concern

The Dolphins made another round of roster shuffling this week, and the most notable move was promoting rookie edge defender Max Llewellyn from the practice squad to the active roster ahead of the upcoming game against the Buffalo Bills. Miami also added punter Jack Browning to the practice squad while continuing to adjust the bottom of the roster, a reminder of how quickly depth can become a concern this time of year.

The bigger picture is the defensive line, where the Dolphins placed Zeek Biggers and Jordan Phillips on injured reserve as part of a broader set of moves. With multiple players cycling on and off the roster and Llewellyn now eligible to suit up, Miami is clearly bracing for a matchup that could test its front in a way the current depth chart had not fully anticipated. [Read more 🡒]