Kyle McCord is about to walk into a pretty tough first test, and the Dolphins are handing him the ball with Sunday’s matchup against the Indianapolis Colts set to be his NFL debut.
The 2025 sixth-round pick did not spend his rookie year on an active roster, but Miami saw enough to make a move for him this summer, sending a future sixth-round pick to the Green Bay Packers and slotting him in as the backup behind another former Packers quarterback, Malik Willis. Now the Dolphins are asking him to step into the spotlight.
McCord remains a mystery at the pro level. His resume so far comes from Ohio State, Syracuse, and preseason work with both the Eagles last summer and the Packers this year. He described the traits he believes define his game on Wednesday.
"I pride myself on just being the ultimate competitor out there on the field," McCord said Wednesday. "And then on top of that, I feel like being able to process information at a quick rate and getting the ball out and being accurate and being on time, I feel like those are all things throughout college and into my preseason games in the NFL that I had success with. So I'm just trying to keep that rolling."
That college-to-preseason track is the key here, because the Dolphins have plenty of precedent for rookie or near-rookie quarterbacks making their first start in Miami. McCord will be the seventh quarterback to make his NFL debut in a Dolphins uniform since 2000, joining Sage Rosenfels in 2004, John Beck in 2007, Chad Henne in 2009, Ryan Tannehill in 2012, Tua Tagovailoa in 2020, Skylar Thompson in 2022 and Quinn Ewers in 2025.
Not all of those cases line up cleanly. Beck, Henne, Tannehill and Tagovailoa were first- or second-round picks, so their paths were different no matter how the careers unfolded. That leaves Rosenfels, Thompson and Ewers as the more useful comparisons.
Ewers stands out as the closest match. He was a sixth-round pick, came from major college football at Texas, and, like McCord, had started out at Ohio State. After opening the year as Miami’s No. 3 quarterback behind Tagovailoa and veteran Zach Wilson, Ewers climbed to No. 2 and finished the 2025 season with three starts.
His first one came against the Cincinnati Bengals in Week 16, and he went 20 for 30 for 260 yards. He also connected on throws of 20 yards or more to four different receivers - tight ends Greg Dulcich and Darren Waller, plus wide receivers Malik Washington and Jaylen Waddle - while throwing two interceptions. Still, the bigger takeaway was that he didn’t look lost.
Skylar Thompson’s first start came with an asterisk. Before facing the Minnesota Vikings, he had already played nearly an entire game the previous week after Teddy Bridgewater was removed by a concussion spotter after Miami’s first snap against the injury-depleted Tagovailoa situation. Rosenfels, meanwhile, had also already seen action before his first start, which came in the 2004 season finale with the Dolphins sitting at 4-11.
Beck and Tannehill are the two exceptions in that group, since both debuted in their first NFL appearances. Tannehill started the 2012 season opener, while Beck got his first action in a Week 11 game against the Philadelphia Eagles. Beck, unlike Ewers, looked overwhelmed and finished 9-for-22 for 109 yards, an early sign the Dolphins had whiffed on that second-round pick.
That’s why Ewers is the best guide for McCord’s situation.
The problem for McCord is that this offense is not the same one Ewers inherited. Dulcich and Washington are still around, but Waddle and Waller are gone and De'Von Achane is on injured reserve. That makes life harder for a quarterback making his first start, especially one who has already watched Malik Willis struggle to put up big numbers with a young, inexperienced supporting cast.
The Colts, meanwhile, come into the game at 2-7 and have only two interceptions all season despite having Sauce Gardner and Charvarius Ward at cornerback. They’re also coming off a game in which they gave up 508 yards in an overtime loss to the Dallas Cowboys.
That was Indianapolis’ first game without DeForest Buckner, who was traded to the San Francisco 49ers. The Colts made four trades before the deadline, and the other three involved offensive players. It has been a long season in Indy, though at least the uncertainty around whether key players like Jonathan Taylor or Daniel Jones would be moved is gone now.
Still, nobody is expecting Miami to pile up 508 yards on Sunday.
And nobody should expect McCord to torch the Colts secondary in his first NFL action, either. Even matching Ewers’ numbers would be a hefty ask. The more realistic target may be keeping the ball out of harm’s way.
A reasonable line for McCord might look something like 215 passing yards, one touchdown and no interceptions.
In Other News...
Dolphins Home Crowd Problem Is Becoming Impossible To Ignore
After the Week 9 loss, the conversation around the Dolphins shifted from the field to the stands, where visiting fans have become impossible to miss at home games. Players noticed it, too, with the atmosphere inside Hard Rock Stadium drawing attention for feeling far less like a true home setting than Miami would want, especially when the opponent brings a loud and visible crowd.
The bigger issue, according to the discussion around the team, is not a lack of interest in the Dolphins so much as the way tickets are getting into the market. Between pricing, aftermarket sales and the incentives around attendance, local fans are being pushed out while more out-of-town supporters find their way in. It leaves Miami with a home-field problem that goes beyond one game and points back to the way the team has chosen to sell the experience. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins Keep Earning Respect In One Area Fans Can Appreciate
Even with the record still looking rough, the Dolphins have continued to show something that tends to travel well from week to week: they are staying competitive. In a Week 9 review and Week 11 betting preview, Miami was singled out for the way it has kept games from getting away from it, a trait that matters both to the standings and to anyone trying to size up this team honestly.
That kind of respect does not erase the losses, but it does change the conversation around Miami as the schedule moves on. The bigger question now is whether that competitiveness can turn into something more tangible in the weeks ahead, especially with the kind of uneven NFL landscape that keeps creating opportunities for teams to break through or slip further back. [Read more 🡒]
Dolphins Defense Just Sent A Strong Message About One Rising Leader
Injuries have already forced the Dolphins to adjust their leadership structure, and the latest move says plenty about where the locker room sees things heading. Miami added Josh Uche as a replacement captain after the teams original group was thinned out, a sign that the defense has identified a player who has quickly earned trust through his work this season.
Jeff Hafley said the request for another captain came from the players themselves, which makes the decision feel less like a formality and more like a reflection of the rooms priorities. Uches rise has been tied to the impact he has made on defense and the respect he has built with teammates and coaches, and the team made it official during Wednesdays meeting. [Read more 🡒]