SEC Legend Sparks Heated Tennessee QB Debate

With Tennessee's quarterback dilemma heating up, former Georgia QB Aaron Murray weighs in on whether George MacIntyre or Faizon Brandon should face LSU's formidable defense.

Tennessee’s quarterback situation is suddenly right back in flux, and the decision for LSU may come down to whether the Vols want the steadier arm or the more dynamic runner.

George MacIntyre had worked his way into the starting job after opening the season as the backup, but a rough stretch of drives and a banged-up status changed the picture at Texas A&M. Faizon Brandon came back into the game and helped Tennessee finish the job in a 22-7 win, which leaves the Vols without a clear answer heading into LSU’s visit.

Former Georgia quarterback Aaron Murray made his preference plain. He believes Brandon has a bright future, but he wants MacIntyre on the field against what he sees as a difficult LSU defense.

“George MacIntyre has continued to look good,” Murray said. “… He was banged up a week ago.

He’s not like a crazy mobile quarterback, but he does need to play in this game. I do not want - I still think Faizon Brandon is going to be a superstar in this league, has potential to be a superstar in this league.

He is not ready to face this defense from LSU. He just is not.

“This defense has been, besides really the first possession and last possession last week vs. Texas, magnificent.

Got after the quarterback, created turnovers, and I expect them to be very aggressive in this game. If George is the guy, make him win the football game with his arm.

Don’t let the run game get going. And if Faizon is in the game, like I said, good luck to Faizon.

This defense is going to be able to put you in third-and-long situations, and they’re going to be able to get after the quarterback with Umanmielen and Ross coming off the edge, linebackers playing at a high level. This is an elite defense.”

MacIntyre’s status has been the main wrinkle. He’s dealing with a knee injury from the Texas A&M game, but he has not shown up on this week’s availability reports, which points to him being available. Josh Heupel said Monday that MacIntyre was trending in the right direction.

“With George, he looked good this morning and will continue to progress through the course of the week,” Heupel said. “We’ve played both of them here the last few weeks, once Faizon got healthy.

And at the end of the day, whoever’s out there has got to go play really good football. This is a really good defense.

You look at them statistically against the run, against the pass. I think they lead the conference in total defense.

They’re playing extremely well.”

Before leaving the Texas A&M game, MacIntyre completed 13 of 17 passes for 109 yards with no touchdowns and no interceptions. Brandon’s work came mostly on the ground, where he ran for 36 yards on six carries. He also threw Tennessee’s lone pass he attempted, a five-yard touchdown to DaSaahn Brame.

Tennessee and LSU are set for a 3:30 p.m. ET kickoff on ABC.