The top of the AP Top 25 barely budged for me after Week 11, but the bottom half turned into a full-on sorting exercise. With the Oklahoma-Ole Miss game pushed to Sunday, I had a little extra time to wrestle with the rankings - and it still wasn’t easy.
Wake Forest was the only team I moved into the top 10 this week, and the Deacons earned it by flattening SMU 49-7 in Dallas on Saturday. Jake Dickert’s group has been rolling for six straight weeks, outscoring opponents 313-38 in that stretch.
Yes, the run came against Stanford (5-5), NC State (fired its coach), California (3-7), Virginia (5-5), Merrimack (FCS) and SMU, but the Mustangs were ranked for much of the season, and Wake Forest also has a win over Louisville, the No. 15 team in my poll. The Deacons’ only loss came against Miami, which sits No. 5 in my latest top 25.
Even if Wake Forest loses to Miami again in the ACC Championship Game, I still think it deserves an at-large College Football Playoff bid as long as it handles Georgia Tech and Duke over the final two weeks.
The real chaos came from 13 through 25. Arizona, Kentucky, LSU, Ole Miss, USC, Missouri, South Carolina and Houston all lost, and that opened the door for teams below them.
But the teams trying to climb in kept stumbling too. SMU, Oklahoma State, Duke and Wisconsin were just outside my poll last week, and all four lost.
Illinois and Northwestern were in the mix as well, and they lost too.
That left me weighing a bunch of imperfect résumés against each other. I gave serious thought to Duke and Oklahoma State anyway because their losses came against Miami and Texas Tech, respectively. But Oklahoma State still has losses to Iowa State and Tulsa, and Duke doesn’t have a quality win and also lost to Georgia Tech, so I left both out.
A lot of the teams that did make it have better wins than those two. Ole Miss, for instance, lost to Oklahoma this week, but the Rebels also own three ranked wins - Missouri, LSU and Louisville - and haven’t lost to anyone outside my top 26. Oklahoma was my last team out.
That’s really what shaped the back end of the poll: quality wins. With so many teams sitting on three or more losses and resumes that don’t line up neatly, that mattered more than ever.
It helped Florida jump from unranked to No. 17 and kept Kentucky inside my top 20. Oregon also benefited, moving up to No. 13 thanks to two ranked wins and no damaging loss.
I considered Illinois there, but I didn’t see a reason to knock the Ducks down.
Style points mattered, too. LSU stayed ranked at 6-4 despite not having a ranked win because the Tigers are No. 7 in ESPN’s College Football Power Index and have handled weaker opponents so convincingly.
Arizona climbed four spots after coming painfully close to upsetting the No. 2 team in the country. The Wildcats have also taken care of business against lesser teams, and their three losses have come against top-12 teams in my poll by no more than 11 points.
South Carolina ended up edging Oklahoma for the final spot in my rankings, and the head-to-head result was a big reason why. The Gamecocks hammered the Sooners in Norman a few weeks ago, and when the two resumes look that similar, that matters.
Oklahoma has looked different since firing offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle, but South Carolina’s loss to Arkansas this week is hard to ignore, even if Oklahoma also has a loss to Michigan. I don’t see much difference between Michigan and Arkansas, especially with the Razorbacks improving over the last few weeks.
Ohio State moved up only two spots despite winning, and that was mostly because beating Northwestern at home without starting quarterback Aiden Chiles doesn’t do much for me. The Buckeyes have been difficult to place for three weeks now, since they haven’t had Chiles, and they’re not the same team that beat Iowa and knocked off Indiana.
In Other News...
LSUs Brutal Loss Ended With An Even Wilder Postgame Scene
Texas left Baton Rouge with a dramatic win, but the night did not really end when Arch Manning found Raleek Brown for the last-second touchdown. The game had already been tense enough, with a fan throwing a drink at Manning and LSU supporters tossing bottles onto the field as Texas celebrated, a messy finish to a close rivalry-style showdown that had the whole stadium on edge.
Then came the postgame scene that social media could not stop replaying. Texas freshman wide receiver Chris Stewart got into a heated exchange with Mike the Tiger near the LSU student section, adding one more jolt to an already volatile night and giving the game an after-the-whistle moment that will linger almost as long as the result itself. [Read more 🡒]
Lane Kiffin Knows What Is Holding LSU Back Right Now
LSUs season has turned into a study in missed chances, and Lane Kiffin said the Tigers 6-4 start in his first year is not the kind of record that matches the talent level around the program. After a tight loss to Texas, the frustration has only grown because LSU has been in position to win several games against ranked opponents, only to let those opportunities slip away in the details.
Kiffin pointed to the same problem areas that often decide November football: red-zone execution, special teams and the small calls that swing momentum. He also acknowledged how difficult it is to build a team that can finish those games cleanly, which is why LSUs margin for error has been so thin even when the Tigers have played well enough to lead late. [Read more 🡒]
Lane Kiffin's LSU Move Is Creating Ugly Fallout Off The Field
Lane Kiffins move from Ole Miss to LSU after the 2025 season was always going to stir up strong feelings across the SEC, but the fallout has not stayed confined to the rivalry between the two schools. His daughter, Landry Kiffin, is still a student at Ole Miss, and the coaching change has put her in an uncomfortable spot as fans have reacted negatively to the familys new reality.
For LSU, the on-field pressure has only added to the noise around Kiffins first season in Baton Rouge. The Tigers have already dealt with a rough start, including a recent loss to Texas, and Kiffin addressed that setback in his postgame comments while the off-field story continued to follow him. [Read more 🡒]
