Two Louisiana district attorneys are now on opposite sides of one of college sports’ messiest fights, and LSU sits right in the middle of it.
Orleans Parish DA Jason Williams has been brought in through his private practice to help represent the Southeastern Conference as it tries to keep member schools - especially LSU - from adding former professional athletes who want to return for a fifth college season. Across the aisle is Tony Clayton, the West Baton Rouge, Iberville and Pointe Coupee parishes prosecutor, who is part of the legal team for the athletes pushing to gain another year of eligibility.
A Baton Rouge hearing is set for Thursday morning.
Williams’ role became visible Wednesday through a court filing on behalf of the SEC. It is still unclear exactly what he will do in the case, and he could not immediately be reached for comment. Clayton said he knew Williams was involved for the conference but declined to say more.
Both men are involved as private attorneys, not in their official government roles.
The matchup adds another layer to a case already drawing plenty of attention in college athletics. Clayton has been West Baton Rouge’s top prosecutor since 2020 and also serves as chairman of the Southern University Board of Supervisors. Williams, a former New Orleans City Council member, has been Orleans Parish DA since January 2021.
Their political lanes have diverged sharply, too. Clayton, a conservative Democrat with a long reputation as a tough-on-crime prosecutor in the Baton Rouge area, is aligned with Republican Gov.
Jeff Landry and Attorney General Liz Murrill. Williams, also a Democrat, came in as a progressive criminal justice reformer and has repeatedly clashed with Landry and Murrill, especially in recent months.
Murrill added her own voice to the dispute Wednesday night, filing an amicus brief backing the athletes. She argued they should be allowed to compete this year in the name of consistency for both schools and players.
“The State has an interest in college sports rules that are fair, consistent, and predictable - ones capable of being followed by athletes, coaches, and institutions who don’t have to choose between contempt charges or conference sanctions,” Murrill’s brief says.
The legal fight began when more than 30 athletes won a temporary restraining order in mid-August from Baton Rouge Judge William Jorden. That order opened the door for Class of 2022 high school graduates to return to college, even though the NCAA had not granted them a fifth year of eligibility despite rule changes allowing current athletes five seasons in five years.
LSU moved quickly to take advantage of the ruling. The Tigers added former Ole Miss starters Dae’Quan Wright and Zxavian Harris, both of whom had signed with NFL teams for the preseason. LSU also would have added Jack Pyburn, a former Tigers edge rusher who was in camp with the Tampa Bay Buccaneerss, if the Kansas City Chiefs had not claimed him off waivers.
The Tigers also picked up former Notre Dame defensive end Junior Tuihalamaka, though he is not part of the SEC’s objection because he never signed a pro contract. LSU coach Lane Kiffin confirmed Monday that Wright and Tuihalamaka were practicing with the team.
In response to the roster moves, the SEC adopted rules barring member schools from adding athletes who had previously been signed or rostered by pro teams. Clayton and the athletes’ lawyers say the conference was trying to get around the restraining order aimed at the NCAA, which the SEC schools belong to.
The conference and commissioner Greg Sankey were later added as defendants, and Jorden expanded the restraining order last week to stop the SEC from punishing LSU and other schools for the additions. Those penalties could include a fine equal to 50% of a sport’s budget and a half-season suspension for a coach.
In Wednesday’s filing, signed by Williams, the SEC argued that it is not simply carrying out NCAA orders and did not coordinate its penalties with the governing body.
“The SEC’s Presidents and Chancellors are entitled - and indeed obligated as stewards of Conference competition - to determine how existing Conference Bylaws (often referred to as rules) would apply to that circumstance,” the filing said.
The conference also said it was trying to protect fair competition by limiting former pros from jumping back into college after rosters were already built, arguing that most programs did not plan for an “influx” of August additions.
Thursday’s 11 a.m. hearing will decide whether a larger group of more than 40 athletes gets a preliminary injunction. If Jorden grants it, the SEC is expected to keep fighting, either at the appellate level or by filing a new lawsuit in another jurisdiction.
Sankey is scheduled to be in court Thursday and may testify, according to Yahoo Sports.
In Other News...
Nick Saban Just Sent LSU A Clemson Warning Fans Will Feel
Nick Sabans memories of LSU still carry a lesson he says every team eventually has to learn: the environment can help, but it cannot do the work for you. Looking back on his early years in Baton Rouge, Saban said his teams sometimes leaned too heavily on the energy inside Tiger Stadium instead of letting their own play set the tone, a reminder that arrived fast after an early-season loss in his first year.
He even put up a sign in the locker room to make the point clear, tying success to what happened on the field rather than what came from the stands. With LSU set for a matchup against Clemson, Saban made it clear he hopes the current Tigers dont fall into the same trap, especially in a game where the atmosphere will matter but execution will matter more. [Read more 🡒]
LSUs Eligibility Fight Just Took A Turn Fans Cant Ignore
A Baton Rouge judges ruling this week gave former collegiate athletes a path to pursue a fifth season of college sports, and LSU is already moving to adjust to the legal reality. The preliminary injunction came in a lawsuit involving the NCAA and Southeastern Conference, and LSU President Wade Rousse acknowledged the decision, saying the university will follow the law while continuing to support its programs.
Lane Kiffin, Verge Ausberry and LSU now find themselves in the middle of a separate SEC lawsuit tied to the broader fight over the injunction, adding another layer to an already messy dispute. For LSU, the issue is no longer just about how one ruling affects eligibility, but how far the conference is willing to go in challenging the school and its people as the legal battle keeps unfolding. [Read more 🡒]
LSU Fans Will Be Watching This Baton Rouge QB Family Showdown
The Louisiana high school season opens with a matchup LSU fans will want to keep an eye on, even if the Tigers are not on the field. Archbishop Rummel visiting University High School brings together two new quarterbacks making their first starts after offseason transfers, and both carry names that already mean something around Baton Rouge football circles.
Knox Kiffin, the three-star quarterback and son of LSU head coach Lane Kiffin, will be on one sideline, while Colton Nussmeier, a four-star Georgia commit and younger brother of NFL quarterback Garrett Nussmeier, will be on the other. For LSU followers, it is a familiar kind of early-season intrigue, with two local family storylines intersecting before the high school calendar even gets rolling. [Read more 🡒]