Paul Finebaum and Stephen A. Smith found themselves on opposite sides of the latest SEC dustup involving LSU, and neither one sounded interested in softening his stance.
At the center of the argument was LSU’s early plan to play a pair of NFL training camp invitees on its 2026 roster, a move that drew headlines, sparked litigation and pushed the conference into a public showdown with one of its own members. LSU eventually backed down, but not before the issue turned into a broader fight over how far schools can push the boundaries of college football eligibility.
Finebaum came down hard on LSU and framed the SEC’s response as both necessary and serious. In his view, the conference was right to draw a line after the Tigers’ move, and he said the league was making a statement that went beyond one school.
"The SEC can survive and will survive without LSU," said Finebaum. "This is about the future of college sports right here.
The commissioner and 15 other Presidents are sending a message-- 'You guys are spitting in our face and we're going to throw you out if you don't sit down and get along.'... This is not sabre-rattling and this is not a joke."
Smith pushed back, not so much on the idea that LSU had overreached, but on the notion that the school deserved the level of public condemnation the SEC was directing its way. He pointed to the broader legal landscape around extra eligibility and argued that LSU’s eventual retreat showed the conference had gotten the result it wanted without needing to escalate the situation further.
"Let me be very, very clear. I am in no way saying nor encouraging Lane Kiffin to break rules," said Smith.
"The issue is that there was clearly an avenue for him to do what he was doing, and then, the SEC stepped in and said no. When they said no, what happened?
Did it happen? No.
Did he put them on the roster? No....
That's the point. My point is they made noise, he backed down, he said it isn't worth it.
But clearly, he thought there was an avenue in order to do it and to do it legally. That's the issue."
Smith had already taken a more blunt shot earlier, telling the SEC to "sit your ass down."
The conference later backed off talk of expulsion, though it still could pursue other disciplinary measures against LSU.
In Other News...
Lane Kiffin Opens Up On Tiger Stadium As LSU Drama Lingers
Lane Kiffins first year on LSUs sideline brought him his first chance to work a game from the home side at Tiger Stadium, and the setting lived up to the reputation on a night that ended with a win over Clemson. For a coach who has spent plenty of time around big venues, the atmosphere in Baton Rouge is still its own kind of backdrop, and this one offered the full LSU experience right away.
The football part is only one layer of the story, though, because LSU is still dealing with an SEC lawsuit tied to recruiting former NFL players, a case that has been delayed by a judge. Kiffin did not add the two players at the center of the dispute to his roster, and the conference also left a recent meeting without announcing any punishments or reprimands, leaving the situation hanging as the season moves forward. [Read more 🡒]
Brian Kelly Just Added Fuel To LSU Fans Clemson Debate
Brian Kellys move into the CBS Sports booth has not kept him far from the conversation around LSU, especially when the Tigers come up in the same breath as Clemson. During a recent discussion of Clemsons uneven stretch, Kelly pointed to coaching and scheme as part of the reason the Tigers stumbled in their loss to LSU, arguing that talent alone does not solve everything when the structure around it is not working.
He also made clear that Clemsons roster looks different now than it did in its peak years, which only adds another layer to the long-running comparison between the programs. Kelly went on to address the recent tension between Dabo Swinney and a reporter, saying he was disappointed by how both sides handled the exchange, a comment that is likely to stir more debate among LSU fans who are still eager to measure what that win meant. [Read more 🡒]
LSUs Latest EA Simulation Exposed A Strange Problem Fans Will Notice
EA Sports College Football 27 already has LSU in the spotlight in a way Tigers fans will recognize, even if the result felt a little off from what you might expect on paper. In a simulated game, No. 8 LSU edged Louisiana Tech 17-6, a tidy win that still came with plenty of uneven offense and a box score that did not fully line up with the teams usual look.
The odd part was the way the game handled the running back rotation, with the simulation leaning into a setup that seemed out of step with the real depth chart. That sort of mismatch stands out even more when the rankings and ratings suggest LSU should have had a cleaner edge, which is why the exhibition-style result leaves just enough of a wrinkle for fans to notice and wonder how the game is sorting things out. [Read more 🡒]