Paul Finebaum didn’t back off his criticism of Lane Kiffin after LSU’s loss to Texas, and he didn’t pretend the Tigers’ 6-4 record feels good. But when asked whether LSU is actually better under Kiffin, Finebaum admitted he couldn’t say for sure.
On Tiger Rag Radio Tuesday, after Finebaum had called Kiffin a “broken man” on national television following Monday’s press conference, I asked whether that was a measured football judgment or the kind of “going for broke” TV take he has talked about before. Finebaum pushed back on the idea that he was chasing attention. He said he was responding to what he saw and heard from Kiffin.
He had every right to question the press conference. Kiffin was visibly upset, and LSU had just dropped another game it had a chance to win. At 6-4, the Tigers have not come close to the expectations that came with his hiring.
Finebaum went a step further, saying he now has to ask whether Kiffin is a great coach.
That opens the door to a football question, not just a personality one: is LSU better now than it was a year ago? I put the year-over-year numbers in front of Finebaum and asked him directly.
“I’ll just be very blunt. I don’t know. I cover college football from 38,000 feet.”
He was straightforward about his limits, and he also acknowledged that people who follow LSU closely may have a better read on the team than he does.
A closer look at the numbers points in one direction. LSU is averaging about 157 more yards and 13 more points per game on offense than it did last season.
The Tigers are also gaining roughly 69 more rushing yards per game. On defense, they are allowing about 66 fewer yards per game.
Through 10 games, LSU has 40 sacks, compared with 27 in 13 games last season.
None of that erases four losses. But it does show real improvement in the parts of the job a coach is paid to fix.
Kiffin still owns the late-game failures. LSU has let chances slip away, made costly mistakes and lost games it had in reach.
I have said that on the air and in print. If that keeps happening, it will define his tenure no matter what the stat sheet says.
Still, this is his first season, and the program is better than the one he inherited. Anyone questioning whether he can coach ought to weigh that alongside the losses.
Finebaum’s case for the harsh criticism is easy enough to understand. LSU went after Kiffin hard, paid him accordingly and brought him to Baton Rouge with huge expectations.
Finebaum thought the Tigers had a real shot at the playoff. From that point of view, 6-4 is a disappointment.
I agree.
A disappointing season and a better program can both be true. So can a rough press conference and solid coaching. Finebaum may have been right to hammer Kiffin’s demeanor, but his doubts about Kiffin’s football ability need more than the view from 38,000 feet.
He didn’t claim otherwise. He said he didn’t know whether LSU had improved because that’s how far removed he is.
The losses are obvious. So is Kiffin looking beat up at a microphone on a bad Monday.
The progress in the offense, defense and roster takes a closer look. Before deciding whether Kiffin can coach, Finebaum should take one.
In Other News...
LSU Suddenly Has A Fresh Roster Problem As Tennessee Looms
With Tennessee looming, LSU is trying to keep its focus on football while a different kind of roster issue has surfaced around the program. On the gridiron, Sam Leavitt has already acknowledged the turnover problems that have followed him this season, a reminder that LSU does not have much margin for error as it gets ready for a major SEC test.
The timing is awkward for a school that has enjoyed a strong start across campus, with both the womens and mens basketball teams opening undefeated and the men picking up recent wins over Gonzaga and ULM. But the latest wrinkle has come off the court, where coach Will Wade had said all players were eligible before LSU president Wade Rousse stepped in and ordered RJ Luis not to play because of eligibility concerns, leaving another roster question hanging over the program. [Read more 🡒]
LSU Just Turned RJ Luis Into A Much Bigger SEC Fight
LSUs handling of RJ Luis has quickly turned into more than a roster decision, becoming the latest flashpoint in the programs uneasy relationship with the SEC. After Luis made his debut, LSU reversed course on whether he would continue to play, and LSU System President Wade Rousse made clear the call came from above after further review. The situation has put coach Will Wade in the middle of a decision that is no longer just about basketball, but about how the school navigates a conference dispute with real consequences.
Luis attorney has already pushed back hard, criticizing the SECs threat of expulsion against LSU for playing the forward and underscoring how tense the standoff has become. For LSU, the issue is bigger than one players availability because it now sits at the intersection of eligibility, conference authority and institutional pressure. However the school proceeds, this is no longer a routine lineup matter, and the next move will say plenty about how far LSU is willing to go in this fight. [Read more 🡒]
Rece Davis Just Cast Doubt On LSU Before Tennessee Showdown
Rece Davis added another layer to the conversation around LSU this week by backing Tyrann Mathieus criticism of quarterback Sam Leavitt leaving the field before the team sang the alma mater after a loss. The College GameDay hosts comments landed in the middle of a broader debate about team standards and body language, with LSU head coach Lane Kiffin pushing back and saying the program does not traditionally sing the alma mater after losses.
The timing matters because LSU is already under the microscope heading into its matchup with Tennessee, and Davis made clear he sees the Tigers current struggles as part of the backdrop. Between the on-field issues and the scrutiny over how the team handled the moment afterward, LSU is carrying more than just game-day pressure into this one, and the conversation around Leavitt has only sharpened the attention on what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
