The latest College Football Playoff rankings have stirred up the same question across the sport: how is Alabama sitting so far ahead of Tennessee?
On Tuesday, the committee slotted the No. 3 Crimson Tide above the No.
8 Vols even though Tennessee beat Alabama by 16 points in October, and both teams are 7-2 heading into a pivotal Week 11. CFP rankings chairman Hunter Yurachek pointed to Alabama’s stronger strength of schedule when he was asked to explain the placement, but that answer clearly didn’t settle things for everyone.
SEC Nation’s Chase Daniel was among the loudest skeptics. The former Mizzou quarterback said Saturday morning that he’s “perplexed” by the ranking, arguing that it gives Alabama a much cleaner path to the playoff despite Tennessee owning the head-to-head win and carrying a comparable résumé.
“Alabama is No. 3 with 2 losses. Tennessee is No. 8, and if I remember correctly guys, did Alabama and Tennessee play each other in a head-to head game?
So why in the world is Alabama 3 and Tennessee 8?” Daniel said.
“… You’re calling your good wins Kentucky, South Carolina, LSU. Here’s what this does and here’s my problem with it.
I think Tennessee should be a little higher, but if Alabama somehow, some way slips up, say they get into the SEC Championship game and lose. They’re in.
The committee is telling you they value their wins and they value that team. If Tennessee were to lose another game, the chances of them getting into the CFP is much lower… how in the world are they 5 spots higher?
I don’t get it. That, to me, is the most perplexing thing of these rankings.”
Alabama’s case is built on what it has already banked. The Tide have three wins over teams currently in the top 25: Kentucky, South Carolina and LSU. The committee also appears to be giving weight to Alabama’s win over Mississippi State and Kamario Taylor, even though Taylor was injured before the matchup and left early.
The catch is that Alabama has no ranked opponents left on the regular-season schedule.
Tennessee’s path looks different. The Vols have top-25 wins over Alabama and Kentucky, and they still have LSU coming to Knoxville.
Tennessee owns the best win between the two teams, but Alabama has more quality wins right now. The Vols also lost to South Carolina, while Alabama’s two losses came against Georgia and Tennessee.
That, for now, seems to be the committee’s logic for putting Alabama ahead of Tennessee after Week 10.
If both teams finish 10-2, though, the debate gets a lot simpler. In that scenario, Alabama and Tennessee would each have three top-25 wins and two top-25 losses, assuming the current rankings hold. At that point, the head-to-head result would be the obvious separator.
Until then, it’s all hypothetical.
In Other News...
LSU Just Lost An Early Recruiting Fight That Should Sting Fans
LSU took a hit on the recruiting trail when Tanner Seaton, one of the top interior offensive linemen in the 2028 class, chose Ole Miss over a group of SEC suitors that included the Tigers, Tennessee and Mississippi State. The Madison, Mississippi, standout gives the Rebels an early anchor in a class that is already drawing attention, and it is the kind of in-state decision that always lands a little harder for programs trying to build regional momentum.
For LSU, the sting is less about one commitment in November of the cycle and more about who got there first. Ole Miss now has five pledges in its 2028 group, and its class sits sixth nationally in the 247Sports Composite, a strong early start for a rival that has been aggressive in the state. The Tigers will keep working, but losing a priority lineman this early is the sort of miss that can echo beyond one recruitment. [Read more 🡒]
Brian Kelly Could Be Headed For Another Power 4 Chance
Brian Kelly is back in the coaching conversation after interviewing for Marylands head coaching opening following the firing of Mike Locksley. For LSU fans still sorting through the end of his tenure in Baton Rouge, it is another reminder of how quickly the college football carousel can spin, especially for a coach with his rsum and Power 4 experience.
Kelly has already acknowledged that he did not meet LSUs expectations of delivering a national championship during his time there, even though he left with a 34-14 record. Now working as an on-air analyst for CBS Sports, he could be positioning himself for another major opportunity, with Maryland representing a potential next stop that will be watched closely from afar in Baton Rouge. [Read more 🡒]
LSU Fans Have A Painful Lane Kiffin Question To Ask
LSUs playoff path took another hit Saturday night, and the frustration was easy to understand. Under Lane Kiffin, the Tigers had Texas on the ropes after leading late in the third quarter, but the offense went cold when it mattered most and the game slipped away in a result that felt especially damaging given the stakes.
The fourth quarter told the story, with LSU managing only 22 yards and turning the ball over repeatedly, including three interceptions by quarterback Sam Leavitt. It also came on the heels of the home loss to Alabama, making this the first time LSU has dropped back-to-back home games since 1994, and leaving fans with an uncomfortable question about how much margin for error is left. [Read more 🡒]
