Lane Kiffin had plenty to think about on that fourth-and-1 at Kentucky, but the decision to punt still landed as the kind of move that invites second-guessing the moment it leaves the foot.
LSU was up 27-24 at the Tigers’ 43-yard line with 1:46 left on Saturday night, and the case for kicking it away was real. The defense had been sturdy, forcing missed field goal tries on Kentucky’s last two possessions, including one drive that started at LSU’s 13-yard line.
Kentucky had already burned all of its timeouts, so a decent punt with no return would pin the Wildcats back and make life miserable with the clock nearly gone. That’s exactly what happened, with Kentucky beginning its next series at its 19 with 1:37 remaining.
There was also the state of LSU’s run game to consider. The interior line has been a problem all season, and that showed up in the short-yardage package. Add in the wind, plus Adam Zouagui’s misses from 42 and 26 yards earlier, and the punt choice had a logical path.
Still, this was Lane Kiffin, and that matters. With Kiffin’s offense and Charlie Weis Jr. calling plays, the idea of getting less than a yard should never feel out of reach.
A first down would have essentially ended it. LSU even had the option of snapping to quarterback Sam Leavitt, letting him take three knees and drain the rest of the game.
Instead, Kentucky marched down the field and got another chance. Zouagui finally cashed in from 33 yards with 12 seconds left to force a 27-27 tie, and the Wildcats finished the job in overtime, 35-34.
“I was surprised he didn’t go for it,” On3 national columnist Chris Low said on Tiger Rag Radio Tuesday night. Low, who spent years at ESPN and has covered Kiffin since 2009, said the call stood out because of the situation and because of what Kiffin usually brings to the table.
“It was fourth and a little bit less than a yard,” Low said. “He could’ve ended the game, and knowing him as long as I have and watching his career, yeah, I was surprised he didn’t go for it there.
But Lane is smart enough to realize what the situation is. He trusted his defense there to stop them.
I get it. I think if he had a mulligan, and we all want mulligans in life, he probably would’ve gone for it.
And I bet he will be going for it.”
Low doesn’t think Kiffin has turned into a conservative coach overnight.
“I don’t think that’s changed,” he said.
The bigger picture, from his view, was that LSU had spent heavily for this exact kind of moment. That’s why he thought the fourth-down call was so hard to defend.
“You’re paying both those guys (Kiffin and Weis) a ton of money,” Low said. “You paid a ton of money to put that roster together (particularly on offense). And if you’re an LSU fan, you step back and take emotion out of it and say, ‘You know what, if we can’t get fourth and less than a yard with everything we’ve invested in the program with one of the better offensive minds out there in Kiffin, we probably don’t deserve to win anyway.'”
LSU, now 4-2 overall and 1-2 in the SEC, gets its next shot Saturday when No. 16 Mississippi State comes to town for an 11 a.m. game on ESPN.
In Other News...
Lane Kiffin Family Drama Adds To LSU Fans' Frustration After Loss
The mood around LSU was already sour after the upset loss to Kentucky, and Lane Kiffin did little to lift it when he pointed to execution errors and turnovers as the reasons the Tigers let one get away. For a fan base expecting a steadier response, the defeat only deepened the frustration around a season that has already produced too many anxious Saturdays.
Then came a bit of added off-field noise during the Red River Rivalry, when Landry Kiffin drew attention online by showing support for several SEC programs, including LSU, Ole Miss and Texas. The social media criticism that followed was less about football allegiance than the timing, since LSU supporters were already bristling over the loss and looking for something, anything, to settle the conversation back on the field. [Read more 🡒]
Lane Kiffin Faces A Dangerous LSU Temptation Right Now
LSUs fast start has given way to a rougher stretch in league play, and the Tigers are suddenly trying to steady themselves after consecutive SEC losses. There have still been flashes of what this team can become, especially on offense, but the inconsistency has been hard to ignore. Too often, LSU has left plays on the field in the moments that matter most, and the defensive effort has followed a similar pattern, with strong outings mixed in with performances that have not held up against conference competition.
For Lane Kiffin, the appeal is obvious because the talent is there and the upside has already shown up in stretches. The challenge now is figuring out whether LSU can turn those promising pieces into something more durable before the seasons biggest games start to define it. The Tigers have enough capability to stay in the conversation, but the margin for error keeps shrinking until the execution catches up with the potential. [Read more 🡒]
LSU Brings Auburn Fans A Bigger Question Than Media Day Absences
LSUs trip to SEC Media Day in Birmingham ended up looking a little thinner than planned, with coach Will Wade and several members of the program left behind by weather problems in Baton Rouge. The same travel issue also kept transfers Abdi Bashir Jr. and Mouhamed Dioubate from making the event, while Kim Mulkey and several LSU womens players were also absent from their own session, turning what should have been a routine preseason stop into a logistics story almost as much as a basketball one.
Beneath the inconvenience, though, the more interesting question for LSU is what the roster actually looks like once the season gets moving. The programs official group has been updated to 10 players, but several names still are not appearing there, and Wade has already been open about taking an unconventional approach to building out this team. For Auburn fans and everyone else around the league, the media-day absences were only the surface issue. The bigger issue is figuring out how complete LSU really is before the real games begin. [Read more 🡒]