College GameDay had its full Week 1 picking panel on Saturday morning, and the group didn’t waste time diving into the biggest games on the slate. With LSU and Clemson set for a major showdown and other matchups like Auburn-Baylor, Cal-UCLA and Ole Miss-Louisville in the mix, Pat McAfee, Desmond Howard, Nick Saban, Rece Davis and Kirk Herbstreit were joined by Lainey Wilson to weigh in on the SEC race, the national title picture and several marquee openers.
The SEC champion picks were split in a way that set up an interesting season-long debate. Desmond Howard and Kirk Herbstreit both went with Texas, while Saban and McAfee backed Georgia. Wilson landed on LSU.
The national title predictions were even more spread out. Howard again chose Texas, Saban picked Miami, McAfee went with Indiana, Wilson selected LSU and Herbstreit named Notre Dame.
When it came to Auburn-Baylor in Atlanta, there was no disagreement at all. Every picker on the panel leaned Auburn: Howard, Saban, Wilson, McAfee and Herbstreit all took the Tigers.
The same unanimity showed up for No. 13 Alabama against East Carolina. Howard, Saban, McAfee, Wilson and Herbstreit all picked Alabama.
For No. 9 Ole Miss against No.
24 Louisville in Nashville, the panel was again locked in. Howard, Saban, McAfee, Wilson and Herbstreit all chose Ole Miss.
The only game that didn’t include a full Herbstreit pick was Clemson at No. 11 LSU, since he’s calling the game. The rest of the group still gave LSU the nod: Howard, Saban, Wilson and McAfee all picked the Tigers.
By the time the show wrapped, the message was clear: the panel sees Texas, Georgia, LSU, Auburn and Alabama as the teams to watch in Week 1’s biggest matchups. Now it’s up to the games to sort out who gets to feel smartest by the end of the weekend.
In Other News...
LSU Fans Had Plenty To Say About GameDay In Baton Rouge
Baton Rouge got the full College GameDay treatment to open the season, and Lainey Wilson was right in the middle of it. Ahead of her turn as the Week 1 celebrity guest picker, the Louisiana native performed the shows intro song and then rolled into her hit Cant Sit Still, giving LSU fans an early jolt before the real football talk took over.
The reaction online was quick and mixed, with plenty of viewers taking aim at both Wilsons performance and ESPNs decision to alter the familiar GameDay opening. Even so, not every fan was bothered by the change, and some seemed more welcoming of Wilsons presence than other parts of the broadcast. For a show built on tradition, it was a reminder that even a familiar Saturday ritual can still stir up a debate in Tiger country. [Read more 🡒]
LSU Drama Just Drew A Warning Tigers Fans Can't Ignore
The eligibility dispute around LSU and former NFL players has already escaped the usual offseason noise and turned into something much bigger, with Paul Finebaum weighing in sharply on the back-and-forth involving Lane Kiffin, the Tigers and the SEC. Finebaum praised commissioner Greg Sankey and the conference presidents for how they handled the matter, but his comments also underscored how quickly a rules question can become a referendum on the people running a program.
For LSU, the uncomfortable part is not just the original issue, but the way it has invited scrutiny about leadership and the possibility of larger fallout if the situation keeps escalating. Finebaum even floated the idea that SEC presidents could talk about removing LSU from the league, though he made clear that outcome is unlikely, which is a reminder of how much tension this episode has created around a program that would rather be talking about football. [Read more 🡒]
College GameDay Took A Strange Turn Before LSU Clemson Even Kicked Off
ESPNs College GameDay got the kind of Baton Rouge welcome nobody had on the script for LSU-Clemson, as lightning forced the network to hit pause during its 40th season kickoff show. What was supposed to be the usual charged, early-morning buildup around the Tigers instead turned into a weather delay that sent the crew scrambling and changed the feel of the entire broadcast before the game even started.
When the show came back, it did so from inside an empty theater, a sharp contrast to the packed scene fans expected from one of college footballs biggest opening weekends. The interruption and relocation quickly became part of the conversation around the day, a strange little pregame wrinkle that stood out almost as much as the matchup itself. [Read more 🡒]