Arch Mannings LSU Finish Just Fueled A Texas Debate Fans Hate

Ryan Clark urges caution in evaluating Arch Manning's potential as a first-round NFL draft pick, questioning whether his performance justifies the hype spurred by his famous family name.

Ryan Clark isn’t buying the Arch Manning first-round buzz just yet.

After Texas pulled out a 22-21 comeback win over LSU on Saturday, Nov. 14, the former NFL safety and ex-ESPN analyst went on X and made it clear he thinks the hype around Manning is getting ahead of the tape. Clark argued that Manning’s name and family background should not carry weight when NFL teams start stacking him against other draft prospects.

“There’s no way an NFL scout can responsibly walk into a draft room, stand on the table and tell a GM that Arch Manning is a first-round pick,” Clark posted on X. “At this point, making that recommendation would be a dereliction of duty.

The name, the pedigree, and the potential can’t outweigh what you’ve actually put on tape. #TexasLSU”

Manning certainly gave Texas a finish to remember in Baton Rouge. He capped the game with a 4-yard touchdown pass to Raleek Brown with three seconds left, turning a tense final possession into a win. Texas had taken over with 2 minutes, 19 seconds remaining and still trailed 21-16, but Manning helped drive the Longhorns down the field by converting three third downs before the winning throw.

The ending was huge. The full performance was a lot messier.

Manning finished with 174 passing yards, a touchdown and three interceptions, going 19 of 35 through the air. He also scored an early rushing touchdown as Texas moved to 8-2, a result that kept the Longhorns’ College Football Playoff hopes alive.

The scrutiny around Manning has been building all season because of who he is. He’s the grandson of Archie Manning and the nephew of Peyton and Eli Manning, a family tree that has only intensified the attention on every snap.

Through 10 games, Manning has thrown for 2,198 yards with 19 touchdowns and 10 interceptions. He’s also added 126 rushing yards and three rushing touchdowns.

Clark’s point was simple: the upside is there, but the production has to carry more weight than the pedigree. Manning’s late-game poise against LSU gave him another highlight moment, but the three picks are still part of the evaluation.

In Other News...

LSU Just Lost An Early Recruiting Fight That Should Sting Fans

LSU took a hit on the recruiting trail when Tanner Seaton, one of the top interior offensive linemen in the 2028 class, chose Ole Miss over a group of SEC suitors that included the Tigers, Tennessee and Mississippi State. The Madison, Mississippi, standout gives the Rebels an early anchor in a class that is already drawing attention, and it is the kind of in-state decision that always lands a little harder for programs trying to build regional momentum.

For LSU, the sting is less about one commitment in November of the cycle and more about who got there first. Ole Miss now has five pledges in its 2028 group, and its class sits sixth nationally in the 247Sports Composite, a strong early start for a rival that has been aggressive in the state. The Tigers will keep working, but losing a priority lineman this early is the sort of miss that can echo beyond one recruitment. [Read more 🡒]

Brian Kelly Could Be Headed For Another Power 4 Chance

Brian Kelly is back in the coaching conversation after interviewing for Marylands head coaching opening following the firing of Mike Locksley. For LSU fans still sorting through the end of his tenure in Baton Rouge, it is another reminder of how quickly the college football carousel can spin, especially for a coach with his rsum and Power 4 experience.

Kelly has already acknowledged that he did not meet LSUs expectations of delivering a national championship during his time there, even though he left with a 34-14 record. Now working as an on-air analyst for CBS Sports, he could be positioning himself for another major opportunity, with Maryland representing a potential next stop that will be watched closely from afar in Baton Rouge. [Read more 🡒]

LSU Fans Have A Painful Lane Kiffin Question To Ask

LSUs playoff path took another hit Saturday night, and the frustration was easy to understand. Under Lane Kiffin, the Tigers had Texas on the ropes after leading late in the third quarter, but the offense went cold when it mattered most and the game slipped away in a result that felt especially damaging given the stakes.

The fourth quarter told the story, with LSU managing only 22 yards and turning the ball over repeatedly, including three interceptions by quarterback Sam Leavitt. It also came on the heels of the home loss to Alabama, making this the first time LSU has dropped back-to-back home games since 1994, and leaving fans with an uncomfortable question about how much margin for error is left. [Read more 🡒]