Arch Manning Just Reignited Texas Fans' Biggest NFL Debate

Can Arch Manning's resilience under pressure help him carve out an NFL future, or will he follow in Tim Tebow's footsteps?

Arch Manning’s night in Death Valley gave everyone plenty to chew on, and Paul Finebaum wasted no time reaching for a familiar comparison.

After Manning delivered a brilliant game-winning touchdown with two seconds left to stun LSU, Finebaum said Monday on First Take, “He’s the gutsiest quarterback I have seen since Tim Tebow,” Finebaum said on Monday’s First Take. “I have never seen anybody put a team on his back after screwing up as much as he has.”

The throw came after Manning had already thrown three interceptions, which made the finish even more striking. One snap earlier in the game, he looked like a quarterback who had been through every possible swing in the same night. Then he flipped it with one perfect pass.

That’s the strange space Manning occupies right now. At Texas, he’s become the kind of player who can look brilliant, shaky and completely unpredictable all in the same stretch. Saturday night fit that profile perfectly.

Finebaum’s Tebow line lands because Manning has become one of college football’s most polarizing figures, and the comparison is really about more than just the throw. It’s about the way he kept going after the mistakes piled up. He made chicken salad out of some not so good stuff, and the LSU pass was the kind of play that can wipe away a lot of the mess that came before it.

There’s also a practical angle here for NFL teams. Resilience matters.

So does the ability to handle pressure without blinking. If Manning keeps showing that kind of response in big moments, it’s hard to imagine him slipping too far when his name finally hits the draft conversation.

Of course, Tebow’s NFL career never matched the hype around him, so Manning would still have to prove there’s more here than toughness and timing. But after Saturday, the conversation around him just got a lot louder.

In Other News...

LSU Found A Few Bright Spots In Another Frustrating Texas Loss

LSU had enough good moments against Texas to make the loss sting a little more, because the Tigers outgained the Longhorns by nearly 100 yards and spent much of the game in control. Even in defeat, there were individual performances worth noting, with the defense getting solid work from Ty Benefield and Jordan Ross while the offense found some life through Jackson Harris and Dilin Jones.

Those bright spots mattered because they showed LSU was not overmatched so much as undone by the kind of details that decide tight games. Pro Football Focus grades backed up the eye test on several of those players, giving the Tigers a few concrete positives to carry forward, even if the final result against Texas still left plenty to sort through. [Read more 🡒]

Tennessee QB Uncertainty Just Changed The Feel Of LSU's Biggest Test

The lead-up to LSUs biggest test of the season got a little more complicated when Tennessee quarterback George MacIntyre came out of a recent game with a knee injury. Even so, the Volunteers are still planning as if hell be available, and head coach Josh Heupel said MacIntyre looked good in practice as Tennessee begins the week of preparation for the Tigers.

For LSU, the uncertainty matters because MacIntyre has been a key part of Tennessees push to stay in the SEC Championship Game and College Football Playoff race. Heupel said the staff will keep monitoring him through the week, which leaves the Tigers facing a familiar kind of late-season tension: preparing for a quarterback who may be limited, or preparing for one who is ready to go. [Read more 🡒]

LSU Pressure Mounts As Lane Kiffin Faces An Accountability Reckoning

The scrutiny around LSUs season has only sharpened with the Tigers headed into their next game against Tennessee, and Paul Finebaum added to it on First Take by taking aim at Lane Kiffins handling of the programs struggles. Finebaums criticism centered on what he viewed as a lack of accountability, arguing that the coach has been too quick to point fingers instead of owning the results on the field.

For LSU, the frustration is bigger than one bad stretch. The expectation in Baton Rouge is always tied to the College Football Playoff conversation, and Finebaum made clear he does not see that path opening this season. His broader point was even less forgiving, casting Kiffin as a coach whose teams have too often come up short when the stakes are highest, a charge that will only hang heavier as the Tigers move deeper into the schedule. [Read more 🡒]