The Los Angeles Rams took a swing on special teams creativity, but the Joshua Karty kickoff experiment has reached the point where the results are hard to ignore.
After losing Blake Grupe to injury, the Rams added Brandon McManus, their third kicker this season, and also brought back Karty. The idea was simple enough: let McManus handle field goals and extra points, and use Karty only for kickoffs, where his knuckleball style was supposed to help the Rams steal better field position. Instead, the numbers from three games have pushed the team toward a different conclusion.
Karty’s kickoffs have been a mixed bag at best. Half of them have ended in either a penalty or a kick into the end zone.
Only two have landed in the landing zone and carried into the end zone, which put the ball at the 20-yard line. Six others were returned, and opposing offenses have averaged starting at the 37.5-yard line.
That doesn’t mean Karty should be shown the door. He has done exactly what the Rams asked of him, and given the team’s bad luck this season, keeping a backup kicker around on the roster or practice squad makes sense. But making him a specialist for the new kickoff rules no longer looks like a winning bet.
McManus, meanwhile, has given the Rams stability. He is perfect on five field-goal attempts and 14 extra points.
Karty’s 2025 numbers tell a different story: he made 10 of 15 field goals and 23 of 26 extra points. Kickers can lose it, then find it again just as fast, and the Rams still believe Karty can get back to the level he showed as a rookie.
For now, though, the safer move looks obvious. If the Rams don’t trust their coverage unit to handle returns, the answer is to kick the ball out of the end zone and let the defense start at the 35-yard line.
In Other News...
Rams Had One Very Encouraging Sign In That Blowout Win
The Rams 34-6 rout of the Cardinals came with more than just a lopsided score line. It also delivered a string of individual milestones that spoke to how well the offense and supporting cast were functioning, from rookie receiver CJ Daniels grabbing his first career catch to Ronnie Rivers setting a career-high in rushing yards.
Blake Corum also turned in his first 100-yard rushing game of the season, while Xavier Smith found the end zone for the first time in the NFL. Even Aaron Donald got in on the celebration with his first sack since unretiring, a reminder that the Rams are getting meaningful contributions from all over the roster at a time when that kind of depth matters. [Read more 🡒]
Rams Receiver Battle Just Got Tougher With Key Returns Near
The Rams got a useful look at the depth of their receiver room in the Week 10 win over Arizona, and the snap-by-snap picture was encouraging for a group that has had to carry more responsibility than expected. CJ Daniels, Konata Mumpfield, Xavier Smith and Tutu Atwell all had moments that mattered, whether it was creating separation, handling extra targets or simply showing they can function in roles that may not come with much margin for error once the roster gets healthier.
After the Week 11 bye, that receiver picture is about to change in a hurry with Davante Adams and Puka Nacua expected back in the mix. For the players who stepped up against the Cardinals, the challenge now is not just proving they can help in a pinch, but making a case for how they fit when the Rams have more options and more competition for snaps, routes and touches. [Read more 🡒]
Rams Suddenly Have A Huge Thanksgiving Eve Question To Watch
The Packers loss to the Vikings added a little more intrigue to a Thanksgiving Eve matchup that already had plenty of it, because Matt LaFleur said his plan is for Micah Parsons to play against the Rams. For Los Angeles, that turns a cross-conference game into a much more complicated scouting assignment, since Parsons changes the way an offense has to prepare for Green Bay from the first snap.
Parsons is still working back from the torn ACL he suffered last season, and while he has been cleared for practice, there are still hurdles to clear before anything is truly final. So the Rams are left watching the situation closely, knowing the difference between a planned return and an actual one can matter a lot when a player with Parsons impact is involved. [Read more 🡒]
