The Yankees are heading into a brutal stretch with a lineup that has too many soft spots and not enough answers, and the schedule is about to test every one of them. They entered Sunday with the fewest wins against winning teams in baseball at 15-16, and their first 22 games after the break come against winning clubs. That run also includes six games against Seattle and Toronto, both 2025 playoff teams.
Aaron Judge is still out, and the timeline remains murky. He has missed almost two months because of a fractured rib and still has not been cleared to start baseball activities. The Yankees still expect him back before the regular season ends, but the ramp-up to get him postseason-ready now looks like it could be short.
Even with Judge, though, this group has a clear weakness against left-handed pitching. Without him, it becomes even easier to attack. The Dodgers showed exactly how on Friday, when they used three straight left-handed relievers to finish off a 2-1 win, getting 10 outs while giving up just one hit.
That is why a right-handed hitting catcher should be near the top of New York’s trade deadline wish list. Minnesota’s Ryan Jeffers would fit cleanly, but the Twins have turned into a surprise playoff team and now lead the AL in runs per game.
Cincinnati’s Tyler Stephenson could be available, though he is hitting .192 against left-handers and is a below average bat. Colorado’s Hunter Goodman, who has hit 18 of his 27 homers away from Denver, would come at an enormous price if he were even available.
Washington’s Keibert Ruiz, who is hitting .307 against lefties, might be the most logical target.
The bigger problem behind the plate is that Austin Wells has fallen off in a way that is hard to explain. He cannot handle breaking pitches, hitting .093 against them, and he is batting .198 over the past two seasons.
The Yankees’ catchers as a group are hitting .175, which is a franchise worst in the live ball era. And while that sounds uniquely ugly, the position has been rough across the league too. This season, three teams are getting below a .180 batting average from their catchers, matching the total from the previous 105 years.
Kyle Tucker is supposed to be the Dodgers’ big-ticket answer, but so far the fit has been jarring. Including the luxury tax penalty, Los Angeles is paying him $119.7 million this season, a figure that tops the Opening Day payrolls of 11 teams. Ninety-two games into his four-year, $240 million contract, the 29-year-old has been a major disappointment.
The bat has not carried the deal. Tucker has posted career full-season lows in bat speed at 71.3, exit velocity at 88.8, hard-hit percentage at 39%, rollover groundballs at 22.4%, barrel rate at 5.8%, two-strike hitting at .165 and runners in scoring position at .247. His frustration has shown at times, though manager Dave Roberts believes there may be signs of life.
“The quality of his at-bats the past two weeks has been the best it’s been all year,” Roberts says. “There have been times when he’ll go into the cage after games and work with the hitting guys.”
The concern goes beyond the bat. Tucker’s defense and baserunning have also slipped.
His fielding run value has gone from 0 last year, when he ranked in the 52nd percentile, to -3 this year, which puts him in the 22nd percentile, and his range has noticeably declined. His baserunning value and sprint speed have been trending down as well, and he has not attempted a stolen base in more than a month.
The Dodgers paid a premium in average annual value to land Tucker on a short-term deal meant to capture his prime without paying for the decline years. Right now, that is not the player they thought they were getting.
In Other News...
Dodgers Make Concerning Will Smith Move Before Phillies Game
The Dodgers made a roster shuffle ahead of their matchup with the Phillies, optioning right-hander Landon Knack to Triple-A and bringing left-hander Charlie Barnes back onto the active roster. Barnes gives Los Angeles another multi-inning relief option, while the move also cleared the way on the 40-man roster as the club continues to manage its catching depth.
The more notable part of the transaction was the change involving Will Smith, who was moved to the 60-day injured list because of his lingering neck stiffness. Manager Dave Roberts has already been updating the situation, and the timeline points to a longer absence than the Dodgers would prefer, leaving the team to keep adjusting around one of its most important everyday players. [Read more 🡒]
Dodgers Face A Surprising Deadline Test As Injuries Keep Mounting
Shohei Ohtani and Will Smith being sidelined would normally send a team into a scramble, especially this time of year, but the Dodgers are not treating the injuries as a signal to abandon their broader plan. Multiple team sources say the front offices deadline approach has not changed, with the club still weighing depth and long-term value as much as any short-term fix.
Will Smiths absence has sharpened the conversation around catching, with Dalton Rushing stepping into the role, but the Dodgers do not appear bent on forcing a backup-catcher move just because the position is suddenly thinner. Instead, the bigger priority seems to be strengthening a farm system that already has top-end talent but could use more overall depth across the roster, a reminder that Los Angeles is still thinking well beyond the next week. [Read more 🡒]
Mookie Betts Just Put A Real End Date On His Career
Mookie Betts has already built a rsum that would define most careers, with four World Series rings and three of them coming in Los Angeles. Even with a slow start to this season and the lingering effects of an oblique injury that cost him time, the Dodgers star has still looked like the kind of player who can shape a lineup and a clubhouse, which is why his place in the franchises recent run feels so firmly established.
What makes the conversation more interesting now is the way Betts has started to frame the back end of his career. He is under contract through 2031, but he has also made it clear he wants to finish on his own terms, which adds a little more weight to every season left in Dodger blue. For a player who has spent so much of his career winning and setting the standard, the next chapter is starting to feel like it will be written on his schedule, not anyone elses. [Read more 🡒]