Dodgers Suddenly Face A Bigger Shohei Ohtani Question

Could Shohei Ohtani's dual-role aspirations be hindered by advice from one of Japan's greatest legends?

Shohei Ohtani’s two-way brilliance has already given the Dodgers plenty to celebrate, but one of Japanese baseball’s biggest voices thinks the next move is obvious: leave the mound behind for good.

That view comes from Sadaharu Oh, the Yomiuri Giants icon who owns the world record with 868 home runs across 22 seasons from 1959-80. Oh recently weighed in on Ohtani’s bat and his arm, and through Satoshi Iizuka of Kyodo News, he made his stance clear.

"Personally, I think he should focus solely on batting and challenge himself to see how far he can go," said Oh.

It’s a notable opinion from a figure with that kind of stature, especially given how closely Ohtani’s career has been watched in Japan and across the baseball world. Ohtani grew up idolizing Hall of Famer Ichiro Suzuki, but he was certainly aware of Oh’s place in the sport long before reaching Los Angeles.

The timing of Oh’s comments also lines up with a season that showed both sides of Ohtani’s value - and the strain that comes with trying to do everything. In 2024, his first year with the Dodgers, he put up a 9.0 bWAR and won his third MVP award without pitching at all.

In 2025, he eased back onto the mound and delivered a 2.87 ERA over 47 innings, then added another 20.1 postseason innings with a 4.43 ERA. That season ended with his fourth MVP and third straight.

Then came 2026, when Ohtani opened the year as both a hitter and a pitcher for the first time. He looked every bit like an ace in the first half, posting a 1.79 ERA in 85.2 innings before a nagging knee injury - one he said bothered him more on the mound than at the plate - knocked him out of the rotation for the rest of the season.

At the plate, he was rolling early too. Ohtani hit .293 with a .953 OPS and 22 home runs before the Midsummer Classic, putting himself on track for yet another MVP-level campaign.

But the second half told a different story. While dealing with the knee issue and later revealing a bicep injury, he hit just .245 with eight home runs after the break.

That slide carried into October, where he batted .192 in 26 postseason at-bats.

Ohtani has said earlier this season that he prefers to pitch and hit in the same games. Still, if injuries start piling up again in 2027 - especially if pitching is part of the problem - the Dodgers will have a tough call to make about how far they want to push to protect a bat as central as his.

In Other News...

Dodgers Face A Costly Infield Decision After Key Departures

The Dodgers are already looking ahead to how they patch up the infield after a pair of familiar faces moved on, and the early free-agent market has given them a couple of practical options. According to The Athletic, Los Angeles has shown interest in Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Mauricio Dubon as it weighs how to replace the departures of Miguel Rojas, who retired, and Kike Hernandez, who is now a free agent.

Both players bring the kind of flexibility the Dodgers tend to value, with the club evaluating not just defense but whether either can add enough offense to make the fit worthwhile. It is the sort of decision that can quietly shape a roster for months, especially for a team that likes to keep its bench and infield mix adaptable, and the next move will say plenty about how aggressively the Dodgers want to address that opening. [Read more 🡒]

Dodgers May Be Letting A Rival Steal A Major Rotation Prize

Tarik Skubal has quickly become one of the most closely watched names on the market, with the Dodgers among the clubs circling as they weigh how far to go for a frontline arm. Los Angeles has been tied to a short-term, high-value approach, which fits the way the club often balances urgency with long-term flexibility, but it is not the only contender in the mix. The Mets, Padres and Blue Jays are also involved, turning this into the kind of bidding situation that can move fast once one team decides to push harder.

The Blue Jays, in particular, appear capable of changing the conversation if they decide to lean into a longer-term proposal, the sort of structure they reportedly explored with Kyle Tucker. That leaves the Dodgers in an interesting spot, interested but maybe not yet as aggressive as some of the other suitors. With talks still ongoing, the question is whether Los Angeles is waiting for the market to come to it or whether a rival is about to set the pace on one of the winters biggest rotation prizes. [Read more 🡒]

Dodgers Face One Contract Problem In Tarik Skubal Pursuit

Tarik Skubals arrival last season gave the Dodgers exactly what they hoped for when they swung the trade, and he backed it up with strong work in both the regular season and the postseason. So it is no surprise that Los Angeles is expected to stay in the mix if the left-hander reaches free agency, especially for a club that has never shied away from chasing elite talent when it believes the fit is right.

The complication is the kind that can shape an entire winter: money. The Dodgers have to weigh the expected cost of a long-term Skubal deal against broader financial concerns, including the possibility of a future MLB salary cap, and that could make them more cautious than usual about how far they go. Even with their track record of landing top free agents, this is the sort of contract decision that can force a team to choose between staying aggressive and protecting its long-term flexibility. [Read more 🡒]