Shohei Ohtani left the Dodgers’ season with more questions than answers, and the biggest one may be what comes next for his body.
After Game 4 of the NLCS, Ohtani said he plans to pitch in 2027, but he was not sure whether he will need surgery to deal with one or two lingering injuries - to his knee and biceps - that have bothered him since July.
That uncertainty hangs over a postseason in which the Dodgers learned the hard way that Ohtani was not operating at full strength. He came through with one huge swing in Game 4, driving a ball with two runners on to put Los Angeles ahead 4-0 against the Milwaukee Brewers.
But the rest of the night told a different story. Ohtani went down in his other three at-bats, twice swinging and once looking, and the Dodgers never held the advantage.
Milwaukee chipped away, erased the lead, and Los Angeles had no answer.
The Dodgers were right about one thing: Ohtani had one good postseason swing in him.
If the Dodgers had finished off that game, Dave Roberts probably would have been able to point to that moment and defend his decision. He would have been able to say, “See? This is why we don't bench Shohei Ohtani.”
Instead, the rest of the game made that call look reckless. Ohtani’s other trips to the plate only reinforced how limited he was, and the Brewers took control from there.
For anyone who watched him swing this October, the need for some kind of operation felt obvious. This wasn’t the sort of issue that disappears overnight, no matter what the Dodgers may have tried to sell their fans.
The bigger problem is that both Ohtani and the Dodgers may be stuck living with this for a while. They are going to have to answer for how they handled the situation, perhaps until Ohtani proves he can survive a full season as a healthy two-way player - and even that may never happen.
The closest he has come to doing both in the same year was 2022. That season, he pitched a career-high 166 innings and appeared in 157 games as a hitter. He also hit 34 home runs and drove in 95 runs, though his numbers at the plate still reflected a step back.
Ohtani is in his early 30s now, an age when wear and tear starts to show up on players. The Dodgers put that reality on display for everyone this postseason, and the disconnect will keep lingering if they continue acting as if he is somehow above it.
Maybe Ohtani gets through an offseason surgery or two and returns in 2027 even better. But the Dodgers can’t assume that. What happened this year demands accountability from everyone involved, and if Los Angeles wants to get back to being the team to beat, the communication around Ohtani has to get a lot better.
In Other News...
Dodgers Move On From A Fan Favorite Catcher With Little Path Back
Ben Rortvedts run with the Dodgers appears to have reached its end, with the catcher electing free agency after being designated for assignment on Sept. 1. He spent the rest of the season in the organization on a minor league contract, and his brief big league stay included 16 major league games with Los Angeles.
For the Dodgers, it is another sign that the catching picture is crowded and that there was little room for a return trip. Rortvedt is now expected to look for his next opportunity elsewhere heading into the coming season, while Los Angeles moves forward with multiple catchers already on its 40-man roster. [Read more 🡒]
Freddie Freeman Shares Dodgers Regret After Miguel Rojas Decision
Miguel Rojas is closing the book on a 13-year MLB career that included multiple stints with the Dodgers, and his announcement lands with a little extra weight around a clubhouse that knows exactly what he meant to the organization. Rojas had even left open the possibility of coming back if Los Angeles had managed to win a third straight title, a reminder of how much this past seasons finish shaped the conversation around his future.
Instead, the Dodgers were swept in the National League Championship Series, and the end of that run helped set the stage for Rojas to move on from playing. He is expected to transition into a role within the Dodgers front office, keeping him close to the organization even as his days on the field are over, and it leaves one more what-if tied to a player who clearly meant a lot to the teams core. [Read more 🡒]
Dodgers Prospects Are Giving Fans An Early Look At Two Intriguing Arms
The Arizona Fall League has already offered a small window into the Dodgers next wave, with Glendale Desert Dogs giving the organization a chance to spread around playing time and see who is standing out early. Charles Davalan has started to find a rhythm after a quiet stretch, while Chase Harlan has flashed the kind of power that keeps prospects on the radar, leaving the more interesting long-term questions centered on the arms the club is evaluating.
Among them, Sam Horn has made a strong first impression in his professional debut, piling up five strikeouts in four innings, and Brooks Auger has followed with a second start that included three strikeouts over two frames despite allowing two runs. Keith Law of The Athletic offered scouting observations on both pitchers, adding another layer of intrigue to what the Dodgers are learning in the desert as the fall schedule continues. [Read more 🡒]