Dodgers May Have One Skubal Problem Money Alone Cannot Solve

The Dodgers' approach to free agency might face a shake-up as they compete with other teams for standout pitcher Tarik Skubal, amid offers of substantial contract lengths and record-setting values.

Tarik Skubal’s free agency is shaping up to be less about charm and more about leverage.

If the Dodgers are in the mix, the rest of the field already knows the problem: Los Angeles has the kind of pitch that usually wins. Fourteen straight postseason appearances.

The players-only charter. The whole machine.

Skubal has seen it up close, and he didn’t hide what that experience felt like when asked about the extra plane this season.

“It’s pretty great. Oh, yeah.

“I mean, all the amenities are first class, you know? Everything that they have-all the recovery modalities, all the spaces they have, the way they treat the families, the family room ... I mean, they're unreal.

“The way they take care of families is incredible. So, it's like it takes that stress off your plate, just making sure your family's taken care of and they have all the resources and security.

Just all those things may be little, but they add up in the big picture of things. And it just feels like everyone's in the same boat trying to win a World Series and, and that's a ton of fun to be a part of.”

That’s the Dodgers’ edge in a nutshell: they don’t need to sell Skubal on the environment. They already have that part covered. If another club wants to beat them, it probably has to do it the hard way - by going longer.

That’s where the Mets, Blue Jays and Padres come in. To separate from Los Angeles in the Skubal sweepstakes, they may need to stretch the contract in a way the Dodgers usually don’t like to do.

Their preference has been clear: use money to buy flexibility, not to get trapped by the back end of a deal. They tend to favor a bigger annual number over a longer commitment, so they’re not stuck paying for decline years.

The Dodgers have already shown how they operate at the top of the market. Yoshinobu Yamamoto got the longest contract for a pitcher, 12 years and $325 million, which pays him $27 million per year through age 36. Blake Snell landed $36.4 million per year, but on a five-year deal that also runs through age 36.

Skubal is entering free agency younger than Snell was, and the comparison only strengthens the case for a long-term Dodgers offer. He’s been better and more durable than Snell, and he turns 30 Friday. If Los Angeles was willing to go to age 36 for Snell, the logic points to at least seven years for Skubal, even with a higher average annual value.

That’s the real pressure point in this bidding war. The AAV could climb past $43.3 million, which is the pitcher-only record held by Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander on three-year deals. But the bigger separator may be years, not annual salary.

The longest pitcher contract after Yamamoto and Wayne Garland’s 10-year deal from 1976 is Gerrit Cole’s nine-year, $324 million agreement with the Yankees, worth $36 million per year through age 37. Cole and Skubal are both represented by Scott Boras, and while Cole was a year younger and more of a workhorse when he hit free agency, Skubal has been the better pitcher.

Adjusted for inflation, Cole’s $36 million AAV in 2020 would be $47.1 million today, which puts a nine-year Skubal deal at $423.9 million. That’s the kind of number that starts to explain what it might take to pull him away from Los Angeles.

There has already been buzz around the market, and multiple MLB sources have confirmed that the Mets’ initial offer on Skubal was nine years and almost $400 million. That alone would blow past the total-dollar record and set a new high for a free-agent starting pitcher’s AAV.

The Yankees once solved this exact problem against the Dodgers with Cole. Los Angeles was at eight years and $300 million with deferrals, and New York won by adding the ninth year and removing the deferrals. That extra term mattered then, and it may matter again now.

Cole’s Yankees run has had its own arc. In his first four seasons, he went 51-23 with a 3.08 ERA.

Over the past three seasons, including one missed because of Tommy John surgery, he is 18-14 with a 3.53 ERA. Age and workload eventually showed up.

Skubal, though, is not a normal free agent and this is not a normal market. He has only two qualified seasons, fewer than Freddy Peralta.

He has never thrown 110 pitches in a start and has topped 105 pitches only three times. But modern teams are willing to trade volume for dominance, and Skubal fits that profile perfectly.

He is the only pitcher over the past three seasons to make at least 25 starts with an ERA+ above 150. Only five pitchers have done that twice in the last three years: Drew Rasmussen, Chris Sale, Cristopher Sanchez, Zack Wheeler and Yamamoto.

The stuff is as loud as the résumé. Skubal is the hardest-throwing left-handed starter in MLB, averaging 96.8 mph on his four-seamer, tied with Jesus Luzardo. He also owns the highest whiff rate on a changeup at 46.9%, and his 5.40 strikeout-to-walk rate through age 29 is the best of any pitcher with at least 150 starts.

That’s why this market is headed where it is headed. Rare pitchers get paid.

Rare pitchers in their prime get paid even more. And when one of them reaches free agency with the Dodgers in the picture, the price tag gets pushed into territory that keeps climbing.

In Other News...

Dodger Stadium Debate Just Got More Uncomfortable For LA Fans

Cooper Pratts take on the postseason atmosphere only added another wrinkle to a familiar Dodgers conversation. The Brewers shortstop said the environment against the Padres felt louder and more intense than what he experienced against Los Angeles, a comparison that lands a little differently for a club that has spent six straight seasons leading MLB in attendance and built a reputation around one of the sports most recognizable home settings.

The comment fits into a broader, ongoing debate about what makes a baseball crowd feel truly big. Aaron Judge has said he prefers the atmosphere of the international tournament over the World Series, while Logan Webb has gone the other way and talked about how much he enjoys pitching at Dodger Stadium because of its energy. For Dodgers fans, the numbers and the turnout still tell one story, but opposing players keep offering a more complicated one. [Read more 🡒]

Dodgers Made One Arbitration Choice Fans Definitely Did Not Expect

The Dodgers went into the arbitration deadline with a clean slate and came out keeping every eligible player in the fold. Alex Call already settled on a one-year deal to avoid the process, while Brock Stewart, Emmet Sheehan, Gavin Stone and Andy Pages all remain on track for arbitration after the club tendered contracts across the board.

It was a notable show of commitment for a roster that has plenty of moving parts heading into the offseason, especially with younger arms and a young everyday piece still in the mix. The one name that did not stay in the picture was Jake Cousins, who had been sent to arbitration before being designated for assignment, leaving a separate decision still hanging over the bullpen picture. [Read more 🡒]

Dodgers Rumored Interest In Teruaki Sato Creates A Real Roster Squeeze

The Dodgers have spent the past year watching the Japanese market from the outside, at least when it comes to the biggest names making the jump from NPB. Roster constraints have kept them from landing any of the major players who came over last season, even as the organization has remained a natural fit for that pipeline and continued to be linked to talent overseas.

Now Teruaki Sato has entered the conversation, with reports saying Los Angeles is among the teams interested in the NPB Triple Crown winner. The appeal is obvious, but so is the complication: the Dodgers already have a crowded roster, and any pursuit of Sato would likely force a hard look at how to create room without disrupting the depth they have built. For now, it is a fit question more than a finished move, and those are the kinds of decisions that tend to linger until the front office finds a path. [Read more 🡒]