The Dodgers are about to get a major piece back, with Will Smith set to be activated off the 60-day injured list on Tuesday after nearly three months away because of neck inflammation. That’s a huge return for a club that’s been missing one of its most reliable middle-of-the-order bats and a three-time All-Star who has been part of three championship teams in Los Angeles.
But Smith’s comeback also puts a spotlight on what the Dodgers had to piece together in his absence, especially in August. Dalton Rushing had already been carrying starter-level duties behind the plate for two months before a partially-torn UCL knocked him out after just one game in August. In response, the Dodgers made two deadline moves that brought back familiar faces: Hunter Feduccia and Ben Rortvedt.
Both catchers were activated on August 4, and between them they handled every inning over the last 24 games. Feduccia started 15 of them and logged 129 innings behind the plate, while Rortvedt started nine times and caught 84 1/3 innings.
In 11 of those 24 games, both were used, usually in the sort of late-game shuffle that comes when a pinch-hitter enters and the catching duties have to be handed off. There was also the August 18 game at Coors Field, when Feduccia threw up behind the plate and Rortvedt finished the game.
At the plate, Rortvedt gave the Dodgers very little, but not much more than they were getting from the other backup options before him. He went 5 for 27 with a run batted in and a sacrifice.
That was in the same neighborhood as what Los Angeles got from Eliezer Alfonzo, who hit 5 for 27 with two doubles and four RBI, and Chuckie Robinson, who was 2 for 23 with one RBI. Those two combined to start 15 games behind the plate while Rushing was Smith’s backup.
Feduccia, though, brought more offense than the Dodgers had any reason to expect. In 49 plate appearances back in Los Angeles, he hit .262/.354/.381 with a home run, two doubles, six walks, and a 109 wRC+. For a catcher, that plays.
The real value from Feduccia and Rortvedt showed up in the day-to-day work behind the plate. They helped steady the catching, the defense, and the game-calling at a time when Rushing wasn’t catching after August 1. Baseball Savant has Rushing at -3 runs in Fielding Run Value, while Baseball Prospectus pegs him at -3.7 in Catching Defense Added.
By those same measures, Feduccia and Rortvedt were better. Feduccia sits at -2 in Fielding Run Value with the Dodgers, while Rortvedt is at -1.
Baseball Prospectus has Feduccia at -0.1 in Catching Defense Added and Rortvedt at -0.2, both improvements over Rushing. Their best work came in ABS challenges, where Feduccia was right on 12 of 19 attempts, or 63.2 percent, and Rortvedt came through on five of eight, good for 62.5 percent.
Baseball Savant’s net overturns over expected shows they are the only Dodgers catchers with a positive impact in that area this season.
The one place the pair did not slow things down was on the bases. Opponents kept running, and both catchers allowed as many steals as they had starts.
Feduccia gave up 15 steals in 16 tries, while Rortvedt allowed nine steals in 12 attempts. Together, they surrendered 24 steals in 28 tries, an 85.7 percent success rate for the runners.
The numbers across the full catching group show the contrast clearly:
Hunter Feduccia: 15 starts, 129 innings, 15 stolen bases allowed, 1 caught stealing, 93.8 percent, 8.6 innings per steal
Ben Rortvedt: 9 starts, 84.3 innings, 9 stolen bases allowed, 3 caught stealing, 75 percent, 9.4 innings per steal
Eliezer Alfonzo: 9 starts, 74 innings, 5 stolen bases allowed, 1 caught stealing, 83.3 percent, 14.8 innings per steal
Dalton Rushing: 54 starts, 472.3 innings, 30 stolen bases allowed, 10 caught stealing, 75 percent, 15.7 innings per steal
Will Smith: 44 starts, 393 innings, 24 stolen bases allowed, 5 caught stealing, 82.8 percent, 16.4 innings per steal
Chuckie Robinson: 6 starts, 59 innings, 3 stolen bases allowed, 1 caught stealing, 75 percent, 19.7 innings per steal
In Other News...
Disturbing Scene Unfolded Near Dodger Stadium During Wednesdays Game
Los Angeles police responded to a call near Dodger Stadium during Wednesdays game and found a man dead outside the stadium. Authorities have not identified him yet, and investigators do not believe foul play was involved. The medical examiners office is working to notify next of kin as the investigation continues.
For the Dodgers and the fans on hand, the scene added a grim note to what should have been an ordinary game night. Even with police saying there is no sign of suspicious circumstances, the discovery outside one of baseballs most recognizable venues leaves unanswered questions, and it is the kind of off-field development that can linger long after the final out. [Read more 🡒]
Dodgers Suddenly Have A Pitching Question They Can't Ignore
The Dodgers latest roster shuffle came on the same day they dropped an 8-6 extra-innings loss to the Cardinals, a reminder that even as they sit at 82-57, the margin for error can get thin fast when the pitching staff starts to churn. Blake Treinen was activated from the injured list, Eric Lauer landed on the 15-day injured list, and Will Klein was moved to the 60-day injured list because of elbow issues, adding more moving parts to a group that has already had to absorb a steady stream of health updates.
Now the bigger concern is the pitcher who hit a setback in recovery and is currently shut down because of arm fatigue, according to Dave Roberts. For a club trying to keep its rotation and bullpen lined up for the stretch run, it is the kind of update that can linger longer than a single loss, especially when the Dodgers are already juggling multiple injuries and trying to keep their pitching plans intact. [Read more 🡒]
Dodgers Left A Rising Outfielder Waiting For One Frustrating Reason
The Dodgers roster expansion brought a pair of familiar names back into the picture, but not the outfielder many around the organization may have had in mind. Instead of turning to James Tibbs, who has been productive at Triple-A and has built a case for a look, the club recalled catcher Dalton Rushing and infielder Alex Freeland as it moved from 26 players to 28.
For Tibbs, it is the kind of frustrating pause that often comes with life on the cusp of a callup. The Dodgers were at least considering him, but chose to stay with players already on the 40-man roster to keep their roster flexibility intact, a practical decision that leaves the top prospect waiting a little longer even as his path to the majors still looks very real down the line. [Read more 🡒]