Kyle Tucker’s first season with the Dodgers has already turned into a test of patience, and the numbers are doing him no favors.
The $240 million outfielder is hitting .249 with a .730 OPS, and for the first time since 2021 he was left out of the All-Star selections. That alone would be enough to put him under a microscope. When a player is tied to the second-highest AAV in baseball history, underwhelming production doesn’t just register - it irritates.
The Dodgers have stayed publicly supportive. Dave Roberts even tried to frame Tucker’s struggles through the lens of Michael Conforto’s rough 2024, a comparison that was meant to reassure more than persuade. The message from the organization has been clear: Tucker’s track record matters, and the club will keep working to get him right.
But a recent ESPN profile doesn’t exactly scream “all-in response.” Alden Gonzalez reported that Tucker has begun taking postgame batting practice, calling it “a rarity in the major leagues.” That’s the headline detail, and it’s hard to see how that alone is supposed to change the conversation.
Gonzalez also wrote that Tucker “won't religiously show up for early on-field work like Betts and Freddie Freeman and so many of the Dodgers' position players do, but, as [Dodgers hitting coach Aaron] Bates said, 'You can care in a different way.' Those postgame batting practice sessions are proof of that.”
Maybe they are. Maybe they aren’t.
What’s clear is that Tucker arrived in January with a reputation that had already sparked plenty of chatter about how much extra work he really put in. The Dodgers signed him anyway, betting that the bat would outweigh any concerns about the rest of the package. So far, that gamble hasn’t paid off the way they hoped.
Gonzalez noted that former teammates and coaches have described Tucker as “relatively apathetic” about baseball and said he “puts in less extra time working at it than most.” The postgame work in Los Angeles is the main sign that anything has changed. If that’s the bar for praise, it’s a pretty low one for a player of this caliber.
The Dodgers don’t need Tucker to be the entire offense. They don’t need him to be flawless for the team to keep winning. But with that kind of money attached to his name, and with the production lagging behind the expectation, fans are going to want more than the bare minimum.
In Other News...
Blake Snell Just Gave Dodgers Fans A Reason To Believe Again
Blake Snells recovery has moved into a more encouraging phase for the Dodgers, with the left-hander saying he feels the best he has in two years after elbow surgery and has no pain in his arm. Snell has already been facing live hitters as he works his way back from the procedure, and the next step in his return should be a rehab assignment before he tries to rejoin the starting rotation.
For a team that has had to manage plenty of pitching uncertainty, any sign that Snell is trending toward a mid-August return matters. His surgery used a NanoNeedle procedure to remove loose bodies from his elbow, and while the final stretch of the comeback still has to play out, the early signs are at least giving Dodgers fans a reason to think the rotation could get a meaningful boost soon. [Read more 🡒]
Dodgers Trade Proposal Puts Orioles In A Tough Spot With Lefty
The Dodgers are still weighing ways to add pitching before the trade deadline, and one idea on the table would send them after a left-hander who has quietly rebuilt his value over the summer. Baltimores Trevor Rogers has looked much sharper in recent weeks, which is exactly the kind of rebound that can make a front office pause and ask whether the market price is about to rise.
For Los Angeles, the question is less about whether Rogers can help and more about how much prospect capital it should be willing to part with to get him. Jackson Ferris remains one of the organizations more intriguing young arms, while Ryan Ward has also put himself on the radar as a depth bat, so any deal built around those two would force the Dodgers to decide how aggressively they want to chase immediate rotation help. [Read more 🡒]
Dodgers Still Have One Lineup Problem That Could Haunt October
The Dodgers have spent much of the season trying to solve a lineup question that sits just behind Shohei Ohtani, where production has been uneven enough to keep drawing manager Dave Roberts back to the topic. The No. 2 spot is supposed to be a bridge between Ohtani and the rest of the order, but the team has rotated several accomplished hitters through it without finding much consistency, leaving a small but persistent hole in a lineup built to overwhelm opponents.
Roberts has acknowledged there may be a mental side to the job, with hitters feeling the weight of batting directly behind Ohtani, though he stopped short of saying he knows that for certain. The Dodgers are still weighing options for later in the season, including a possible look at Will Smith when he returns from injury, and the answer could matter more in October than it has in the regular season if this one spot continues to lag. [Read more 🡒]