Tarik Skubal is already sitting near the center of the winter market, and the early chatter points to the same familiar heavyweights: the Mets and Dodgers.
Free agency opened to all 30 teams on Monday evening, and while the first stretch of the offseason has been slow across the board, the bidding for Skubal has started to take shape. Jon Heyman of The New York Post wrote on Wednesday that the Mets are interested in making a run, though he noted they still haven’t decided how aggressive they’re willing to be with the Juan Soto contract already in place two years into its record-setting run.
New York has other business to handle, too. The club needs help at the back of the bullpen and around the infield, which makes any huge swing more complicated.
The Dodgers, by contrast, are better positioned to shop for a premium arm without having to solve as many roster issues at once. They’ll need to re-sign or replace several leverage relievers - Evan Phillips, Alex Vesia, Blake Treinen and Kris Bubic - and could also look at second base as a possible upgrade over Tommy Edman and Alex Freeland.
That gives them more flexibility to focus on a few targets instead of spreading resources across multiple holes.
Both the Mets and Dodgers have generally leaned toward massive annual salaries rather than long-term pitching commitments. The Dodgers made an exception for Yoshinobu Yamamoto, whose 12-year deal began in his age-25 season, and also went to five years for Blake Snell.
Otherwise, their rotation additions have tended to stay shorter. The Mets have been even more restrained under David Stearns, never signing a pitcher - or any non-Soto free agent - for more than three years in his first three offseasons running baseball operations.
That leaves room for another club to try to crash the party with a longer offer, and the Cubs have been mentioned as a team to watch. ESPN’s Jeff Passan wrote on Monday that Chicago will be in on Skubal, though the price is expected to climb well beyond $300MM. Cubs president of baseball operations Jed Hoyer has already said this offseason will be centered mostly on pitching.
Chicago does have the financial room to make a real run. Its projected $168.9MM luxury tax number for 2027 is almost $100MM below where it finished the 2026 season, according to MLBTR contributor Ethan Hullihen.
Even so, the Cubs have never signed a player for more than the $184MM Jason Heyward deal from more than a decade ago, and Skubal could end up commanding more than twice that figure. Their history suggests a move more in the mold of Trevor Rogers, Michael King or Freddy Peralta than a record-setting splash, but that Heyward number won’t define the franchise forever.
The Yankees remain in the conversation as a less obvious possibility. They’ve shown no hesitation about long-term pitching contracts in recent years, landing Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodón and Max Fried on deals ranging from six to nine years going back to the 2019-20 offseason.
All three have worked out well so far. They’re considered a longer shot because they don’t really need a starter, but they aren’t completely out of the mix either.
ESPN’s Kiley McDaniel wrote this week that the Yankees would at least consider a push for Skubal and could then trade from their rotation if they landed him. That could mean moving one or two of Ryan Weathers, Will Warren and Clarke Schmidt. McDaniel also noted that the Yankees may move one of those starters anyway as they look to upgrade their position-player group, most likely at second base, third base or catcher.
The Tigers are another team worth watching, at least in the background. McDaniel suggested they may keep tabs on their former ace in case the market softens enough to create a discounted opportunity. That seems unlikely with so many big-market teams circling, but it does fit the way Detroit has handled the rotation market under president of baseball operations Scott Harris.
Last offseason, the Tigers jumped on a three-year deal for Framber Valdez at a massive $38.333MM average annual value when he was still unsigned into February. They made a similar, cheaper move for Jack Flaherty the year before. A Skubal deal in that range feels far less likely, though a reunion with former rotation mate Casey Mize could make sense on a two- or three-year contract with an opt-out after his rough post-deadline stint in San Diego.
For now, the market is still in its opening phase, but it shouldn’t stay quiet for long. There are three and a half weeks left before the inevitable December 1 lockout, and next week’s GM Meetings are expected to matter more than usual. Heyman wrote on Thursday evening that some people in the industry expect Skubal to come off the board early.
In Other News...
Dodgers Fans Have A New Prospect Debate With A Fall Stars Twist
Major League Baseballs Fall Stars Game roster announcement gave Dodgers fans a fresh reason to keep an eye on the Arizona Fall League, with third baseman Chase Harlan and pitcher Luke Fox landing on the National League team. The showcase will be played Sunday at Salt River Fields and aired on MLB Network, giving the organization another chance to see two of its prospects on a bigger stage.
Now the debate shifts to who should join them, with fans voting on one more National League spot from a pool that includes Dodgers prospects Eduardo Quintero and Charles Davalan, along with Padres infielder Justin DeCriscio. For a player development system that has already put two names on the roster, the final choice adds a little extra intrigue for Dodgers followers who have been tracking the fall circuit closely. [Read more 🡒]
Dodgers Could Be Near A Tough Kik Hernndez Decision
Kik Hernndez has been one of the more familiar October pieces in the Dodgers recent run, a utility presence who has shown up in postseason after postseason since 2015 and given the club flexibility all over the diamond. Even with that track record, the offseason always has a way of forcing uncomfortable choices, and Hernndezs status is now part of that familiar roster churn as Los Angeles weighs how to reshape its bench and defensive depth.
One name that has surfaced in that conversation is Mauricio Dubon, the versatile defender most recently with the Atlanta Braves. Dubon would likely come at a higher salary, which only adds to the calculus for a Dodgers front office trying to balance value with familiarity, and while a move away from Hernndez looks increasingly possible, it is not yet official. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Could Lose A Bullpen Weapon To A Familiar Rival
The Dodgers have already made one major bullpen splash by landing Edwin Daz, and they are not likely to stop there as they keep looking for ways to deepen a roster built to chase another title. With Tarik Skubal expected to be a major winter target, Los Angeles is also being linked to a more immediate relief-market possibility in Padres left-hander Adrin Morejn, a pitcher who has quietly become one of the more interesting names in the division.
Morejn has been extended a qualifying offer by San Diego and has until November 17 to decide whether to take it or test free agency, which leaves the door open for a familiar rival to make a run at him. For the Dodgers, the appeal is obvious: pairing Morejn with Daz would give them another high-end bullpen look, while also turning a Padres weapon into part of the same late-inning mix that has long frustrated opponents in the National League West. [Read more 🡒]