The 2027 Hall of Fame ballot is out, and Chase Utley is back in the spotlight after making the biggest leap among returning candidates last year. The former Dodgers second baseman drew 59.1 percent on the 2026 ballot, his third year of eligibility, after sitting at 39.8 percent the year before. Now he’s trying to make another jump to the 75 percent needed from the Baseball Writers Association of America for Cooperstown.
Utley’s surge last year wasn’t random. A big chunk of it came from first-time voters and returning voters who had skipped the 2025 ballot, with Utley appearing on 42 of those 51 ballots, or 82.4 percent. If he falls short again, the field gets more complicated - and Buster Posey suddenly becomes the most likely first-ballot candidate.
Posey is one of the headliners among the newcomers, and he brings a résumé that jumps off the page: National League MVP, Rookie of the Year, and the catcher who helped lead the San Francisco Giants to three World Series titles. In his career, he hit .302/.372/.460 with a 129 wRC+, and finished with 45 bWAR and 57.9 fWAR.
Jay Jaffe’s JAWS system puts Posey at 40.8, which ranks 14th all-time among catchers. His seven-year peak came in at 36.5 bWAR, and his 45 career bWAR stacks up against the Hall’s 17 catchers, whose average is 34.9 peak bWAR and 53.7 career bWAR.
Utley is not alone among familiar names trying to hang on. Andy Pettitte is back after getting 48.5 percent last year, Félix Hernández returned at 46.1 percent, and Alex Rodríguez checked in at 40 percent. Carlos Beltrán and Andruw Jones were elected last year.
The Dodgers also have Bobby Abreu, Jimmy Rollins, and Cole Hamels on the ballot again. Abreu is in his eighth year after receiving 30.8 percent last time, Rollins is in his sixth after 25.4 percent, and Hamels is in his second year after 23.8 percent in his debut.
There are 14 first-time names on the ballot, and none of them played for the Dodgers. That group includes Jake Arrieta, Jay Bruce, Asdrúbal Cabrera, Starlin Castro, Wade Davis, Brett Gardner, Jon Lester, Andrew Miller, Posey, Pablo Sandoval, Ervin Santana, Kyle Seager, Joakim Soria, and Ryan Zimmerman.
Soria is a notable oddity in that group. He pitched for nine major league teams over 14 seasons, but not for the Dodgers, who signed him out of Mexico nearly a quarter-century ago. He did, however, pitch four games for the Gulf Coast League Dodgers in Vero Beach in 2022.
In Other News...
Former Dodgers Arm Just Landed A Deal That Says Plenty
Dustin Mays latest stop says plenty about how much teams still value his arm, even after all the stops along the way. The former Dodgers pitcher has agreed to a three-year deal with the Chicago White Sox worth about $52.5 million, a notable commitment for a veteran who has bounced through several clubs and is now being brought in to add stability to a staff looking for depth more than a headline name.
Mays path has already taken him from Los Angeles to the Cardinals, Brewers and Red Sox, and he even picked up a World Series ring with Milwaukee in 2026. For the White Sox, the appeal is clear: they are betting on experience, durability and usable innings rather than asking him to anchor the rotation, which makes the contract a revealing one for both sides. [Read more 🡒]
Dodgers GM Just Added Intrigue To How Fans Judge The Skubal Trade
The Tarik Skubal deal already had enough moving parts to keep Dodgers fans talking, but Brandon Gomes added another layer by drawing a direct line between River Ryan and one of the more recognizable pitchers of the recent Dodgers era. In discussing the trade, the general manager pointed to Ryans stuff and his development path, comparing his arsenal and confidence to Walker Buehler, a nod that instantly reframes how some around the team may view what Los Angeles gave up to land Skubal.
Ryans road has been shaped by limited big league experience after Tommy John surgery, which makes any early evaluation tricky, but the traits the Dodgers liked were never hard to miss. He has flashed potential in his appearances with the Tigers, and Gomes comparison only heightens the sense that this trade may be judged not just by Skubals impact in Los Angeles, but by whether Ryan eventually looks like the kind of arm the Dodgers believed they were moving on from. [Read more 🡒]
Former Dodgers Reliever Explains Why He Chose Atlanta Instead
Evan Phillips spent six seasons in Los Angeles, enough time to become one of the more familiar bullpen names around the Dodgers before his free agency sent him into a different kind of decision. After weighing his options with his family, the right-hander landed in Atlanta, where he signed a three-year, $35 million contract following his recovery from elbow surgery. For a pitcher with his track record, the move was about more than just money or familiarity, and it marked a notable shift after years in Dodger blue.
The Braves are betting on Phillips despite the injury risk, encouraged by what he has shown recently and confident he can still be a meaningful late-inning arm. For Dodgers fans, it is another reminder of how quickly a trusted reliever can move from a familiar bullpen role to a rival contenders plans, especially when health and timing enter the picture. The choice was made, but the broader impact of it is still something both clubs will be watching closely. [Read more 🡒]
