The idea of the Carolina Panthers swapping Bryce Young for Justin Herbert sounds big on paper. In reality, it looks a lot closer to a mistake than a makeover.
Henry McKenna and Steven Ruiz recently tossed the Panthers out as a possible landing spot if Herbert ever wanted out of Los Angeles, putting Carolina alongside the Buccaneers as a team that might take a call. McKenna framed the fit this way: "We'll see what happens with Bryce Young as the season goes on. I could see a team like the Panthers, that would be the type of team, a team that will finish in the middle of the draft and the middle of the league."
Ruiz reacted with enthusiasm at the thought of Herbert in Carolina, and McKenna followed by saying, "You're probably talking about more than three firsts because it's that middle-of-the-round pick."
He also suggested Young could be included as a "sweetener," which would reduce how much draft capital the Panthers would have to send out beyond those three first-rounders.
That’s a wild price for Carolina to pay when the payoff is so unclear. Herbert is a good quarterback and should still have a strong NFL career, but nothing is guaranteed there.
McKenna pointed to the idea that things were supposed to work with Mike McDaniel and said Herbert has been "atrocious." Young, meanwhile, is trending upward.
He’s younger, cheaper, and not tied to a monster extension the way Herbert is.
There’s also the simple question of direction. If the Panthers are still far enough away that one quarterback upgrade doesn’t make them a contender, then why burn a pile of premium picks just to change the name on the jersey? That kind of move can leave a team with a shiny new passer and very little else.
And there’s another layer that makes the whole thing even messier: Young might flourish somewhere else. When he was benched, some already floated the Dolphins as a possible fit because of the way his game lines up with Tua Tagovailoa’s. If Mike McDaniel made that work with Tagovailoa, the argument goes, he’d probably be thrilled to have Young.
That’s what makes this hypothetical feel so hard to defend for Carolina. The Panthers have already poured plenty into getting Young to this point, and the work is finally starting to show. Trading him now for a quarterback who would cost a mountain of draft picks and is going through the worst season of his career so far makes very little sense.
In Other News...
Bo Nix Faces A Growing Broncos Question Sean Payton Can't Ignore
Bo Nixs first season has already produced a clear talking point in Denver, where the rookie quarterback is averaging 5.8 yards per attempt and sitting near the bottom of the league in that category. Sean Payton has made it plain he wants more aggressiveness from his quarterback, and that push says as much about the Broncos offensive ceiling as it does about Nixs comfort level in the system.
For the Chargers, it is the sort of division-wide development worth watching closely because every AFC West ripple matters. One name that has surfaced in broader trade chatter is Quentin Johnston, but any potential move would have to navigate both the financial side and Los Angeles willingness to part with a young receiver, leaving this as more of a long-view possibility than an obvious quick fix. [Read more 🡒]
Chargers Have Reached A Justin Herbert Debate Nobody Wanted
An 0-5 start has pushed the Chargers into a place few around the league expected to see them, and it has dragged Justin Herbert into an uncomfortable conversation for a franchise built around him. His play has slipped, the offense has sputtered, and the broader picture has only sharpened the pressure on the coaching staff and the personnel choices around the quarterback.
There is no easy path through a downturn like this, especially when the teams most important player is the one under the brightest spotlight. Moving Herbert would be the kind of seismic decision that comes with huge risk, so the real question is more basic and more difficult: are the Chargers looking at a quarterback problem, or at everything orbiting the quarterback? [Read more 🡒]
Chargers Draw A Hard Line As Pressure Builds Everywhere Else
With the noise around the Chargers building from every direction, one line appears to be holding firm: Justin Herbert is not going anywhere. ESPNs Adam Schefter reported that the team has never discussed trading its quarterback, and the idea is not under consideration, a notable stance for a franchise trying to steady itself while Herbert works through a stretch of uneven play.
Herberts contract runs through 2029, and the full no-trade clause gives him major control over any such scenario anyway. So if the Chargers decide change is needed, the pressure is more likely to land on the coaching staff or the front office before it reaches the quarterback, which tells you where the real uncertainty in Los Angeles still sits. [Read more 🡒]