The Chargers’ offense has looked out of sync from the jump, and the first two games have only sharpened the contrast with what Mike McDaniel built in Miami.
When McDaniel was calling plays for the Dolphins in 2022, Tua Tagovailoa and company came out humming. The start was clean against New England, then explosive in Baltimore, where Tagovailoa threw for six touchdowns and 469 yards in a 42-38 road win. The version of McDaniel’s offense in Los Angeles has been a different story entirely: choppy, mistake-filled and stuck in ugly losses to the Arizona Cardinals and Las Vegas Raiders.
That gap matters because nobody in the NFL is confusing Tagovailoa for a better quarterback than Justin Herbert. Herbert went sixth overall to the Chargers in 2020, one pick after Miami took Tagovailoa. But in McDaniel’s system, Tagovailoa looked at ease immediately, and Herbert hasn’t yet found that same rhythm.
Tagovailoa had two clear advantages in 2022: he was more polished on run-pass-option plays, and he had Tyreek Hill. Hill, at his peak, was the kind of weapon who made life easier and more fun for every quarterback around him. Los Angeles doesn’t have Hill, but it does have Ladd McConkey, and he’s been the one receiver who’s made a quick adjustment.
McConkey had a touchdown catch and 106 yards in the opener, including a 24-yard gain on pass interference, before leaving the fourth quarter with a rib injury. On Sunday, he was limited to 31 snaps, but still managed a 19-yard catch on third-and-11 along with two shorter receptions. Outside of him, the offense has been stuck in mud.
The numbers back that up. In extra points added, Miami’s first McDaniel offense produced positive marks of 6.1 and 32.0.
The Chargers have gone the other direction, posting negative EPA totals of -3.3 against Arizona and -8.7 against Las Vegas. Those games ended in 12-point losses, and Herbert’s passing numbers reflect the struggle: an 83.7 passer rating in one game, then 59.5 in the next.
McDaniel was fired by Miami in January, and the Chargers brought him in largely because of Herbert, 28. On paper, Herbert has the edge over Tagovailoa in arm strength, size, durability, contact balance, physicality and the run game. He’s also already shown he can handle different play callers, succeeding under Shane Steichen, Joe Lombardi, Kellen Moore and Greg Roman.
But this offense has been breaking down in more than one way. Right guard Cole Strange, receiver Quentin Johnston and fullback Alec Ingold have all gotten off to rough starts.
Omarion Hampton has fumbled twice. Star right tackle Joe Alt was flagged four times Sunday, and rookie center Jake Slaughter, who had to step in because of a veteran’s preseason injury, drew three straight penalties in the opener.
Herbert has also finished both losses with fourth-quarter throws that were intercepted. On Sunday, that pick came just before Alt’s holding penalty led to a safety, and CBS cameras later showed McDaniel talking to Herbert on the bench. Herbert stared straight ahead, expressionless.
For longtime San Diegans still putting money and time into the franchise, this is a familiar kind of bad start, and one with a place in team history. The Chargers haven’t opened an offense this poorly since 2007, when Norv Turner’s first unit stumbled out of the gate with negative EPAs of -4.94 and -12.50. Philip Rivers, adjusting from “Martyball” to “Norvball,” posted passer ratings of 73.7 and 74, LaDainian Tomlinson was held to 25 yards on 17 carries in the opener, and the team still managed a 14-3 win over Chicago before being routed 38-14 by New England.
By season’s end?
In Other News...
Chargers Suddenly Have A Tight End Problem They Can't Ignore
A thin tight end room has forced the Chargers to make a quick adjustment, signing Hayden Rucci off the Jacksonville Jaguars' practice squad after placing David Njoku and Charlie Kolar on injured reserve because of injuries. The move leaves Oronde Gadsden as the only other healthy tight end on the active roster, a sudden squeeze that changes the look of the offense and puts even more pressure on the depth chart.
Rucci arrives with limited NFL experience, but he does bring something useful in a situation like this: familiarity with offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel's system from his time with the Miami Dolphins. For a team trying to keep its offense moving without two key tight ends, that kind of head start matters, even if the bigger question is how quickly the Chargers can turn a stopgap addition into something workable. [Read more 🡒]
Chargers Suddenly Have A Justin Herbert Problem Joe Hortiz Can't Ignore
The Chargers offensive line has become one of the most uncomfortable storylines around the team, because it keeps putting Justin Herbert in the kind of position no franchise quarterback should have to navigate. When protection breaks down, everything gets harder to trust, from the rhythm of the offense to the staffs ability to evaluate what is really going wrong and where the fixes need to come from. Joe Hortiz does not have the luxury of treating it as a temporary inconvenience anymore.
For a team trying to stay on track, the issue is bigger than one rough afternoon or one bad matchup. The Chargers need Herbert upright and functional, and they need the front office to sort through the roster with a clear eye toward what can actually help right now. Whether that means adjusting the line, exploring moves, or simply admitting the problem is more urgent than hoped, this is the kind of situation that can linger unless it gets addressed head on. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals May Have Exposed A Chargers Problem That Goes Beyond Herbert
The Chargers rough 0-2 start has drawn plenty of attention to Justin Herbert and the new offensive setup, but one ESPN take pointed to a more basic issue up front. Ben Solak argued the bigger concern has been the play of tackles Joe Alt and Rashawn Slater, both working back from significant injuries suffered in 2025, and the ripple effect has shown up in protection and penalties along the line.
For a team trying to make a fresh offensive scheme work, that kind of instability on the edges can change everything. Herbert can only operate so comfortably when the pocket is collapsing and the tackles are fighting through recovery, and the early evidence suggests the Chargers problems may be rooted in more than scheme or quarterback play. [Read more 🡒]