The Chargers have seen enough of the JK Scott roller coaster.
Thursday night’s preseason finale against the Rams offered another rough reminder of why the punter’s grip on the job feels shaky. Scott shanked a punt in the Chargers’ 20-18 loss, and the night ended with three punts averaging just 33.7 yards, with a long of 48.
That one sequence would be bad enough on its own. But it sits inside a much bigger pattern.
Scott’s 2025 numbers are respectable at first glance: 47.8 yards per punt, a 41.4-yard net average and 23 punts placed inside the 20. The problem is that the production hasn’t always matched the stat line. Too many kicks have lacked consistency, and too often the Chargers haven’t gotten the field-position edge they needed from the position.
The 83-yard punt return touchdown against the 49ers earlier this preseason only added to the concern. Scott wasn’t solely responsible for that play, but he did outkick his coverage and then miss the tackle. Jim Harbaugh addressed it afterward, saying Scott needed to have a plan for making the tackle in that situation.
That’s where the larger issue comes into focus. Special teams can’t be an afterthought for a team trying to build toward a championship. The Chargers have put real resources into offense and defense, and they can’t keep giving away hidden yards because the punting situation is unstable.
Scott has been with the Chargers since 2022, so this isn’t a case of a player still learning what the team wants. He’s had plenty of time to settle in and become a dependable part of the operation. He’s also had some strong moments in a Chargers uniform, but they haven’t come often enough to outweigh the uneven stretches.
With roster cuts approaching, the Chargers should at least look hard at the position. If there’s another punter out there who can be more consistent, place the ball better and avoid the mistakes, Los Angeles should be willing to make the switch.
Thursday night alone shouldn’t decide Scott’s fate. One preseason game does not tell the whole story.
But when that game looks like part of a familiar pattern, the warning signs get harder to ignore.
The Chargers have bigger concerns than punter. Still, this is one they can address.
In Other News...
Chargers Roster Cuts Could Leave One Big Young Talent Debate
Once the Chargers trim down to their final 53, the real debate may not be over the roster, but over who sticks around on the practice squad and why. Draft analyst Thomas Martinez has been running through a projected group that includes a mix of quarterbacks, running backs, receivers and defenders, with the kind of preseason evaluation that often says as much about future plans as it does about August performance.
What makes the picture interesting for Los Angeles is the blend of young talent, versatility and lingering injury questions that can shape those decisions. Some players have shown enough in the preseason to stay in the conversation, and others could still end up part of the Chargers' long-term picture even if they do not make the initial cut. For now, it remains a prediction game, but the final decisions should offer a clearer read on which young players the staff values most. [Read more 🡒]
Chargers Suddenly Have A Backup QB Problem Harbaugh Can't Ignore
The Chargers have spent much of camp making sure Justin Herbert stays the center of everything, but the conversation behind him has turned less comfortable. Trey Lance and DJ Uiagalelei have not done much to settle the backup quarterback job in preseason play, and that has left a thin-looking depth chart in a spot teams hate being thin at this time of year.
Jim Harbaugh has dealt with this kind of problem before and did not wait around then, choosing a trade to shore up the position when the situation demanded it. With final roster cuts looming, Los Angeles could again look at trades, the waiver wire or free agency if it decides the current options are not enough, because the Chargers cannot afford to go into the season feeling uneasy about what happens if Herbert is unavailable. [Read more 🡒]
Chargers Still Have One Offensive Decision That Could Stir Debate
The Chargers wrapped up their preseason with a close loss to the Rams, and the afternoon served mostly as one last audit of the roster for Jim Harbaugh and his staff. It was a useful final look at both the established starters and the players trying to force their way onto the 53-man roster, with the offensive line and back end of the running back room drawing particular attention.
Trevor Penning and Logan Taylor were in the mix for what looks like the final offensive line spot, while undrafted rookie Gregory Desrosiers Jr. made a case as a possible third back and special teams option. Quarterback DJ Uiagalelei also left the preseason with some momentum after showing steady growth, a contrast to Trey Lance, whose night was far less convincing and only added another layer to the teams evaluation process. [Read more 🡒]