No matter how ugly things have gotten for the Los Angeles Chargers, Justin Herbert doesn’t sound like a realistic trade candidate.
That’s the takeaway after ESPN’s Adam Schefter said he checked in with the Chargers about the possibility ahead of the NFL deadline and got a swift shutdown. On his podcast, Schefter said he reached out to the team and was told in no uncertain terms that the idea was never under discussion.
Schefter said that "the person basically cut me off mid-sentence, stopped me in my tracks, and said, 'let me be very clear about this. We have never even discussed that idea. The sentence should we trade Justin Herbert has never once been uttered in our organization, nor will it be.'"
It’s easy to understand why the question came up in the first place. Jim Harbaugh’s Chargers have been a mess, and the source of that mess has been laid at the feet of horrendous roster building and an apparently ill-advised addition of Mike McDaniel. The result has been disaster for Herbert and a team that looks like the worst and least-prepared group in the NFL.
Still, even with the organization spiraling, moving a 28-year-old star quarterback was always going to be a long shot. Herbert is under contract through 2029 and holds a full no-trade clause, giving him the power to block any deal if he wanted. A post-June 1 move would also leave the Chargers with dead money north of $19 million in each of the next three years, along with other complications.
And if a trade ever did get seriously explored, the price would be massive. Herbert would command multiple first-round picks. Even so, his value is not quite what it once was after a stretch in which he has mostly looked horrible, posting 937 yards, five touchdowns and seven interceptions while leading the NFL in turnover-worthy throws.
That doesn’t change the bigger picture, though. The Chargers may be headed toward consequences for Harbaugh and even general manager Joe Hortiz, but dealing Herbert is still the kind of idea that belongs in speculation, not reality.
In Other News...
Bo Nix Faces A Growing Broncos Question Sean Payton Can't Ignore
Bo Nixs first season has already produced a clear talking point in Denver, where the rookie quarterback is averaging 5.8 yards per attempt and sitting near the bottom of the league in that category. Sean Payton has made it plain he wants more aggressiveness from his quarterback, and that push says as much about the Broncos offensive ceiling as it does about Nixs comfort level in the system.
For the Chargers, it is the sort of division-wide development worth watching closely because every AFC West ripple matters. One name that has surfaced in broader trade chatter is Quentin Johnston, but any potential move would have to navigate both the financial side and Los Angeles willingness to part with a young receiver, leaving this as more of a long-view possibility than an obvious quick fix. [Read more 🡒]
Chargers Have Reached A Justin Herbert Debate Nobody Wanted
An 0-5 start has pushed the Chargers into a place few around the league expected to see them, and it has dragged Justin Herbert into an uncomfortable conversation for a franchise built around him. His play has slipped, the offense has sputtered, and the broader picture has only sharpened the pressure on the coaching staff and the personnel choices around the quarterback.
There is no easy path through a downturn like this, especially when the teams most important player is the one under the brightest spotlight. Moving Herbert would be the kind of seismic decision that comes with huge risk, so the real question is more basic and more difficult: are the Chargers looking at a quarterback problem, or at everything orbiting the quarterback? [Read more 🡒]
Panthers Just Got Pulled Into A Dangerous Justin Herbert Debate
The latest round of quarterback chatter around Justin Herbert has taken a strange turn, with the Chargers star suddenly becoming the centerpiece of a what-if discussion that reaches all the way to Carolina. The speculation, driven by analysts Henry McKenna and Steven Ruiz, centers on the idea of what it would look like if Los Angeles ever had to seriously entertain moving Herbert, a conversation that naturally invites comparison with Bryce Young and the Panthers own quarterback situation.
Carolina only enters the conversation because of the sheer scale of a theoretical Herbert deal, and because any team looking to swing for a franchise quarterback would have to pay an enormous price. The framework being kicked around is the kind that would strip a roster of premium draft capital and more, which is why the whole debate feels more like a stress test for the Chargers than a real transaction watch. For now, there is no confirmed move, just an uncomfortable reminder of how quickly a league-wide rumor can pull another team into the middle of it. [Read more 🡒]