Dustin May’s new deal with the White Sox has done more than stun the market. It has handed the Angels a fresh pricing guide for two of their most important arms, and neither Reid Detmers nor Yusei Kikuchi looks the same in that light.
May landed a three-year, $54 million contract after a 2026 season split between St. Louis and Milwaukee, where he put up a 4.70 ERA in 31 starts.
The numbers underneath were rough, too: 0.4 bWAR and an 85 ERA+. That kind of production, paired with an extensive injury history, is now setting the bar for what teams are willing to pay just to stabilize the back end of a rotation.
For the Angels, that matters immediately. If a pitcher coming off that kind of season can still command $17.5 million a year, then controllable starters with real upside suddenly look even more valuable. That is where Detmers enters the picture.
Detmers is coming off a huge 2026 rebound after a bullpen stint in 2025. He posted a 3.36 ERA, struck out 211 batters in 185 innings, and finished sixth in AL Cy Young voting.
With two years of arbitration left before free agency after the 2028 season, he is projected to make about $7.5 million in 2027. In the current market, that makes him one of the best bargains around.
That bargain status also changes the Angels’ leverage. Before free agency even opened, Angels on SI projected a long-term Detmers extension at around five years and $100 million.
Now, that number may be the floor rather than the target. If the Angels want to keep him from getting even more expensive in his final arbitration year, the starting point could be closer to $20 million annually.
Detmers’ side can point to May’s $17.5 million average annual value and argue for more, given his stronger performance and injury history.
If the Angels go the other direction and explore trades, the return should be massive. Clubs that get priced out of the free-agent market will look at two affordable years of Detmers and see a major opportunity. The asking price would have to be enormous, and even the trade package recently floated with the Cubs may already fall short.
Kikuchi’s situation has shifted, too. The veteran left-hander is in the final year of his three-year deal and is owed $21.225 million for 2027.
At first glance, moving that salary looked difficult, especially after shoulder inflammation cut short his 2026 season and limited him to 14 starts with a 4.92 ERA. But May’s contract changes the conversation.
A contender might now view Kikuchi’s one-year commitment as the safer play compared with giving three years and $52.5 million to a volatile starter. Kikuchi was an All Star for the Angels as recently as 2025, and because he is on an expiring deal, there is no long-term risk attached to acquiring him.
That gives the Angels options. They could eat part of the salary and try to turn Kikuchi into young, controllable talent, or wait for teams that miss out on the first wave of free-agent starters. Either way, the market has been pushed upward, and that should help their return.
The first step, of course, is getting a new front office in place to handle the trades and the free-agent work. But once that happens, May’s contract gives the Angels a much stronger hand.
Detmers is now a premium trade chip or a premium extension candidate. Kikuchi is suddenly movable.
And if the richest owner in baseball wants to keep Detmers around, the check is going to have to get a lot bigger.
In Other News...
Angels Just Made A Prospect Move Fans Could Feel For Awhile
The Angels spent part of Monday making sure two of their most promising young outfielders stay in the organization for the long haul. Nelson Rada and Raudi Rodriguez were added to the 40-man roster, a move that protects them from the Rule 5 draft and signals how highly the club values both players even though neither has reached the majors yet.
It is the kind of roster maneuver that does not change the lineup today, but can matter a lot down the road, especially with the MLB lockout set to begin Dec. 1. For an Angels team still trying to build real depth and keep its best talent in house, securing Rada and Rodriguez now removes one more bit of uncertainty from a winter that is already headed into a freeze. [Read more 🡒]
Angels Suddenly Have A Real Brandon Marsh Reunion Debate
Brandon Marshs name is back in the Angels conversation for a reason that has nothing to do with nostalgia alone. The former Angel, now with the Phillies, is suddenly being discussed as a possible non-tender candidate because of his projected arbitration salary and the way injury issues have affected his recent performance, which opens the door to a familiar question in Anaheim: if he reaches free agency, should the Angels take a real look?
It is the kind of decision that would force the front office to weigh what Marsh still brings against what the roster needs by 2027. His defense remains a clear selling point, and there is still some appeal in the idea of bringing back a player who knows the organization, but the offensive side of the equation has been less steady. For a team trying to sort out its outfield picture, the possibility of a reunion is interesting enough to linger on, even if the answer is not obvious yet. [Read more 🡒]
Albert Pujols Looks Like The Angels Most Compelling Managerial Choice
With Brad Ausmus now in place in Houston, the Angels are the lone big-league club still without a manager, and the timing only adds to the pressure on a franchise already in transition. They moved on from Kurt Suzuki and are expected to settle on a new skipper soon, with the pending sale to Stan Kroenke and the looming lockout both hovering over the decision.
Among the names in the mix, Albert Pujols stands out as the most intriguing fit. He brings instant credibility, deep organizational familiarity and the kind of stature that would resonate with a fan base looking for a fresh start, though his reported contract demands could make the process more complicated than a simple reunion. [Read more 🡒]
