The Angels had a chance to turn Zach Neto into a much bigger haul, and in this case the real lesson is in what they didn’t get.
Heading into the 2026 trade deadline, Boston’s interest in Neto was no secret. The Red Sox were hunting for offense, and the rumors got louder when top prospect Franklin Arias was pulled from his AAA game the day before the deadline.
At the time, reports said the Angels were pushing for Arias in any Neto deal. Boston giving up Arias alone would have been a steep price unless more talent was included.
Instead, the Red Sox held onto Arias and sent a package to Baltimore for catcher Adley Rutschman. That is the kind of return the Angels could have used to speed up their rebuild.
The headliner in that group was pitching prospect Anthony Eyanson, and he would have fit neatly into what the Angels are trying to build. Eyanson projects as a future frontline starter with multiple plus pitches and above average control. His fastball can reach 100 and sits in the upper 90s, while his slider gets whiffs about half the time.
There was more behind him. Enddy Azocar brings big raw power, solid defensive and baserunning metrics, and a very aggressive approach at the plate for a 19-year-old.
Baseball America gives him a very high 60 prospect grade. Kyson Witherspoon also would have been part of the mix, and even with a rough first pro season after a huge junior year at Oklahoma, his delivery and four plus-rated pitches still point toward a middle-of-the-order arm.
The Red Sox ultimately landed Harold Rivas instead, an 18-year-old outfielder with a 50 grade who flashes five tools and still needs all of them sharpened. Carlos Narvaez was included too, though the backup catcher piece was never the real story. The prospect value was.
That’s why the Angels’ missed opportunity stings. The Rutschman return would have pushed their farm system into the top 10, and Eyanson alone would have changed the shape of the organization.
Pair him with top prospect Arjun Nimmala, and the Angels suddenly have two players who belong in the top 30 prospects in baseball. Eyanson probably would have sat at No. 1 in the system because of the ace upside and the fact he has already reached AAA.
Witherspoon is another name that stands out. He was one of the writer’s favorite college arms, and even after a shaky first year as a pro, the stuff and delivery still look like a major league regular.
Azocar and Rivas, meanwhile, are the kind of teenage lottery tickets that can take years to pay off, if they ever do. But in a rebuild, those are exactly the swings that matter, especially when they can help form a second wave behind the current loaded club in Rocket City.
The problem for the Angels is that keeping Neto came with a real cost. He may be their best bat and can take over a game in stretches, but with Denzer Guzman and Oswald Peraza already on the roster, he is likely the third-best defensive shortstop on the team. That creates a roster puzzle that gets harder the more the Angels try to build around him.
Neto can also complicate what comes next with Nimmala. If the Angels extend Neto, they either block Nimmala or push their top prospect to a less valuable position like second base, even though Nimmala might be the better defender. And if the plan is to keep Neto at short, then it raises the obvious question of why trade for a shortstop in the first place.
For 2026 and 2027, Neto helps the Angels win more games. But if the goal is to rebuild from the ground up, keeping him may have slowed the whole operation down. The Angels appear to have overplayed their hand with Boston and missed a chance to land a package that could have accelerated everything.
In Other News...
Angels Ownership Change Puts Real Pressure On One Offseason Strategy
The Angels are heading into an offseason with more moving parts than usual, and the most important one may not be on the field. A new majority owner is expected to be in place by the start of next season, which gives the club a transitional feel just as it begins weighing how aggressive to be in free agency and trade talks. With the market viewed as thin, the usual shopping route may not offer much help anyway.
That has put more attention on the trade market, where the Angels could try to move faster than their rivals before a likely lockout complicates the calendar. Under future executive John Mozeliak, the club is expected to look hard at rental players and other trade assets as it tries to strengthen the roster without waiting on a free-agent class that does not appear especially deep. [Read more 🡒]
Angels Face A Costly Reid Detmers Decision They Can't Delay
Reid Detmers has given the Angels exactly the kind of second-half jolt that can force an uncomfortable front office conversation. Since the All-Star break, he has been one of the best pitchers in baseball, putting together a stretch that has turned heads around the league and made it easy to see why rival clubs were circling him before the deadline.
Now the Angels are staring at a choice they cannot put off for long: lock Detmers into a long-term deal or cash in while his value is soaring. Either path carries real consequences for a club still trying to build something lasting, and the possibility of landing top prospects in a trade only sharpens the pressure to decide what Detmers is truly worth to them. [Read more 🡒]
Ryan Johnson Is Giving The Angels A Real Rotation Decision
Ryan Johnsons recent run has started to look less like a promising stretch and more like a legitimate case for sticking in the Angels rotation. The right-hander turned in a strong six-inning outing against the Boston Red Sox, and over his last seven starts he has paired a low ERA and WHIP with the kind of weak contact that tends to keep a pitcher employed in the majors.
For a team already sorting through a strong rotation, that has turned Johnson into more than just a stopgap option. The Angels are considering him for the fifth starter job, and the way he has been handling recent lineups is making that decision a real one rather than a formality. [Read more 🡒]