Last night, Tampa Bay Rays third baseman Junior Caminero added another line to a résumé that keeps getting louder. He turned on an inside fastball and drove a two-run homer down the line, a swing that helped send Tampa Bay to the 2026 World Series. As he circled the bases, he cupped his hand to his ear and took in the roar from the Florida crowd.
But there’s a version of this story where Caminero is doing that in Anaheim.
During the frantic stretch before the 2023 MLB trade deadline, the Rays made a serious push for Shohei Ohtani. Even with the Angels publicly saying they were chasing a postseason berth, conversations kept happening behind the scenes. Tampa Bay was willing to go huge in an effort to land the two-way star, and the centerpiece of that offer was Junior Caminero.
At the time, Caminero was the kind of prospect Tampa Bay almost never puts on the table. MLB Pipeline had him ranked sixth in baseball, and the reports on him were glowing: plus bat, plus-plus power, a decent glove, and a strong arm.
He was 19 then and hitting .324 with 31 home runs across High A and AA, absurd production for a player that young and that far ahead of his competition. He looked like a future middle-of-the-order force and, in this scenario, the Angels’ answer at third base.
The Rays’ offer wasn’t built around just one prospect, either. Carson Williams was another name tied to the talks over time.
Tampa Bay’s second-ranked prospect and the 22nd-best in baseball, Williams brought slick fielding and raw power to the table. Now 23, he has struggled in limited MLB action, but he has put together a .243/.342/.454 line over 577 minor league games.
The deal never happened because Arte Moreno stepped in and shut it down.
Even with general manager Perry Minasian trying to navigate a return that would have been enormous for a player headed toward free agency, Moreno blocked the trade himself. His thinking, according to the source here, came down to two things: he believed the Angels were still real playoff contenders, and he didn’t want to be the owner who traded away a generational face of the franchise. Moreno pushed the front office to buy at the deadline instead of sell, even with the team sitting a few games out of a Wild Card spot and facing a much tougher schedule ahead than the one they had already played.
That was Moreno in a nutshell, according to this account: unwilling to rebuild, unwilling to accept the obvious, and determined to keep chasing wins in the moment. Trading Ohtani, even for a return as massive as this one, didn’t fit that mindset.
So Ohtani stayed. Then he walked in free agency.
The Angels did not match the Dodgers’ offer, and instead of landing Caminero or another centerpiece prospect, they received the 74th overall pick in the 2024 draft as compensation. They used it on pitcher Ryan Johnson.
Caminero, meanwhile, has become exactly the kind of hitter the Angels have lacked. He’s now 23, cost-controlled, and producing at a level that would fit neatly into any lineup. Across two-plus seasons, he has piled up 10.8 bWAR, hit 92 home runs, and posted a 132 OPS+.
The Angels, by contrast, have lost 190 games over the last two seasons and finished both years in last place in the AL West. Third base has been a revolving door, with Yoan Moncada among the names cycling through, and there still isn’t a clear answer there for 2027.
The comparison is blunt: Caminero and two other Rays prospects, or Ryan Johnson. The gap is obvious, and the source frames Moreno’s decision as one of the worst mistakes of his ownership tenure, even worse than the trade he blocked that would have brought back Andy Pages as part of a Taylor Ward/Luis Rengifo package.
The Angels didn’t just miss out on a trade. They missed out on a chance to inject a franchise-changing bat into the middle of their lineup.
The club still cratered down the stretch, finished without a winning record, and never came close to a playoff berth. Former GM Jim Bowden even wrote in The Athletic that Minasian should have resigned in protest.
Would Caminero alone have fixed everything? No.
But the point here is simpler than that. A lineup with a bat like his in the heart of it would have looked a lot more workable than the groups the Angels have rolled out on Opening Day over the last two seasons.
And that’s the part that hangs over this whole episode: Moreno had the chance to take a huge swing for the future, and he chose pride instead.
His tenure, the source argues, will be remembered as a failure. Whether he traded Ohtani or not, the outcome was always going to trace back to the same fact: he had Mike Trout and Ohtani, and still couldn’t get the Angels into the playoffs. Instead of facing that reality, he made a decision that kept pushing the franchise backward.
In Other News...
Angels Rebuild Suddenly Hinges On One Difficult Rotation Decision
The Angels rebuild may be heading toward a more aggressive phase next year, with new ownership expected to give the front office more resources to work with. That matters especially on the pitching side, where the organization has some younger arms it can develop, but also enough uncertainty that the rotation could still be reshaped quickly if the right veteran fits come along.
Reid Detmers and rookie Walbert Urena are part of the young core making the case for bigger roles, yet the Angels still have to decide how much of the staff should be handed to pitchers in that category versus more established names. Yusei Kikuchi is one option to keep in the fold, while Sonny Gray is among the veteran starters who could factor into the conversation if the club decides to spend on stability rather than let the kids carry too much too soon. [Read more 🡒]
Angels Coaching Reset Begins After A Collapse Fans Wont Forget
The Angels offseason reset is already underway after a year that left little room for debate. Following a 62-100 finish, the club declined manager Kurt Suzukis contract option after the 2026 season, closing the book on a one-year run that ended with the franchises first 100-loss season and a postseason drought now stretched to 12 years.
The announcement came through the teams official social media, with the organization saying it will work alongside incoming ownership to rebuild the dugout and coaching staff. Suzukis exit is only the first step in what figures to be a broader overhaul, and the next move at manager will say plenty about how aggressively the Angels intend to turn the page. [Read more 🡒]
Angels Dugout Reset Just Put One Bigger Decision In Focus
The Angels are making another clean break in their dugout, declining Kurt Suzukis 2027 option after just one season and signaling that the organization wants a fresh start on the field as well as in the front office. Interim general manager John Mozeliak said Suzuki has been offered a special assistant role within the club, a move that keeps him around the organization even as the search begins for a new manager and coaching staff.
It is the latest sign of how much turnover is ahead in Anaheim after the recent ownership and front office changes, and it puts the next managerial hire squarely in the spotlight. Among the questions now hanging over the process is whether the Angels will lean on an in-house option as they sort through who should guide the next phase of the reset. [Read more 🡒]