Cleveland Browns' Quarterback Conundrum: Sanders vs. Watson
The Cleveland Browns are stirring up quite the quarterback debate this offseason. With a laser focus on revamping the offensive line during free agency, they opted not to bring in another quarterback, setting the stage for an intriguing showdown between Shedeur Sanders and Deshaun Watson for the starting role in 2026.
Financial constraints played a significant role in this decision, ruling out the pursuit of Malik Willis. Trading for a veteran would have meant parting with precious draft picks, something the Browns weren't keen on. However, the door isn’t completely shut on bolstering the position.
According to insider Mary Kay Cabot, the Browns are still eyeing quarterback prospects as the draft approaches. This suggests that Sanders’ hold on the starting job is anything but secure.
“The Browns like Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson, but it remains to be seen if they like him enough to take him in the first round, where he’s likely to go. Simpson has started only 15 games - all last season - but exhibited some tantalizing traits, including quick processing, accuracy, arm strength and mobility,” Cabot noted.
Cleveland's draft picks at No. 6 and No. 24 add layers of complexity. To snag a top-tier quarterback, the Browns might need to maneuver up or down the draft board, leaving GM Andrew Berry juggling immediate needs with long-term potential at the game's most pivotal position.
Sanders’ Unexpected Rise
Shedeur Sanders' rookie season was a rollercoaster, culminating in a promising finish that keeps him in the mix. Initially pegged as a first-round talent, Sanders slipped to the fifth round, picked 144th overall by Cleveland in the 2025 draft, putting him under the microscope from the get-go.
Starting the year as the third-string quarterback under former head coach Kevin Stefanski, Sanders got his break in Week 11 after Dillon Gabriel went down with an injury. Sanders seized his chance, starting the following week against the Las Vegas Raiders, where he threw for 209 yards, one touchdown, and one interception in a 24-10 victory.
Over eight games, Sanders racked up 1,400 passing yards, seven touchdowns, and 10 interceptions, earning a Pro Bowl nod. His stats showcased both his promise and areas needing polish.
With Todd Monken now at the helm and Watson on the mend, the quarterback situation is fluid. Sanders is not just competing for snaps but also for his future with the franchise.
Off the field, Sanders' star is rising. His growing profile has landed him major endorsement deals and made him the most-searched athlete in the U.S. on Google in 2025.
As Cleveland navigates its options, Sanders' development and marketability present a unique evaluation challenge for the Browns.