The Raiders’ Week 7 loss to the Rams was the kind of afternoon that leaves little room for anyone to feel good about the film, and that included the rookie class. With Las Vegas sliding further from the postseason picture, the broader question starts creeping in: if this season keeps drifting in the wrong direction, who among the young players earns a larger piece of the puzzle?
That matters because Klint Kubiak and John Spytek still want to win now. The Raiders are 3-4 and the schedule ahead looks favorable enough to keep that idea alive.
But if the season starts to tilt away from them, the organization can’t afford to repeat the mistake Pete Carroll made. The staff needs to know what it has in its younger players.
Fernando Mendoza, of course, did not factor into Sunday’s game. He received an N/A because he did not play, with in-depth coverage of his situation reserved for the weekly Mendoza Meter.
Among the rookies who did see the field, Treydan Stukes had one of the tougher days. After what had been arguably his best outing as a Raider in Week 6, he stumbled badly against Los Angeles and came away with a D.
He got caught on play-action for a touchdown, missed a tackle, and was pushed out of a few run plays. The talent is there, but it didn’t show up this time.
Trey Zuhn III was one of the few bright spots, even if his role stayed limited. He was used only a handful of times in jumbo packages, yet this was his best performance so far. He was late off the line on one snap, but he also did a nice job moving defenders in the run game and held up well in pass protection while still hunting for work.
Jermod McCoy still hasn’t broken into the cornerback rotation, but he is starting to leave a mark on special teams. Against the Rams, he picked up an assisted tackle there for his first of the season. That effort could eventually open the door for defensive snaps if he keeps trending that way.
Mike Washington Jr. turned in a mixed but worthwhile showing. He carried the ball six times for 27 yards, including a 21-yard run, but five of those carries added up to just six yards.
He also did not catch a pass and had one solid and one rough rep in pass protection. There was enough there to keep the grade above average, but not enough to call it a clean win.
Zeke Masses had a similarly uneven afternoon. In 29 defensive snaps, he didn’t surrender much through the air, but he did get caught on play-action and allowed a touchdown to one of the Rams’ tight ends. Still, he made his presence felt against the run, posting six total tackles without a miss.
Malik Benson made his biggest impact on special teams. He played only three offensive snaps and wasn’t targeted, but he did return two punts for 26 yards, including gains of 14 and 12 yards. That was enough to earn him a B+ despite his limited role on offense.
Tim Keenan III debuted with a C-, and the grade fit the look of a rookie still settling in after not spending the offseason with the team. He flashed at times by moving well and holding his ground, but he also had moments where he was overpowered and beaten.
Brandon Cleveland remained on the practice squad, while Dalton Johnson did not play and carried a season GPA of 1.3 in his lone game. Keyron Crawford is on season-ending IR.
The bottom line from the rookie report is pretty simple: nobody had a great game, and the group wasn’t immune from the mess of Sunday’s loss. But more of these young players are getting chances, and that’s at least something the Raiders can work with.
In Other News...
Raiders Already Have A Kirk Cousins Decision Looming
Kirk Cousins has given the Raiders a steadier hand at quarterback, but his presence has also created an early fork in the road for a team that is still balancing the present against the future. With rookie Fernando Mendoza waiting behind him, Las Vegas is already facing the kind of decision that can shape a season long before the calendar gets deep into fall.
An NFL analyst has even raised the possibility that Cousins could become a trade target before the Nov. 10 deadline, which would instantly add another layer to how the Raiders view their quarterback room. The other path is simpler, and maybe more practical in the short term: keep Cousins in place and let him serve as the veteran guide while Mendoza continues to learn with little NFL experience under his belt. [Read more 🡒]
Raiders Next Game Could Change Everything Around Maxx Crosby Rumors
Four straight losses have pushed the Raiders into a difficult spot, and the next game against the Jets now carries a little more weight than a typical midseason matchup. Team analyst Kirk Morrison called it a must-win, and with the trade deadline drawing closer, the result could shape how aggressively the Raiders approach the roster in the days ahead.
Naturally, that has fed the chatter around Maxx Crosby, whose name is always going to come up when a struggling team starts to wonder about its long-term direction. There is no confirmed trade decision, and the speculation remains just that for now, but the broader uncertainty around the Raiders makes this a situation worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]
Raiders Suddenly Have A WR Problem They Cant Ignore
The Raiders four-game slide has exposed problems all over the roster, but the receiver room is now under a sharper microscope as the offense struggles to find reliable answers. Former Raider Lincoln Kennedy was particularly blunt after the loss to the Rams, pointing to a group that did not consistently separate or make life easier on the quarterback, which only adds to the unease around a unit that has not lived up to the moment.
Tre Tucker has been the clear bright spot at the position, and his recent play has only strengthened the sense that the Raiders need to make a priority out of keeping him around. With free agency approaching, the team is reportedly focused on re-signing him before he can test the market, a signal that Tucker may be the one wideout they can least afford to lose if this offense is going to have any stability going forward. [Read more 🡒]