The Raiders keep circling the same problem, and this offseason may be the point where they finally have to stop pretending Malcolm Koonce is the answer.
Las Vegas has spent year after year trying to find a real partner for Maxx Crosby, and year after year it has come up short. John Spytek tried to patch the issue this past spring by signing Kwity Paye to a three-year, $48 million deal, bringing Koonce back on a one-year, $11 million contract and using a third-round pick on Keyron Crawford in the 2026 NFL Draft.
On paper, it looked like a workable plan. On the field, it has fallen apart.
The result is ugly: the Raiders have one of the worst pass rushes in the league again.
Paye does have an out in his contract after 2027, but that does nothing for next season. Crawford should be back from a season-ending Achilles injury and will be part of the mix, but Las Vegas still cannot keep returning to Koonce and hoping the same story changes. He’s a solid player, just not one who has earned another contract on promise alone.
Koonce has reached the point where the Raiders need more than flashes. He hasn’t played well enough or consistently enough to justify another deal, and the team should move on and let him test the market.
There was a stretch early in the season when it looked like the pass rush might be taking shape. After Week 1, Paye seemed poised to be the Robin to Crosby’s Batman.
When his production dipped, Koonce stepped in and helped keep things moving. He even flashed the version of himself that made this whole idea appealing back in 2023.
That version has disappeared.
Koonce’s snap share has dropped along with his production, and the split between the first five games and the last five tells the story clearly, according to Pro Football Focus, via Bleacher Report’s Matt Holder:
Stat
Weeks 1-5
Weeks 6-10
Sacks
3.0
0.0
Pressures
16
8
Pass-Rush Win Rate
19.4%
10.0%
That kind of decline can’t be blamed entirely on fewer snaps. Koonce has played just four percent fewer snaps from Weeks 6-10 than he did in Weeks 1-5, even with two recent games where his workload was especially light. The drop-off is real.
He was never known as a great run defender, but the selling point was always the pass-rush juice. Right now, that juice isn’t there. The Raiders have already brought him back on short-term deals in each of the last two offseasons, and if he’s not producing now and doesn’t fit into the long-term plan, there’s a simple question staring them in the face: why do it again in March?
If Las Vegas wants to fix this, it needs to look elsewhere for edge help.
The draft could offer some mid-round options, and the Raiders have already seen a couple of them up close this season. LSU’s Jordan Ross and Princewill Umanmielen both fit the kind of profile the team should be studying.
Ross is listed at 6-foot-5 and 254 pounds, and he has shown a real feel for getting to the quarterback and finishing plays. He has 6.0 sacks and 36 total pressures this season, along with an interception and a forced fumble.
He brings speed off the edge, bend, and enough versatility to line up inside, over or outside the tackle. He also holds up against the run and is coming off a strong showing against Texas’ offensive tackles.
Umanmielen is an inch shorter than Ross but weighs the same, and he brings a different kind of complete package. He has athleticism, bend, power and production, plus a knack for showing up in big moments.
This season, he has 9.5 sacks, 39 pressures and 24 run stops. He was productive at Ole Miss last year too, and his brother is currently with the Carolina Panthers after going in the third round in 2025.
The Raiders have seen both players three times, and either one would make sense.
Free agency could also provide a cleaner fix.
Yaya Diaby would be an obvious name to watch if he reaches the market. Spytek already knows him from his time in the Tampa Bay front office, and that connection matters.
Diaby has only 3.0 sacks this season after posting 19.0 total sacks over his first three years, but he’s still affecting the quarterback. His pass-rush win rate is down as well, though he has been dealing with injury and has missed the last few games for Tampa Bay.
If he’s healthy and available, the Raiders should be all over it.
Tuli Tuipulotu is another name worth watching. Chargers GM Joe Hortiz left him out when discussing the team’s young core before the deadline, and that said plenty.
Tuipulotu has also had a quieter year, with 3.0 sacks after piling up 26.0 in his first three seasons. Even so, he remains a strong player.
He has 33 pressures and a 15.7 percent pass-rush win rate, and he’s solid against the run too. He would likely cost plenty and could bring Los Angeles a comp pick, but if the goal is to fix the pass rush, Tuipulotu would help.
In Other News...
Raiders May Need A Drastic Kwity Paye Change Already
Kwity Paye was brought in to make an immediate difference for the Raiders, but through his first 10 games, the production has not matched the contract or the expectation. The most obvious issue has been his pass-rushing effectiveness, which has lagged enough that the conversation around him is already shifting from simple adjustment period to possible role change.
A move inside to defensive tackle is now being floated as a way to better tap into what he does well while also helping a run defense that could use more sturdiness in the middle. It would not be a small tweak, either, since it would mean adding weight and learning a new spot on the fly, but that kind of drastic change is exactly the sort of move the Raiders may have to consider if they want more value from him soon. [Read more 🡒]
Jon Gruden Just Added To The Raiders Defensive Frustration
Jon Gruden added another layer to the Raiders defensive conversation this week, using the Gruden Family Football Show to voice concerns about both the units performance and Rob Leonards play calling. It comes at a time when Las Vegas has little room to shrug off criticism, with the defense sitting at the bottom of the league in overall Pro Football Focus grade and grading poorly against both the run and the pass.
Leonard still has support inside the building, but the questions around his effectiveness are hard to ignore as the struggles continue. For a Raiders team trying to steady itself, the defensive issues have become impossible to separate from the larger picture, and Grudens comments only sharpened the spotlight on a group already under heavy scrutiny. [Read more 🡒]
Raiders May Have Finally Stabilized One Of Their Biggest Line Problems
The Raiders have spent much of the season searching for some stability on the right side of their offensive line, cycling through multiple options at right guard before rookie Trey Zuhn III finally settled into the job after three games. Drafted in 2026, Zuhn has given the team something it badly needed there, especially with his run blocking, which has stood out enough to earn him a longer look.
Klint Kubiak has sounded encouraged by what he has seen so far, pointing to both Zuhns current performance and the room still left for growth. The next step is the one that usually decides whether a young lineman sticks long term, and for Zuhn, pass protection remains the area that will tell the real story. [Read more 🡒]
