The Raiders don’t have much margin for mixed messages right now, and that’s why Maxx Crosby should stay put.
Head coach Klint Kubiak already made his stance clear when he brushed aside any quarterback controversy between Kirk Cousins and Fernando Mendoza. Cousins is the starter, Mendoza is the rookie learning behind him, and the message was simple: the Raiders are trying to win games. That same logic should apply to general manager John Spytek if offers start rolling in for Crosby.
Kubiak put it plainly last week: “ Kirk is playing really well, and we’re in the hunt,” Kubiak said to the media last week. “It’s really important that they keep playing really well behind them and continue to develop Fernando.”
That’s not the kind of line a team throws out when it’s ready to start selling off its best pieces.
At 4-4, Las Vegas is still sitting in the early playoff mix. In a league where one or two breaks can swing a season, the Raiders should be acting like a team that expects to matter in January. Trading Crosby would say the opposite.
And there’s no easy way to replace what he brings.
The Raiders still haven’t found a steady edge partner for Crosby. Kwity Paye flashed in the opener against the Miami Dolphins with 2.0 sacks, but he’s been quiet since.
Malcolm Koonce has shown hints of the player who broke out late in 2023, but he hasn’t recorded a tackle in two weeks. For all the talk around the rest of the front, this remains Crosby’s defense when it comes to the pass rush.
The numbers back that up even if the sack total doesn’t jump off the page. Crosby has only three sacks, but he’s second in the league with 29 pressures and fourth with 12 quarterback hits. Paye and Koonce have combined for 20 pressures and five quarterback hits.
That’s a huge gap, and it helps explain why the Raiders are generating the third-highest pressure rate in the NFL at 28.4 percent. Only the Minnesota Vikings and Seattle Seahawks are ahead of them.
Take Crosby out of that equation, and the defense would take a major hit. The Raiders already rank 25th in passing yards allowed and are even worse against the run. Losing their best edge threat would make life easier for quarterbacks and open the door even wider for opposing ground games.
Still, the case against a trade goes beyond the defense itself.
Crosby matters in the locker room, too. He’s one of the team’s leaders, and moving him would send a jolt through a young group that leans on him. Even with his past openness to a change of scenery before the trade with the Baltimore Ravens fell apart this offseason, Crosby now sounds like a player who wants to stay in Las Vegas and keep building.
“I’m excited ’bout everything,” said via The Athletic’s Sam Warren. “I love being a Raider.
Said that a million times, and yeah, this is where I want to be. Super excited for, obviously, the present, but what’s to come as well.”
ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported the same basic picture from the team side.
“Unlike last year, when Crosby openly wondered about his future in Las Vegas, this year he doesn’t want to go anywhere, and the Raiders currently have no plans to trade him, according to league sources.”
That doesn’t mean the door is locked forever. An offer strong enough to match Spytek’s demand for two first-round picks would at least force a real conversation, and a lopsided Week 9 loss to the San Francisco 49ers could also change the mood. But short of that kind of haul, moving Crosby would make little sense for a team trying to win now.
If Koonce were breaking out or Paye were living up to the three-year, $48 million contract he signed, the calculus would look different. If the Raiders were buried at the bottom of the standings, it would look different too.
But they aren’t there. They can still finish with more than twice as many wins as last season, and Crosby could still be part of another step forward in 2027 while playing through his age-30 season. His timeline may not line up perfectly with the rebuild, but his production hasn’t shown a major drop.
For now, the Raiders’ best move is the simplest one: keep the player who still drives the defense and still gives them a chance to matter.
In Other News...
Raiders Face A Trade Deadline Choice That Could Define This Run
The Raiders have spent the first part of the season making a better case for themselves than almost anyone expected, and that has turned the next few weeks into a real test of how serious they are about staying in the playoff picture. With the November 10 trade deadline approaching, the front office has a chance to answer a simple question: is this a team content to ride the momentum, or one willing to push chips in while the window is open?
The roster has clear pressure points, even if the record has softened some of the early skepticism. Help at wide receiver would make life easier on Ashton Jeanty and give the offense more balance, while the defensive front could use another body to complement Maxx Crosby and keep the pass rush from wearing down. Several names have surfaced as possible fits, and the Raiders now have to decide whether to stand pat or make the kind of move that can shape the rest of this run. [Read more 🡒]
Broncos Face Early Roster Pressure Around J.K. Dobbins And Secondary
Maxx Crosby has been one of the more steady voices around the Raiders as camp chatter starts to settle into real roster questions, and he sounded encouraged by where the team is headed. The veteran edge rusher said he likes the locker room and trusts the new leadership, while also pointing to both Klint Kubiak and first-time defensive coordinator Rob Leonard as reasons for his optimism about the direction of the group.
On offense, the conversation around Ashton Jeanty has already taken on a familiar training-camp split: what he has done as a receiver versus what he has shown as a runner. Offensive coordinator Andrew Janocko said Jeantys work in the passing game has been stronger than his production on the ground, but the team is treating the rushing issues as something bigger than one back, a sign that the Raiders are still sorting out how the whole offense wants to function. [Read more 🡒]
Raiders May Have Found A First Round Answer To Their Guard Problem
The Raiders have spent enough time searching for stability inside that any promising young lineman is worth a long look, and Minnesota guard Greg Johnson is starting to look like the kind of first-round option that could fit the bill. He brings the size teams want up front, and his tape points to a blocker who can help in both phases, giving Las Vegas a potential answer to a spot that has been a recurring problem.
What makes Johnson especially intriguing is how much more than a simple guard prospect he appears to be. His versatility gives him appeal across the offensive line, and his work in pass protection and run blocking suggests a player who could step into a bigger role quickly if he continues on this path toward the 2027 NFL Draft. For a Raiders team trying to build real durability in the trenches, that kind of flexibility is hard to ignore. [Read more 🡒]