John Spyteks Early Raiders Picks Are Already Sparking One Big Debate

Explore the mixed success of John Spytek's draft picks as we rank the top 10 selections of his tenure with the Raiders.

The Raiders’ recent skid has put John Spytek’s draft record under the microscope, and the early returns are a mixed bag at best. With six losses in their last seven games, the GM has drawn heat for both his free-agent moves and, more pointedly, his draft classes. It’s still early, of course, but the picks are starting to form a picture.

Here’s the current rundown of Spytek’s 10 best selections since he arrived in 2025, from the bottom up.

At No. 10 is Jack Bech, the 2025 second-round wideout. The production hasn’t been there, but he’s at least been on the field, and that matters when comparing him with players who haven’t seen much action.

Bech doesn’t bring an elite trait to the table, though he does have reliable hands and brings physicality as a blocker. Even so, he’s not a sure thing to be back next year.

Hezekiah Masses lands at No. 9 after a season that includes three interoceptions. That total should help his case, but two of those picks were basically handed to him, and his coverage work has been uneven outside of a few flashes. Still, for a fifth-round corner, there’s real potential in his traits.

Caleb Rogers comes in at No. 8.

There was some buzz around him before the season, but after three starts and shaky play, his path to more snaps looks murky. He has put some rough tape out there, and those plays are hard to forget.

The Raiders do have people in the building pulling for him, though, because from a character standpoint, Rogers everything a head coach and GM can hope for.

Darien Porter checks in at No. 7.

He’s often near the action, just not quite making the play. That said, he’s higher on this list than some might expect because the traits are there for him to become a very good NFL corner.

He’s still relatively new to the position, so there’s time for things to start clicking.

Trey Zuhn III sits at No. 6.

Spytek reportedly had him on a short list heading into the 2026 draft, and so far the pick has held up. In two starts this season, Zuhn has avoided the kind of negative moments that have shown up elsewhere on the line.

There’s upside here, and he looks like a player with a real future in the starting lineup.

Mike Washington Jr. comes in at No. 5, and he’s been one of the better surprises in the class. The rookie back has already looked like a strong fit in Klint Kubiak’s system, even if he still needs work as a blocker and receiver. Spytek also noted before the season that it was Kubiak who was pounding the table for Washington, and that call is looking smart.

Ashton Jeanty lands at No. 4.

Given the draft slot and the production, he could probably be lower, but the big plays from his rookie year and his Boise State résumé keep him in this spot for now. The Raiders’ offensive line has held him back, and until that changes, he won’t hit his ceiling.

Tonka Hemingway is No. 3.

He may be a touch high, but the flashes have been real, and the Raiders need impact from him at a position where help is badly needed. Hemingway had four sacks in the Raiders’ last five games in 2025, though he has only one sack this year and hasn’t popped on film the same way.

There’s still upside, but the next stretch matters.

Treydan Stukes is No. 2 and looks like one of the clearest wins of Spytek’s tenure. The safety has started all but one game this season, missing only Week 3 at New Orleans, and he doesn’t seem to have any glaring holes in his game. He may not be the next Ed Reed, but he projects as one of the better safeties in the league and might be the best value pick Spytek has made so far.

Fernando Mendoza takes the top spot, though the case is more about pedigree than production. Spytek gets some credit for taking the obvious choice with the no. 1 pick in last year’s draft, but Tom Brady had plenty of input too.

Mendoza hasn’t done enough yet to fully justify the ranking, but his college season at Indiana was strong enough to keep him at No. 1.

He also played pretty well against the Seahawks on Sunday, even if the second half faded.

There’s still time for these picks to move around, and maybe Jermod McCoy or Keyron Crawford would have changed the whole conversation. But right now, the list is what it is, and it doesn’t exactly scream confidence.

In Other News...

Maxx Crosbys Kirk Cousins Reaction Says A Lot About Raiders Reset

The Raiders decision to move on from Kirk Cousins was part of a broader reset, and Maxx Crosbys reaction on his podcast offered a reminder of how the locker room viewed the veteran quarterback. Crosby called Cousins a great teammate and a professional, which fits the tone around a deal that sent Cousins back to Minnesota in exchange for a 2027 third-round pick. It was the kind of trade that signals a team is looking ahead, even if the short-term optics are always a little messy.

Cousins first game back with the Vikings only sharpened the contrast, as he helped lead Minnesota past Green Bay with 207 passing yards and two touchdowns. For the Raiders, the move is less about what Cousins did elsewhere than what it says about where they are now: clearing space, collecting future value and leaning into a new direction. Crosbys comments made clear there was respect for the player, even if the organization had already decided it was time to turn the page. [Read more 🡒]

Raiders Playoff Hopes Feel More Real Than Fans Might Think

The Raiders season has felt like a grind for weeks, with a 4-6 record and six losses in their last seven games leaving little margin for error. Still, they are not out of the AFC picture, and with eight games left there is enough runway for the standings to shift if they can start stacking wins. A Week 12 matchup with the Browns looms as one of the more important checkpoints in that push, especially with so many other teams in the conference still sorting themselves out.

Las Vegas does not need a miracle so much as a turnaround, and the path is more about surviving the next stretch than chasing some dramatic finish line. The remaining schedule offers both obstacles and openings, which is why the playoff conversation is not as far-fetched as it might sound from the outside. For a team that has spent much of the fall trying to stop the slide, the next few weeks will say plenty about whether this remains a long shot or starts to look like a real race. [Read more 🡒]

Raiders Progress Keeps Pointing To One Offseason Problem

The Raiders have taken real steps forward this season, but the same weak spot keeps surfacing in the back end of the defense. Head coach Klint Kubiak recently acknowledged that veteran cornerback Eric Stokes was benched for some plays because of performance issues, even while stressing that Stokes still matters to the defense. It was a reminder that the progress in Las Vegas has not been evenly distributed, and the secondary remains the area most likely to undo the good work elsewhere.

Defensive coordinator Rob Leonard has been leaning on younger defensive backs as part of the answer, but the rotation also underscores how thin the group still is. The Raiders are clearly trying to find combinations that hold up week to week, yet the depth and talent concerns in the defensive backfield are not going away quietly. With an offseason fix looming, this is shaping up as one of the front offices biggest priorities. [Read more 🡒]