Heading into Week 18, the quarterback carousel has already spun through 10 teams, and the mix of reasons behind those changes makes this season stand out. Some clubs are turning to rookies, some are patching over injuries, and some are simply trying to find out what they have before the year runs out.
The most notable shift is happening in Las Vegas and Minnesota, where there’s a clean two-for-one swap. Fernando Mendoza, the No. 1 pick, is stepping in for the Raiders, while Kirk Cousins takes over for the Vikings after being traded at the deadline.
Cousins is back with his old team, and Las Vegas gets a look at Mendoza at the same time. Mendoza’s first start also arrives just in time for the 2026 Topps Chrome Football release, which has to have Fanatics pretty happy.
Arizona is making a change of its own, with Carson Beck taking over for the Cardinals. Jacoby Brissett was traded to the Ravens, and Gardner Minshew is headed to IR, opening the door for Beck.
He and Haynes King of the Carolina Panthers put on an epic quarterback duel in the Hall of Fame Game in August, which got people wondering whether Beck could be the Cardinals’ quarterback of the future. He was hurt in his first start and will miss this week, but he still looks positioned to be the biggest chase in the current class behind Mendoza.
The Giants’ situation has settled into a different kind of story. JJ McCarthy is one of only two quarterbacks from the 2024 class with True Panini RPAs, alongside Michael Penix, and he has taken over for Jameis Winston, who had replaced Jaxson Dart after Dart’s season-ending knee injury in Week 2. The former Michigan national champion appears to have found his footing with his new team, and New York is one of the few clubs on this list with a real shot at the playoffs.
Anthony Richardson remains one of the most intriguing names in the group. He was the third quarterback selected in 2023, behind Bryce Young and CJ Stroud, and he’s 8-7 as an NFL starter.
He may also be the most talented quarterback on the board here. The question is whether he’ll get a chance to show it on an Colts team that moved most of its offensive assets at the trade deadline.
Seattle is asking Drew Lock to do the heavy lifting for an offense that has looked extremely pedestrian this season, even after a Super Bowl Championship. Lock began his career in Denver, and the source material notes that he has outplayed Sam Darnold throughout the season.
Miami is not headed to the playoffs, and Kyle McCord is not expected to change that. The Dolphins are likely looking at a Top 3 pick in the draft, and the real question is whether they already have a quarterback they can pair with Jeremiah Smith or whether they need to go find one themselves.
Philadelphia is in a different kind of bind after losing Jalen Hurts for the year. Joe Milton has a big arm and has bounced around, having spent time with the Patriots and started the year on the Dallas Cowboys’ practice squad. The Eagles now have to decide whether he can be more than a short-term answer and whether they can give him a long-term opportunity.
Baltimore made its move after losing both Lamar Jackson and Tyler Huntley to long-term injuries. UDFA Joe Fagnano got a shot, but after back-to-back losses to the Jaguars and previously 0-8 LA Chargers, the Ravens traded for Jacoby Brissett, who had been Arizona’s Week 1 starter.
New England is also going back to a familiar name. Tommy DeVito returns for the Patriots after rising to fame with the Giants a few seasons ago. The Patriots opened the season with winning aspirations after reaching the Super Bowl last year, but DeVito arrives with plenty of NFL chances already behind him and very little to show for them.
When you zoom out across the top quarterback markets, the pattern is clear: the biggest names are first-round picks who are playing for the teams that drafted them. Fernando Mendoza fits that mold, but there’s an important wrinkle.
Many of those quarterbacks were not Day 1 starters. Caleb Williams, Joe Burrow, and Trevor Lawrence were taken first overall and started in Week 1.
Josh Allen and Justin Herbert entered during their first season, more like Mendoza. Patrick Mahomes and Jordan Love waited a full season or longer before taking over.
The takeaway is straightforward: Mendoza’s draft capital gives him room to keep growing in the market. Still, with multiple sales above $10,000, a lot of that upside already appears to be baked in. The safer play is to stick with Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, Patrick Mahomes, and Brock Purdy.
The advice is to buy the dip on proven quarterbacks dealing with injuries, like Jaxson Dart and Lamar Jackson. As for the new starters, the warning is simple: the odds of these players sticking have historically been low.
In Other News...
Mark Davis Just Turned The Madden Movie Into A Raiders Fight
Mark Davis has never been shy about defending the Raiders legacy, and his latest comments on the Madden movie made clear he felt the film missed the mark. While he praised Christian Bales performance, Davis said the script took too many liberties with the truth and turned both his father, Al Davis, and John Madden into unfair caricatures instead of the figures he knew from the family history and the franchises past.
For Davis, the issue is bigger than one Hollywood project. His criticism suggests a deeper push to control how the Raiders story gets told, especially when it comes to the complicated relationship between two of the most important names in team history. He also made clear hed like to create a more accurate depiction of his father down the road, leaving open the possibility that the Raiders version of this era is still waiting to be properly put on screen. [Read more 🡒]
Fernando Mendoza Just Put The Raiders In An Unexpected Award Race
Fernando Mendozas first NFL start in Week 10 gave the Raiders something they have not had much of this season: a fresh storyline with real staying power. The rookie quarterback threw for 143 yards and added 22 rushing yards with a touchdown, enough to get immediate attention beyond Las Vegas and put his name into a conversation that usually belongs to players who have been around longer than a single Sunday.
Oddsmakers have already made Mendoza the favorite for Offensive Rookie of the Year, a reflection of both his upside and a rookie class that has not produced much separation. The bigger question now is whether he can keep building on that debut in the weeks ahead, because his case will be shaped not just by his own play but by how the Raiders finish and whether they can stay in the postseason picture. [Read more 🡒]
Raiders Run Defense Problem Could Make This Prospect Hard To Ignore
The Raiders run defense has been one of the clearest weak spots of the season, and it has put a spotlight on a defensive tackle room that has not come close to solving the problem. Las Vegas has been near the bottom of the league in rushing yards allowed and yards per carry, and the lack of impact inside has shown up in the grades too, with no member of the group earning an average run defense mark from Pro Football Focus.
That is why ESPN draft analyst Jordan Reids 2027 mock draft is worth a look for Raiders fans already thinking about the next fix. Reid projects Las Vegas to take Tennessee defensive tackle Xavier Gilliam, a move that would line up neatly with the teams need to get sturdier up front and make life harder on opposing run games. [Read more 🡒]
