ESPN’s rules analyst wasn’t buying the safety call that swung Saturday’s SEC matchup between No. 11 Kentucky and Florida.
Late in the first half in Lexington, Kentucky OT Lance Heard was flagged for holding in the end zone, and the penalty was ruled a safety. That handed Florida two points and pushed the score to 7-2 Kentucky.
But on the broadcast, ESPN rules expert Jerry McGinn said the call should not have stood as a safety after further review. The key issue was where the hold began.
“The hold started in the field of play. It finished in the end zone, but started in the field of play,” McGinn said.
“It should be enforced from the field of play, not the end zone. This should not be a safety.
“In real time, you should know where the hold starts. You want to see the whole play.
When you’re ever gonna give points away, you better make real sure you know where the enforcement is. Someone can always help, whether it be another referee or the short wing.
But, someone can help him. The umpire can jump him.
But, the hold started at the one-yard line. Maybe the two.”
The call drew disagreement from Kroger Field and from the broadcast itself.
The officiating criticism comes at a time when SEC commissioner Greg Sankey has already taken aim at ESPN’s rules analysts. Earlier this week, Sankey pushed back hard on the way announcers have been handling officiating discussions.
“Now I’ll say this: I am highly disappointed in announcers and their criticism,” Sankey said on The Paul Finebaum Show. “And they’re wrong.
Some of the worst officials in America are those in the announce booth. We have officiating experts, who I turned on a game on Saturday, who was just flat wrong.
“And what that creates is this narrative that we’ve done something wrong and that is unacceptable to me, and we have to address that. We’re going to be wrong.
We’ve made announcements when we own it. We’re going to have debates about judgment calls.”
In Other News...
Kentucky Legend Just Put Mark Popes Start Under A Harsh Spotlight
Kentuckys narrow win over Northern Arizona did little to calm the nerves around a program that has looked uneven and vulnerable far too often this season. The ball movement has had its bright spots, but the broader picture has been harder to ignore, with the defense continuing to draw criticism and the overall performance leaving fans and observers wanting more from a team that was supposed to look more settled by now.
Jamal Mashburn added to that pressure by openly questioning the state of the defense and the direction of Mark Popes tenure, a pointed reminder that expectations around Kentucky are never small. In his third year, Pope is already facing a louder conversation about whether this group is meeting the standard, and the uneasy feeling around the program is only growing as results like this keep piling up. [Read more 🡒]
Kentucky Escaped With A Win But Mark Pope Saw A Bigger Problem
Kentucky got the result it needed at Rupp Arena, edging Northern Arizona 78-77, but the box score told a less comforting story. The Wildcats were beaten badly on the glass, with Northern Arizona pulling down 32 rebounds to Kentuckys 20 and turning that edge into 11 second-chance points, the kind of gap that can erase a talent advantage in a hurry.
Mark Pope did not try to soften it afterward, and Malachi Moreno echoed the point by calling the rebounding effort unacceptable. For a team trying to build habits early, the concern is bigger than surviving a close call against a lower-profile opponent, because nights like this tend to expose the exact flaw that can travel with a team if it is not cleaned up quickly. [Read more 🡒]
Kentuckys Playoff Hopes Just Ran Into The Same Old Problem
Kentuckys playoff push took another hit Saturday in a 21-14 loss to Florida, a result that left the Wildcats with their third defeat of the season and made the road to the College Football Playoff look far steeper. The game started with promise after Kentucky put together an early strong drive, but the offense never fully settled in after that, and the margin for error kept shrinking as Florida leaned on its ground game and controlled the key moments.
Aaron Philo was a major part of that for Florida, piling up 102 rushing yards and a touchdown while Kentucky struggled to answer. A costly fumble by Kenny Minchey swung momentum the wrong way, and Florida finished the job with a late fourth-quarter touchdown drive, the kind of closing sequence that has become all too familiar for teams trying to stay alive in the playoff picture. [Read more 🡒]
