Kirk Herbstreit didn’t hold back after the latest College Football Playoff rankings, and Oklahoma took the brunt of it.
Appearing on “The Pat McAfee Show” on Thursday, the ESPN analyst questioned how the committee handled the bottom of the Top 25 and unloaded on the Sooners, who debuted at No. 22.
“What happened at the bottom doesn’t make a lot of sense to me with South Carolina losing at Arkansas,” Herbstreit said. “Oklahoma has been trash all year.”
Oklahoma’s placement came after Sunday’s 24-17 win over Ole Miss, and the Sooners landed one spot behind South Carolina, which beat them 42-25 in Norman, and one spot ahead of 7-3 Louisville. Herbstreit said he liked Arizona’s jump to No. 19 after its 40-39 loss to unbeaten Utah, but he wasn’t sold on the cluster of four-loss SEC teams sitting below the Wildcats.
“I’m not a big fan of a lot of those teams down there [in the rankings] from the SEC,” Herbstreit said.
The rankings debate also tied into the conference-strength conversation Heather Dinich raised this week. The SEC placed nine teams in the rankings, and Oklahoma’s profile is the kind that fuels the argument: a win over then-No. 1 Texas, but four losses overall, including two at home.
That’s a long way from where the season started. Oklahoma opened No. 10 in the AP poll after a 10-3 finish and a playoff trip, with quarterback John Mateer back for his senior year. But the offense stumbled early in a 17-10 loss at Michigan, followed by a 14-6 win over New Mexico and a 41-13 defeat at Georgia.
The Sooners then pulled off their biggest win of the year, stunning top-ranked Texas 27-24 in Dallas. But the momentum didn’t last. A 21-13 home loss to Kentucky followed, with Mateer throwing three interceptions, and then came a 42-25 home loss to South Carolina that dropped Oklahoma to 4-4.
After that game, coach Brent Venables didn’t sugarcoat it.
“We just didn’t coach well, didn’t have [them] well prepared, didn’t play good,” Venables said.
Two days later, Venables fired offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle and handed play-calling duties to tight ends coach Jason Witten. At the time, Oklahoma ranked 111th nationally in total offense, and Mateer had accounted for nine turnovers in the first six games.
The move has at least steadied things. Oklahoma won 23-7 at Florida and then held off Ole Miss, and Venables said he’s “really proud of John, everything he’s had to fight through and overcome this season.”
Herbstreit’s criticism doesn’t erase the Texas upset, which undercuts his own read on the Sooners. Before that game, he picked the Longhorns and said, “I just don’t think they can win, with the offense the way they are playing.”
Venables is secure for now after Oklahoma gave him a six-year, $63 million extension in August, with a $51.67 million buyout if he were fired after this season. Still, he has now dismissed two offensive coordinators in the middle of a season - Seth Littrell in 2024 and Arbuckle this year - and a strong finish would go a long way toward easing the pressure in Norman.
Oklahoma’s next test comes Saturday against Texas A&M at 3:45 p.m. ET on ESPN2, and the regular season ends Nov. 28 at Missouri.
In Other News...
Two Former Kentucky Wildcats Just Landed Intriguing New Pro Opportunities
The UFLs first in-person draft in St. Louis gave a couple of former Kentucky Wildcats a fresh pro football path, with familiar names popping up as the league began building out its next wave of rosters. Former Kentucky wide receiver Fred Farrier came off the board in the 10th round to the Louisville Kings, while offensive tackle Shiyazh Pete was taken in the 8th round by the Dallas Renegades after already spending time in the NFL orbit with the Cowboys as an undrafted free agent.
For Kentucky fans, it is another reminder that the programs reach continues well beyond Lexington, even when players are looking for a different route to stick at the next level. The UFLs draft format adds a little more intrigue to those opportunities, and both Farrier and Pete now have a chance to turn a new setting into a real football foothold, with their next steps still to be sorted out as these rosters take shape. [Read more 🡒]
Kentuckys Slide Just Changed How One CFP Contender Is Being Viewed
Greg McElroys latest take on the College Football Playoff picture has added another layer to the debate around where Texas belongs in the rankings. He said he believes the Longhorns should be placed ahead of Alabama, pointing to Texas wins over top 25 teams and the way it has handled highly rated opponents as the basis for that view.
For Kentucky fans keeping an eye on the wider SEC race, it is another reminder of how much every result can reshape the national conversation. Texas and Alabama still look positioned to land high seeds if they keep winning, but the order matters, and McElroys stance shows just how closely the committees next move will be watched. [Read more 🡒]
Mizzou Suddenly Has A Week 12 Threat Fans Wont Want To Ignore
Kentucky is back in the conversation for a Week 12 upset spot, and the matchup with Missouri has enough intrigue to make people around the SEC pay attention. The Wildcats are part of a five-game list of potential shockers this week, alongside Nebraska over Ohio State, Cal over Stanford, Arizona State over Oklahoma State and San Jose State over UNLV, with the picks shaped by recent form, standings and the schedules ahead.
For Kentucky, the appeal is simple: this is the kind of game that can flip the mood around a season in a hurry if the right breaks go its way. DraftKings odds are part of the discussion, but the bigger point is that Missouri has been put on alert for a reason, and Week 12 suddenly carries the kind of danger that can make a favorite sweat long before kickoff. [Read more 🡒]
