Kansas State's Biggest QB Debate Starts Behind Avery Johnson

With Kansas State Football's season opener just around the corner, a deep dive into the quarterback depth chart raises intriguing questions about Avery Johnson's potential record-breaking season and the backup dynamics with Dillon Duff and Blake Barn

Kansas State’s quarterback room has a clear headliner, but the real intrigue starts behind Avery Johnson.

Johnson sits firmly at No. 1 on the Wildcats’ depth chart, and for good reason. He’s entering what the source describes as his fourth season and is on track to finish with multiple all-time Kansas State quarterback records.

The bigger picture, though, is where his future could take the roster next. He was originally heading into his senior season, but now the eligibility picture has shifted, and he’s effectively moving through the old college-football terminology as a redshirt junior.

The ideal outcome for Kansas State is simple: Johnson puts together a huge year, pushes the Wildcats to the Big 12 Championship and heads to the NFL draft. But if he comes back for another season, the rest of the quarterback board changes in a hurry.

That’s why the backup discussion matters. The depth chart projection has Dillon Duff ahead of Blake Barnett, even though the writer notes that if Barnett has had the better camp, he would be the backup instead.

The reasoning here is tied to eligibility and retention. Duff is a year behind Barnett, and the thought is that he may be easier to bring back for another season if Johnson stays in 2027.

Barnett, meanwhile, has already waited his turn, and another year of delay could make a future move more likely if he’s still blocked from the starting job.

The projection also reflects a broader philosophy about how valuable every snap can be. If all else is equal, the idea is to invest those reps in the player more likely to return and turn them into production down the line. Whether that actually factors into the staff’s thinking is another matter, but it’s part of the new reality coaches and general managers have to navigate in 2026.

Jacob Knuth is still listed as a quarterback, but the update on him is that he’s trying to get on the field as a special teamer in 2026. Even so, he brings experience and gives Kansas State what amounts to a dependable emergency option at the bottom of the room. If Johnson, Duff and Barnett were all unavailable on game day, the Wildcats would still have a quarterback with meaningful experience to turn to.

Johnson remains the ceiling for this offense. Still, the source argues the floor does not collapse if Duff or Barnett are forced into extended action. Both are said to fit the Klein offense better in some ways than Johnson, and with Kansas State’s running back talent this season, either one should be able to hold things together against most of the Big 12, with the upper tier of the league still the toughest test.

In Other News...

Jay Harris Gives Kansas State A New Weapon Fans Will Watch Closely

Jay Harris is already making an impression in Manhattan, and Kansas State has every reason to believe the transfer running back can be part of the offense right away in 2026. The move from Oregon brings a player with real game experience, and his path through Northwest Missouri State and then into a deeper Power Four program has only added to the buzz around what he might become for the Wildcats.

Coaches and teammates have pointed to Harris physical style and burst as reasons he stands out, the kind of back who can change the feel of a practice rep or a game series. He showed flashes at Oregon in 2024 with carries, scores and work on special teams, and now the more interesting question for Kansas State is how quickly that production translates into a bigger role when the games count. [Read more 🡒]

Kansas State Still Has One Big O-Line Concern Before The Opener

With the season opener against Nicholls now just days away, Kansas State is still sorting out a major question on the offensive line. The Wildcats lost John Pastore and George Fitzpatrick for the season to injuries, leaving coach Collin Klein and offensive coordinator Sean Gleeson to piece together a plan at left tackle while the rest of the front continues its prep for Sept. 5.

A committee approach appears to be the way forward for now, and freshman Oliver Miller has emerged as a player to watch in that mix. Even so, the uncertainty up front gives Kansas State one of its most important pregame decisions, because protecting the edge is never a detail you want to leave unsettled this close to kickoff. [Read more 🡒]

Collin Klein Could Change One Big Thing About K-States Offense

Collin Klein is back running Kansas States offense, and one of the biggest changes he wants to make is simple enough in theory: get more plays off. The Wildcats operated at 73.7 plays per game in 2023 with Klein calling the shots, and the broader idea now is to lean into tempo and rhythm in a way that fits what the game is asking for instead of letting the offense drift into long stretches without much urgency.

Klein has made clear he likes a faster pace, but he is also not treating tempo like a one-size-fits-all answer. The goal is to be more intentional about when to speed up and when to settle in, which matters for a Kansas State offense trying to stay on schedule and keep opponents from getting comfortable. If that balance clicks, it could be one of the quieter but most meaningful shifts in how the Wildcats attack this season. [Read more 🡒]