The Royals have had their share of trade misfires over the years, but some of the best deals in franchise history were the kind that left the other side wondering how it happened. With the November 18 blockbuster that sent former All-Star Maikel Garcia and right-handed pitchers James McArthur and L.P.
Langevin to the Seattle Mariners for starting pitchers Bryce Miller and Logan Evans and reliever Jose A. Ferrer, fans on both sides immediately started arguing over who got fleeced.
That kind of debate is nothing new around Kansas City.
If you want a reminder of how lopsided a trade can look in hindsight, the Royals have a few classic examples. These are the moves that worked out almost entirely in Kansas City’s favor - the ones still talked about as straight-up heists.
One of the earliest and most dramatic came in the fall of 1971, when the Royals were looking for offense after an 85-76 season that left them second in the AL West. They went after Houston Astros first baseman John Mayberry, and the payoff was huge.
Mayberry spent six seasons in Kansas City, posting 21.4 bWAR, hitting 143 home runs and driving in 552 runs. He also made two All-Star teams.
Houston, meanwhile, got very little back from RHP Jim York, who finished with a combined -0.7 bWAR in four seasons with the club. Lefty Lance Clemons did eventually get moved to the St.
Louis Cardinals in the deal that brought pitcher Jerry Reuss to Houston.
Another steal came before the 1988 season, when the Royals landed RHP Jeff Montgomery from the Cincinnati Reds for outfielder Van Snider. Montgomery had just gone through a rough rookie year in 1987, but Kansas City turned him into the greatest closer in team history.
Over 12 seasons with the Royals, he made three All-Star teams and collected 304 saves, which ranks 28th in MLB history. He wasn’t a huge strikeout arm, but he got the job done year after year.
Snider, by contrast, barely made a dent in the majors. He appeared in only 19 career at-bats, picked up seven hits in 35 at-bats over two seasons with the Reds, and after 1989 never got close to the big leagues again.
The biggest name on this list might be Amos Otis. In December 1969, the Royals acquired the outfielder from the New York Mets along with RHP Bob Johnson in exchange for Joe Foy.
Otis had been limited early in his Mets career, so the move didn’t seem outrageous at the time. But in Kansas City, he blossomed immediately, making the All-Star team in 1970 and putting up a 4.1 bWAR season.
He went on to become one of the defining players in franchise history, piling up 44.8 bWAR with the Royals and nearly reaching 2,000 career hits in a Kansas City uniform. Foy never came close to matching that production.
He spent one season with the Mets, hit six home runs and drove in 37 runs in 322 at-bats, then was taken by the Washington Senators in the 1970 Rule 5 Draft after the season.
In Other News...
Royals Offseason Plan Just Shifted After A Trade Fans Will Debate
The pitching market keeps moving, and Tarik Skubal is now part of the conversation after the Padres met with the free agent left-hander, joining other clubs that have already had discussions with him. Around the same time, the Royals made one of the more notable moves of the offseason by completing a six-player trade with the Mariners, a deal that sent Maikel Garcia, Bryce Miller, Jose A. Ferrer, Logan Evans and James McArthur into the spotlight as both teams reshaped their plans.
For Kansas City, the trade is the kind of move that can ripple through the rest of the winter, especially with rival clubs still active in pitching pursuit and the Twins also adding Sonny Gray on a two-year deal. Fans will debate the direction of the swap for a while, since it changes the Royals' immediate outlook and may affect how aggressively they need to keep shopping for help in the months ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Patrick Mahomes Weighed In On A Royals Move Fans Will Feel
Patrick Mahomes had a familiar kind of split reaction to the Royals move involving Maikel Garcia, the All-Star third baseman who was dealt to the Seattle Mariners. As part of the clubs ownership group, Mahomes has a stake in the long view, and he framed the trade in the same practical terms the front office would - a step aimed at improving the pitching staff and keeping the team in the mix for the postseason.
Still, the emotional side of it was hard to miss, because Garcia had become one of the more recognizable pieces on the roster. Mahomes said he wished him well, even as he acknowledged the business of the move, and his attention is also being pulled toward another Kansas City title chase with the Current heading into the NWSL Championship Game. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Bullpen Rebuild Comes Down To A Tough Call Ahead
After a rough 2026 season, the Royals have spent the early part of the offseason trying to steady a pitching staff that needed help in a hurry. Kansas City has already added Bryce Miller and Angel Bastardo, and it agreed to a salary with Randy Dobnak for 2027, moves that point to a front office still looking for ways to deepen the staff without getting reckless. General manager J.J. Picollo has made it clear the club plans to be careful with bullpen spending, which makes every roster decision feel a little more consequential.
The next pressure point arrives with the November 20 non-tender deadline, when the Royals will have to decide whether to keep Lucas Erceg, Nate Pearson and Anthony Gose on the books. Their performance and salary figures will all factor into those calls, and with Kansas City trying to rebuild the bullpen on a measured budget, the margin for error is thin. It is the kind of offseason crossroads that can quietly reshape a relief corps before spring training even begins. [Read more 🡒]
