Jac Caglianone gave the Royals exactly what they needed at the plate in 2026. What comes next is a lot murkier, because his defensive home is suddenly one of Kansas City’s more interesting offseason questions.
After a rough debut in 2025, when he hit just .157 with a .532 OPS in 62 games, Caglianone turned the page in a big way this season. The 23-year-old led the Royals in batting average (.289), slugging percentage (.494) and OPS (.834), and he finished among the club’s top three in runs (72), hits (148), home runs (23) and RBIs (75).
Most of that work came in right field, where he played 95 games. But first base kept calling him back, and not just occasionally. Injuries to Vinnie Pasquantino created multiple openings, giving Caglianone extended chances at a position he had already played at the University of Florida and in the Minor Leagues before Kansas City shifted him to the outfield.
His first long look at first base came in June after Pasquantino had surgery to repair a fractured hamate bone. Caglianone got another run there when Pasquantino went on the 10-day injured list with right wrist soreness on July 29.
During the 16 starts before Pasquantino returned on Aug. 17, Caglianone raked: .387 with a 1.148 OPS, six homers and 20 RBIs.
By season’s end, he had appeared in 39 games, with 30 starts, at first base - his most extensive major league work at the position. At first, he hit .291/.316/.614 with a .930 OPS in 133 plate appearances. In right field, he posted a .300/.350/.481 line and an .831 OPS across 363 plate appearances.
The outfield, though, came with plenty of rough edges. Caglianone’s year there was interrupted by injuries of his own, starting on June 5 when he hurt his right shoulder crashing into the wall while tracking a double against the Twins in Minnesota. He stayed in that game, but soreness knocked him out of the next one.
The same shoulder flared up again on July 21 against the Giants, when he aggravated it on a diving attempt down the right-field line. He waved off medical attention, finished the inning and was pulled in the sixth before missing the following day’s lineup.
Then came another issue on Sept. 5 against the Blue Jays, when Caglianone left with left elbow soreness after uncorking a 95.2 mph throw from right field. Imaging showed a Grade 1 flexor strain, and the Royals shut him down from throwing for a stretch.
Even with those setbacks, the arm played loud. Caglianone averaged 98.7 mph on his throws from right field and delivered seven outfield assists. But the defensive numbers also reflected the learning curve, as he finished with minus-9 outs above average and two errors in the outfield.
Pasquantino is still Kansas City’s primary first baseman, but he could also be one of the position players the Royals consider moving if a trade helps them address pitching. If that happens, Caglianone could slide back to first on a more permanent basis.
For now, the Royals know they have a major offensive piece in place. What they decide to do with Caglianone’s glove could shape another key part of the roster conversation heading into 2027.
In Other News...
Royals Face One Costly Arbitration Call In Bigger 2027 Roster Picture
The Royals are already getting an early look at a few pieces that could matter in the next wave of roster construction, and the conversation starts with players in very different stages of their careers. Left-hander Justin Lamkin is still working through mixed results in the Arizona Fall League, a reminder that his long-term path remains more projection than certainty, while the front office is also weighing more immediate decisions on the major league side as it sorts through the depth it may want to carry into 2027.
One of the bigger calls involves second baseman Michael Massey, whose arbitration outlook forces the club to balance cost, role, and upside rather than simply look at the name on the lineup card. The Royals are also kicking around possible pitching fits for the future, including veteran reliever Steven Okert and a reunion with right-hander Luke Weaver, two options that speak to how much the bullpen picture could change by the time that next roster cycle arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Could Lose A Rising Front Office Piece To Houston
The Astros search for a new general manager has pulled in another name with ties to Kansas City, with Royals senior vice president Scott Sharp reportedly among the candidates under consideration. Sharps inclusion is notable for a front office that has been on the rise, and it speaks to how much demand there is for executives who have worked their way into meaningful responsibility around the game.
Houston is casting a fairly wide net, with Braves assistant general manager Ben Sestanovich also in the mix along with Matt Kleine, Josh Barfield and Randy Flores. At the same time, the Astros are moving ahead with another key hire, bringing in Spencer Medick as director of pitching to oversee pitching development, a sign the organization is trying to bolster multiple layers of its baseball operations structure at once. [Read more 🡒]